Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations In our store you will find a variety of items but our most popular items are our delicious fried pie and award winning cheeses!
(1)

We have many great flavors to choose from! Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Cheesecake
Coconut Cream

Seasonal Flavors:
Bavarian
Chocolate
Rhubarb
Strawberry
Strawberry/Rhubarb
Pecan (September - December)
Pumpkin (October - November)

🥧 Who’s ready for some pie?Natalie from Rolling Pin Bakehouse is here at Hershberger’s Fine Foods today, serving up deli...
10/16/2026

🥧 Who’s ready for some pie?

Natalie from Rolling Pin Bakehouse is here at Hershberger’s Fine Foods today, serving up delicious pie samples until 2 PM!

Stop in and try:
🍫 Chocolate Cream
🎃 Pumpkin Spice Cream
🍪 Chocolate Chip

Love what you taste? We carry Rolling Pin Bakehouse pie filling mixes AND pie crusts, so you can take everything home to make your own!

Come grab a sample and find your new favorite! 😋

🍩 Who's coming for DONUT FRIDAY tomorrow?! 🙋‍♀️🍩You folks have certainly made Donut Friday a HIT!We thought we were prep...
10/15/2026

🍩 Who's coming for DONUT FRIDAY tomorrow?! 🙋‍♀️🍩

You folks have certainly made Donut Friday a HIT!

We thought we were prepared the first week, but you bought us out!

So last week, we DOUBLED production… and you bought us out AGAIN! 😳😂

We're back at it tomorrow at Hershberger's Fine Foods, making fresh donuts and hoping we can finally keep up with you!

We absolutely love the excitement you've shown for Donut Friday, and we can't thank you enough!

Come early before they're gone again! 🍩

10/14/2026

🎃 Pumpkin is a vegetable, so pumpkin fried pies are basically a salad… right? 😉

We’ll leave the math to someone else. You just stop in and grab a little fall goodness—and maybe an extra for the ride home. 🥧🍂

🥣 Soup's On at Hershberger's Fine Foods! 🍂Nothing hits the spot quite like a warm bowl of soup on a chilly fall day!Toda...
10/13/2026

🥣 Soup's On at Hershberger's Fine Foods! 🍂

Nothing hits the spot quite like a warm bowl of soup on a chilly fall day!

Today's menu features two delicious favorites:

🌶️ Chili – Hearty, flavorful, and perfect for warming you up!

🧀 Broccoli & Cheese – Rich, creamy, and loaded with cheesy goodness!

Whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch or just craving some comfort food, we've got something that'll hit the spot!

Come hungry and let us take care of lunch today!

🍫 FUDGE, FUDGE, AND MORE FUDGE! 🎃Who says you have to wait until the holidays to enjoy a little fudge?We've got three de...
10/12/2026

🍫 FUDGE, FUDGE, AND MORE FUDGE! 🎃

Who says you have to wait until the holidays to enjoy a little fudge?

We've got three delicious flavors waiting for you at Hershberger's Fine Foods!

🍫 Chocolate – Rich, creamy, and a classic for a reason!

🍪 Cookies & Cream – A sweet combination of creamy fudge and chocolate cookies!

🎃 Pumpkin – A little taste of fall in every bite!

Whether you're sharing with the family or sneaking a piece for yourself (we won't tell 😉), there's always room for a little fudge!

Stop in and grab your favorite today!

📍 Hershberger's Fine Foods | Hicksville, OH

🍩 700 DONUTS. GONE BY 9:30 AM! 🤯Well, you guys did it again!We doubled our donut production from last week, making a who...
10/09/2026

🍩 700 DONUTS. GONE BY 9:30 AM! 🤯

Well, you guys did it again!

We doubled our donut production from last week, making a whopping 700 donuts this morning, and somehow you still managed to wipe us out by 9:30!

We're starting to think we underestimated just how much you all love donuts! 😂

A HUGE thank you to everyone who stopped in and supported us! We're blown away by the response to our first two Donut Fridays.

Now comes the million-dollar question... how many do we make NEXT Friday?! 🍩😂

🎃 Pumpkin season just got a little sweeter!Our homemade Pumpkin Fried Pies are here, and they're packed with all that de...
10/09/2026

🎃 Pumpkin season just got a little sweeter!

Our homemade Pumpkin Fried Pies are here, and they're packed with all that delicious pumpkin spice flavor you love about fall! 🍂

Flaky, golden crust filled with sweet, spiced pumpkin goodness. It's like a little slice of pumpkin pie you can hold in your hand!

Stop by Hershberger's Fine Foods and grab one (or two 😉) while they're here!

Find pies online if you aren't local!

Donut Friday is back for round two! Tomorrow is our second Donut Friday, and we're ready to do it all over again! Fresh,...
10/08/2026

Donut Friday is back for round two!

Tomorrow is our second Donut Friday, and we're ready to do it all over again!

Fresh, homemade donuts made right here in our kitchen. The perfect way to sweeten up your Friday!

$1.50 each
$15 per dozen

Packed a lunch this morning? Neither did we. See you at the deli. 🥪
10/08/2026

Packed a lunch this morning? Neither did we. See you at the deli. 🥪

Address

304 Wendell Avenue
Hicksville, OH
43526

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 5:30pm
Tuesday 7am - 5:30pm
Wednesday 7am - 5:30pm
Thursday 7am - 5:30pm
Friday 7am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

(260) 868-7437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category