Cream City Cookies

Cream City Cookies Custom sugar cookies for any event in your life! Cookies for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, graduations, holidays, or just for fun!

And here’s the full set! 💍✨ From the custom bride and groom cookies to the florals, engagement rings, and modern details...
06/04/2026

And here’s the full set! 💍✨ From the custom bride and groom cookies to the florals, engagement rings, and modern details, this bridal shower set came together exactly how I envisioned!

Tell me why making tiny cookie versions of people is suddenly my new favorite thing?! 😂💕 These adorable bride and groom ...
06/03/2026

Tell me why making tiny cookie versions of people is suddenly my new favorite thing?! 😂💕

These adorable bride and groom cookies were inspired by the couple’s save the date artwork and might just steal the show from the rest of the set.

Who’s ready for me to make tiny cartoon cookies of them?!

Give me florals and a gorgeous color palette and I’m a happy cookie decorator. 💕 These blooms were such a fun challenge ...
06/02/2026

Give me florals and a gorgeous color palette and I’m a happy cookie decorator. 💕 These blooms were such a fun challenge to bring to life, and I can’t get over how beautifully the berry and chartreuse colors play together!

I always love the individual cookie designs, but seeing the full set together is my favorite part! Everything just comes...
05/29/2026

I always love the individual cookie designs, but seeing the full set together is my favorite part! Everything just comes together, and this young, wild and three birthday set was no exception! ❤️

Just a bunch of party animals ready to celebrate 🥳 Which animal is your favorite? I love them all but think the rhino is...
05/21/2026

Just a bunch of party animals ready to celebrate 🥳

Which animal is your favorite? I love them all but think the rhino is my favorite! 🦏

Okay but can we talk about this name plaque for a second 😍Using the same exact pink icing with a stencil gives it so muc...
05/20/2026

Okay but can we talk about this name plaque for a second 😍

Using the same exact pink icing with a stencil gives it so much depth and texture. It almost looks like two different shades and I’m obsessed. Being able to use one icing color and consistency to create such a detailed look is a huge cookie decorator win in my book!

I was honored to donate this set for this past weekend’s Period Party, an event helping raise awareness for period pover...
05/19/2026

I was honored to donate this set for this past weekend’s Period Party, an event helping raise awareness for period poverty while collecting products and funds for the Milwaukee Diaper Mission’s period program. ❤️

Did you know 1 in 3 menstruators struggle to afford period products. Period poverty is real, and events like this help make a difference for so many in our community! Thank you to milwaukeeperiodparties for putting all these events together this month!

Last call for Teacher Appreciation cookies!! ✏️🍎 Today is the FINAL day to get your orders in!Pickup will be Wednesday 5...
05/02/2026

Last call for Teacher Appreciation cookies!! ✏️🍎 Today is the FINAL day to get your orders in!

Pickup will be Wednesday 5/6 in Hals Corners, just in time to celebrate all the amazing teachers in your kiddos’ lives! Cookies are the perfect way to say thank you. Both cute and delicious!!

Don’t miss out before I close orders tonight!

www.creamcitycookies.biz/shop

Teacher Appreciation presale is still going strong! Cookie cards are still holding onto the #1 spot for a reason! I’m m...
04/29/2026

Teacher Appreciation presale is still going strong! Cookie cards are still holding onto the #1 spot for a reason! I’m mean that little apple is so cute!🍎✏️

These extra large cookie cards can be personalized with your kiddo’s teacher’s name, and there’s space for them to write why they love their teacher. Such a fun keepsake and yummy treat all in one!

If you’ve been meaning to order, now’s the time before I sell out! Only 5 of these are left!

www.creamcitycookies.biz/shop

Teacher Appreciation orders are rolling in, and you all definitely have favorites 🍎✏️ The Composition Cookie Cards are c...
04/26/2026

Teacher Appreciation orders are rolling in, and you all definitely have favorites 🍎✏️

The Composition Cookie Cards are currently the #1 pick, with the Nerdy Apple close behind in second place! I only have a handful of both designs left, so if one is on your wishlist, don’t wait too long 💛

Order here —> www.creamcitycookies.biz/shop

Address

Hales Corners, WI

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 6pm
Tuesday 9am - 6pm
Wednesday 9am - 6pm
Thursday 9am - 6pm
Friday 9am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

+14149160520

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cream City Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cream City Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category