Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations

Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations In our store you will find a variety of items but our most popular items are our delicious fried pie and award winning cheeses!
(3)

We have many great flavors to choose from! Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Cheesecake
Coconut Cream

Seasonal Flavors:
Bavarian
Chocolate
Rhubarb
Strawberry
Strawberry/Rhubarb
Pecan (September - December)
Pumpkin (October - November)

🥧 Pecan Fried Pies are back for the season!A golden, flaky crust filled with rich, sweet pecan goodness—basically everyt...
09/02/2026

🥧 Pecan Fried Pies are back for the season!

A golden, flaky crust filled with rich, sweet pecan goodness—basically everything you love about pecan pie, only easier to eat in the car.

Stop by Hershberger’s Fine Foods and grab one while they’re here!

Yes, we have Ball jars!Canning season is in full swing, and our canning shelf is ready to help you preserve all that gar...
09/01/2026

Yes, we have Ball jars!

Canning season is in full swing, and our canning shelf is ready to help you preserve all that garden goodness. Stop by Hershberger’s Fine Foods and stock up! 🍅

🍅 Roma tomatoes are here—only $1.25/lb.!🍕 And the school pizzas are finally back in stock!Stop in and grab yours while t...
08/28/2026

🍅 Roma tomatoes are here—only $1.25/lb.!

🍕 And the school pizzas are finally back in stock!

Stop in and grab yours while they last!

Friday at the fair starts with supporting hardworking kids and ends with watching grown adults intentionally destroy per...
08/28/2026

Friday at the fair starts with supporting hardworking kids and ends with watching grown adults intentionally destroy perfectly good cars. That’s what we call balance.

🐄 Junior Fair Livestock Sale — 9 a.m.
🎢 Rides open from 6–10 p.m.
🚗 Demolition Derby — 7 p.m.

If you can, come out and support the young people who have put months of work into their livestock projects. Then stick around for the crashing, smashing and general mechanical bad decisions at the derby.

Stop by Hershberger’s while you’re out and get stocked up for the weekend!

🍓 Flavor of the Week: Strawberry Cheesecake! 🍓Sweet strawberry filling and creamy cheesecake flavor, all wrapped inside ...
08/27/2026

🍓 Flavor of the Week: Strawberry Cheesecake! 🍓

Sweet strawberry filling and creamy cheesecake flavor, all wrapped inside one of our delicious fried pies. Stop by Hershberger’s and grab yours while they last!

🎡 Thursday is KIDS DAY at the Defiance County Fair!There’s plenty happening all day:🐐 Fun goat classes beginning at 8 a....
08/27/2026

🎡 Thursday is KIDS DAY at the Defiance County Fair!

There’s plenty happening all day:

🐐 Fun goat classes beginning at 8 a.m.
🧪 Cool science activities from 10 a.m.–noon
🎨 Coloring, clowns and face painting
🐴 Horsin’ Around from 1–3 p.m.
🎢 Rides from 1–5 p.m. and 6–10 p.m.

In other words, the fair has planned an entire day devoted to keeping your children busy and hopefully sending them home exhausted. Parents, take advantage of it.

And when everyone suddenly remembers they’re hungry again, stop by Hershberger’s for an easy supper!

🐑 MUTTON BUSTIN’ IS TONIGHT! 🤠Get ready to watch some of the bravest little cowboys and cowgirls in the county climb ont...
08/26/2026

🐑 MUTTON BUSTIN’ IS TONIGHT! 🤠

Get ready to watch some of the bravest little cowboys and cowgirls in the county climb onto a sheep and hold on for dear life. The sheep, meanwhile, have one goal: remove their tiny rider as quickly as possible and get back to doing absolutely nothing.

Mutton Bustin’ starts at 7 p.m. at the Defiance County Fair, so stop in to Hershberger’s beforehand and stock up on snacks, drinks and everything you need for a night of cheering, laughing and wondering how a child can be braver than most adults.

Come for the sheep. Stay for the chaos. Leave with a new appreciation for Velcro.

🎉 Help us wish Shelly a very happy birthday! 🎂We’re so thankful to have her as part of our store family and hope she has...
08/26/2026

🎉 Help us wish Shelly a very happy birthday! 🎂

We’re so thankful to have her as part of our store family and hope she has a wonderful day. If you see Shelly today, be sure to wish her a happy birthday! 🥳

🎡 Tuesday at the Defiance County Fair!Tonight’s lineup includes:🐄 NW Show Down Pull-In Beef Show — 6 p.m.🐮 Decorated Ani...
08/25/2026

🎡 Tuesday at the Defiance County Fair!

Tonight’s lineup includes:

🐄 NW Show Down Pull-In Beef Show — 6 p.m.
🐮 Decorated Animal Contest — 6 p.m.
🎶 Live local Christian music at the grandstand — 6 p.m. and FREE
🎢 Rides open from 6–10 p.m.

Basically, you can watch dressed-up livestock, enjoy some music and then pay to be spun around until your fair food becomes questionable. Sounds like a pretty good Tuesday.

Since these events start after we close, stop by Hershberger’s before heading to the fair to stock up on everything you’ll need for the evening!

🎡 FAIR FOOD AT HOME: CHEESY WALKING TACOS 🎡Bring a little fair food home with these easy Cheesy Walking Tacos—loaded wit...
08/24/2026

🎡 FAIR FOOD AT HOME: CHEESY WALKING TACOS 🎡

Bring a little fair food home with these easy Cheesy Walking Tacos—loaded with Tri State Cheese, of course! 🧀

You’ll need:

🌮 1 lb. ground beef
🌮 1 packet taco seasoning
🌮 ⅔ cup water
🌮 1 large bag of Doritos or corn chips
🌮 2 cups shredded Tri State Cheddar or Colby Jack
🌮 Lettuce, tomatoes, salsa, sour cream, jalapeños or your favorite toppings

Directions:

1. Brown the ground beef and drain.
2. Add the taco seasoning and water, then simmer until thickened.
3. Divide the chips among individual bowls or plates.
4. Top with taco meat, plenty of shredded Tri State Cheese and everyone’s favorite toppings.
5. Grab a fork and dig in!

It may not technically be a “walking” taco once you put it on a plate—but it still tastes like fair week! 😄

Stop in and pick up your Tri State Cheese before making yours!

Address

304 Wendell Avenue
Hicksville, OH
43526

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 5:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 5:30pm
Thursday 8am - 5:30pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

(260) 868-7437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category