Shi’s Custom Cookies

Shi’s Custom Cookies Welcome to Shi’s Custom Cookies! We specialize in custom sugar cookies with royal icing.

These are perfect for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, holidays - or just because life’s sweeter with cookies!

✉️DM to order your custom cookies!
📍Hastings, MI

Apparently I’m not so great at remembering to take pictures of the cookies before they disappear 😅🍪But seriously—thank y...
04/05/2026

Apparently I’m not so great at remembering to take pictures of the cookies before they disappear 😅🍪

But seriously—thank you all SO much for the Easter orders. I appreciate every single one of you 🐣💛

Hope your day is filled with sweets, family, and good vibes!

I may be a couple days late posting, but these cookies were right on time 🍀Hope your St. Patrick’s Day was extra lucky (...
03/19/2026

I may be a couple days late posting, but these cookies were right on time 🍀

Hope your St. Patrick’s Day was extra lucky (and sweet) 💚

Custom cookies for special people and special moments 🌊🐢
03/15/2026

Custom cookies for special people and special moments 🌊🐢

🐰 Easter Presale Reminder!Just ONE WEEK LEFT to order!If you’ve been eyeing something, now’s the time to grab it before ...
03/13/2026

🐰 Easter Presale Reminder!

Just ONE WEEK LEFT to order!
If you’ve been eyeing something, now’s the time to grab it before the presale closes💛

✨ Available Sets✨

🐣A. Paint Your Own (PYO) Large Egg $6 — Comes with paint palette, brush, and instructions card. LIMITED quantities! (ONLY 2 left)
🐣B. Bunny Bait Bag $12 - 10 bites
🐣C. 4 Pack Egg Minis $8
🐣D. Classic Easter 2-Pack $10
🐣E. Custom Name & Carrot 2-Pack $10 — Choose pink or blue for the name

📅 Presale closes: March 20 OR until sold out
📍 Porch pickup in Hastings on April 3rd from 3:00pm-5:00pm

💌 How to order:
Please DM me with the set(s) you’d like and quantity. I’ll confirm availability and send payment information (Venmo or Cashapp) to secure your order.

How cute are these Paint Your Own Eggs and Bunny Bait minis?! 🐰🥕 Limited quantities available! Make sure to grab yours b...
03/10/2026

How cute are these Paint Your Own Eggs and Bunny Bait minis?! 🐰🥕 Limited quantities available! Make sure to grab yours before they’re gone during the Easter presale!🥚

Large Paint Your Own Egg (Comes with paint palette, brush, and instructions card)- $6

Bunny Bait (10 minis) - $12

Mini brunch vibes 🥓🍳🍩☕️💌DM to order your own custom set!
03/08/2026

Mini brunch vibes 🥓🍳🍩☕️

💌DM to order your own custom set!

🌷🐰 Easter Presale is LIVE! 🐰🌷Simple, sweet, and ready for baskets! All sets come packaged and gift-ready. ✨ Available Se...
03/05/2026

🌷🐰 Easter Presale is LIVE! 🐰🌷

Simple, sweet, and ready for baskets! All sets come packaged and gift-ready.

✨ Available Sets✨

🐣A. Paint Your Own (PYO) Large Egg $6 — Comes with paint palette, brush, and instructions card. LIMITED quantities!
🐣B. Bunny Bait Bag $12 - 10 bites
🐣C. 4 Pack Egg Minis $8
🐣D. Classic Easter 2-Pack $10
🐣E. Custom Name & Carrot 2-Pack $10 — Choose pink or blue for the name

📅 Presale closes: March 20 OR until sold out
📍 Porch pickup in Hastings on April 3rd from 3:00pm-5:00pm

💌 How to order:
Please DM me with the set(s) you’d like and quantity. I’ll confirm availability and send payment information (Venmo or Cashapp) to secure your order.

Thank you so much for supporting my small business — it truly means everything! 🤍🐣

Lemon lovers 🍋 this one’s for you! Lemon designs AND lemon flavor — and it’s a market exclusive.I’ll only have a limited...
03/02/2026

Lemon lovers 🍋 this one’s for you! Lemon designs AND lemon flavor — and it’s a market exclusive.
I’ll only have a limited batch, so be sure to stop by the Hastings Market early!

Community Winter Market - 3/7
231 S Broadway
Hastings, MI 49058
10am-2pm

🚨 GLUTEN-FREE FRIENDS, THIS ONE’S FOR YOU 🚨Gluten-free decorated sugar cookies are officially here ✨Same soft bite. Same...
02/28/2026

🚨 GLUTEN-FREE FRIENDS, THIS ONE’S FOR YOU 🚨

Gluten-free decorated sugar cookies are officially here ✨

Same soft bite. Same detailed designs. Same signature look and flavor you know and love — just without the gluten.

If you’ve been waiting for this option (or sending this to your gluten-free bestie 👀), custom orders are now open. 🤍

Testing something special for my gluten-free friends this weekend💛
02/21/2026

Testing something special for my gluten-free friends this weekend💛

02/19/2026

So many satisfying parts to cookie decorating 🍪

Address

Hastings, MI
49058

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shi’s Custom Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category