Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations

Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations In our store you will find a variety of items but our most popular items are our delicious fried pie and award winning cheeses!
(4)

We have many great flavors to choose from! Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Cheesecake
Coconut Cream

Seasonal Flavors:
Bavarian
Chocolate
Rhubarb
Strawberry
Strawberry/Rhubarb
Pecan (September - December)
Pumpkin (October - November)

You spent hours planning the cookout.You bought the burgers.You bought the hot dogs.You bought the drinks.Then someone a...
06/04/2026

You spent hours planning the cookout.

You bought the burgers.
You bought the hot dogs.
You bought the drinks.

Then someone asks...

"Do we have any plates?" 😳

Before the panic sets in, we've got you covered with cups, plates, trays, forks, and spoons for your next cookout, graduation party, reunion, or family gathering.

Stop by Hershberger's Fine Foods and check one more thing off your list.

🍓 Flavor of the Month Has Arrived! 🍓Strawberry Fried Pie is officially our **Flavor of the Month**!Sweet strawberry fill...
06/03/2026

🍓 Flavor of the Month Has Arrived! 🍓

Strawberry Fried Pie is officially our **Flavor of the Month**!

Sweet strawberry filling wrapped in our flaky, golden crust and fried to perfection. Whether you're a longtime strawberry fan or just looking for an excuse to treat yourself, now's the time to grab one.

But don't wait too long—when the month is over, this flavor heads back to the pie vault.

Stop by Hershberger's Fine Foods this week and try our Strawberry Fried Pie while it's here!

Who else thinks strawberry is one of the best summer flavors? ☀️🍓

Don't live close? Get pies delivered to your door! www.hershbergersfinefoods.com

🥤 It's officially cold drink season.Whether you're grabbing lunch, stocking up for the week, or just trying to survive t...
06/02/2026

🥤 It's officially cold drink season.

Whether you're grabbing lunch, stocking up for the week, or just trying to survive the afternoon heat, we've got plenty of options waiting in our drink cooler.

🍑 Bottled teas
🥤 Ice-cold sodas
⚡ Energy drinks
💧 Water and flavored waters
🧃 Juice drinks and more

Stop in, cool off, and grab your favorite—or try something new while you're here.

What's your go-to summer drink?

🌯 Dinner Idea: Build-Your-Own Burrito BowlsSkip the drive-thru and make Chipotle-style bowls at home tonight!Start with:...
06/01/2026

🌯 Dinner Idea: Build-Your-Own Burrito Bowls

Skip the drive-thru and make Chipotle-style bowls at home tonight!

Start with:
✔ Rice
✔ Seasoned meat (beef, chicken, or pork)
✔ Black beans
✔ Fresh veggies
✔ Cheese
✔ Salsa
✔ Sour cream

Set everything out buffet-style and let everyone build their own bowl. Less complaining, more eating.

Need ingredients? Stop by Hershberger's Fine Foods and grab everything you need for burrito bowl night, from fresh produce and meat to cheese, beans, and toppings.

Need a recipe? Find it here: https://hershbergersfinefoods.com/blogs/news/easy-chipotle-style-burrito-bowls

What's your perfect burrito bowl combination?🌯👇

This week marked Piper’s 1 year anniversary at Hershberger’s Fine Foods! 🎉Over the last year, she’s become a big part of...
05/30/2026

This week marked Piper’s 1 year anniversary at Hershberger’s Fine Foods! 🎉

Over the last year, she’s become a big part of the team and we’re thankful for all the hard work, kindness, and smiling face she brings to the store each week.

We appreciate you, Piper — and we’re glad you’ve been part of HFF for the last year! If you see her today, make sure to help us congratulate her!

Some cheeses try really hard to get your attention.Our White Cheddar just quietly shows up, tastes incredible, and lets ...
05/29/2026

Some cheeses try really hard to get your attention.

Our White Cheddar just quietly shows up, tastes incredible, and lets everyone else do the talking. 🧀

Smooth, creamy, and packed with that rich cheddar flavor that keeps people coming back for “just one more slice.”

Perfect on burgers, crackers, sandwiches… or standing at the kitchen counter at 10:30 at night. We don’t judge.

Ice cream season is officially here. 🍦We’ve got waffle cones, sugar cones, and plenty of Mooville ice cream ready to go....
05/28/2026

Ice cream season is officially here. 🍦

We’ve got waffle cones, sugar cones, and plenty of Mooville ice cream ready to go. Which means your “just one scoop” plans are probably in trouble.

Stop in, grab your favorite flavor, and build yourself something worth sitting on the porch for.

There’s just something about a fresh fried pie that feels like home. 🥧Flaky crust, homemade fillings, and fried fresh ri...
05/27/2026

There’s just something about a fresh fried pie that feels like home. 🥧

Flaky crust, homemade fillings, and fried fresh right here at Hershberger’s Fine Foods. Whether you’re loyal to apple, can’t resist chocolate, or always grab whatever flavor catches your eye… we’ve got a case full waiting for you this week.

And for those of you who aren’t local — good news:
You can now order fried pies and cheese online at [www.hershbergersfinefoods.com](http://www.hershbergersfinefoods.com)

Bacon… but make it beef. 🥓🐄We just brought in Godshall’s Beef Bacon, and it’s already turning heads. Real wood smoked, p...
05/26/2026

Bacon… but make it beef. 🥓🐄

We just brought in Godshall’s Beef Bacon, and it’s already turning heads. Real wood smoked, packed with flavor, and a great option for anyone wanting something different from traditional pork bacon.

Perfect for breakfast, burgers, or honestly just because you’re curious what beef bacon tastes like.

Available now at Hershberger’s Fine Foods.

Today we remember and honor the men and women who gave their lives in service to our country. Their sacrifice purchased ...
05/25/2026

Today we remember and honor the men and women who gave their lives in service to our country. Their sacrifice purchased freedoms we should never take for granted.

From all of us at Hershberger’s Fine Foods, thank you to those who served and to the families who gave so much. 🇺🇸

Address

304 Wendell Avenue
Hicksville, OH
43526

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 5:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 5:30pm
Thursday 8am - 5:30pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

(260) 868-7437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category