The Cookie Fairy

The Cookie Fairy I also offer Gluten Free Not your average baking service, The Cookie Fairy is a Cottage Industry Bake Shop and Gift Shop (plus delivery service) combined!

The Cookie Fairy is an artisan bakery delivery service that brings you cookies and desserts, made from scratch with high quality ingredients, heaps of love & a dash of magic! ✨️ Serving Hillsdale College & Hillsdale County, MI. As a lifelong artist, I enjoy creating in many forms. Culinary arts is one of my passions, but I also enjoy painting, crafting, floral arranging, sewing, knitting, and writ

ing to name a few :) Gift items (non baked goods) can be purchased on their own for local delivery, added on to your bakery order, or shipped virtually anywhere.
-Similar to a flower shop, all orders come with an optional gift card that can be customized with a message of your choice to your gift recipient. This service is free of charge. The Cookie Fairy offers Free pick up (message me for pick up locations) or delivery ($5 charge) inside the Hillsdale City Limits. Another thing that makes the Cookie Fairy unique is that I try to use home grown organic or locally based supplies whenever possible. Some of the things I grow myself, I use locally grown organic free range chicken eggs, and in May-October buy produce used for ingredients from Hillsdale's local Farmer's Market. The Hillsdale Natural Grocery Store is another place I support and buy ingredients from. You are truly supporting local business(s) when you place an order. I've been a passionate cook and baker for well over 20 years, but just officially started this small cottage business in May/June of 2021. A website and menu, more branded materials etc. are coming in 2022! So excited about that :) . As a seasoned baker, if you are looking for something you don't see here, please feel free to ask me about it. Chances are I can make it for you. Thank you so much for supporting my small business. It truly means the world to me. God Bless,
Rebekah Ann (you can call me Bekah or "The Cookie Fairy" if you like)

Some of the gift items I offer (this will vary based on season or what's in stock):
- Dried florals/Wreaths made with flowers and herbs I grow in my garden.
- Fresh floral arrangements
- Hand painted home decor/gift items, ornaments, etc.
- Framed prints and greeting cards of my art
- Sewn items (Therapeutic microwavable rice packs , Fun pillow cases, etc)
- Hand Knitted Accessories

** Photos of items will be available on my website or in an album on this page in the future.

A few of the orders that went out this last week!
08/29/2026

A few of the orders that went out this last week!

I had a little bit of vanilla cake batter leftover from the soccer cake I just made, plus leftover homemade raspberry fi...
08/29/2026

I had a little bit of vanilla cake batter leftover from the soccer cake I just made, plus leftover homemade raspberry filling and whipped cream icing leftover from the bridal cake tasting party this week. I made a small 6 inch layer cake for my family to enjoy. I had to show you a photo of the inside so you can see that moist crumb! There is nothing from a box here folks! Just wholesome goodness. This is a popular wedding cake flavor combo I offer.

This soccer themed cake has a 9in.square cake on the bottom in "Life by Chocolate " flavor, with a round vanilla cake st...
08/27/2026

This soccer themed cake has a 9in.square cake on the bottom in "Life by Chocolate " flavor, with a round vanilla cake stacked on top. Made from scratch! I am loving the colors on this cake. Everything is iced in vanilla buttercream.

This little 6 inch boutique layer cake is one of several orders that went out today. These 6 inch cakes come beautifully...
08/26/2026

This little 6 inch boutique layer cake is one of several orders that went out today. These 6 inch cakes come beautifully boxed and are great for smaller gatherings, as they yield 8-10 slices.
Pictured here is a classic carrot cake with cream cheese icing. These are available with or without walnuts, and come in regular or gluten free! Pricing starts at $40 on up, depending on cake flavors, fillings and decorations.

08/25/2026

**Gluten Free Special!!** . I hosted a bridal cake taste testing party for a small group in my garden today and have some freshly made extras to sell at discounted prices.

💖GF carrot cake with cream cheese icing
💖GF white wedding cake with raspberry filling and whipped cream icing
💖GF chocolate cupcakes with your choice of vanilla or chocolate icing

Mix and match a variety of all if wish! Available by the 4 pack($12), 6 pack($15), or dozen.($25)
(Normally 3.50 to 4.00/cupcake for the gf)

Available for delivery or pick up any day this week, starting Tuesday. I also have a variety of regular cookies for sale too.

Contact me here or call or text 517-425-4603 to order.

With recent egg recalls, I thought I would drop a note letting you know that The Cookie Fairy uses all high end brand or...
08/20/2026

With recent egg recalls, I thought I would drop a note letting you know that The Cookie Fairy uses all high end brand organic eggs, or eggs bought from local farmers I know who have their own chickens. None on the recall list . It also gives you some insight on my pricing ;) . Always top of the line quality ingredients here ✨️✨️✨️

This is a busy week for your cookie fairy! I'm baking over 500 cookies this week. I won't reveal where they are headed o...
08/20/2026

This is a busy week for your cookie fairy! I'm baking over 500 cookies this week. I won't reveal where they are headed off to just yet, but will just say that many of you may see them soon ;) . I will also have extras for sale to kick off the new school year with care packages. Pictured here are my grandma's old fashioned sugar cookies (they are so thick and heavy! Large cookies) and snickerdoodles. I'm doing about 175 chocolate chip cookies tomorrow.

Two 12" cookie cakes that went out today. A chocolate chip and an oatmeal chocolate chip. They are both decorated with a...
08/16/2026

Two 12" cookie cakes that went out today. A chocolate chip and an oatmeal chocolate chip. They are both decorated with a combo of Ghirardelli dark chocolate and cream cheese icings. Yum! Not pictured were a box of 2 dz mini pumpkin chocolate chip muffins with cream cheese icing to go with the 75th birthday cookie cake. I forgot to photo those!

A cookie cake I made as a gift for a couple at church 🌻
08/14/2026

A cookie cake I made as a gift for a couple at church 🌻

A deep dish blueberry pie going in the oven. Mmm! 🫐
08/12/2026

A deep dish blueberry pie going in the oven. Mmm! 🫐

Address

Hillsdale, MI
49242

Telephone

+15174254603

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Fairy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category