Carmys Cakes & Hand Crafted Cookies

Carmys Cakes & Hand Crafted Cookies Carmys Cakes has been open since October of 2015, serving hundreds of happy customers in the Columbus/ Grove City areas. Love yourself!

We sell custom cake & cookie orders along with a ton of other tasty treats! Don't pay outrageous amounts of money... but also don't settle for less than you want! Help me help you work out the best cost, design & taste

Sorry we have been a small bit MIA - birthday cookies for our big 3 year old this past October!💙💛🍌 PS. Due to pregnancy ...
02/11/2026

Sorry we have been a small bit MIA - birthday cookies for our big 3 year old this past October!💙💛🍌

PS. Due to pregnancy & the swelling of my feet, I am not currently taking orders BUT will be back in business in June of this year!❤️

Thank you for all your messages regarding orders, they still make my heart so happy!

Halloween Baby Shower cookies!🎃👻💀🧡🖤💚💜
10/09/2025

Halloween Baby Shower cookies!🎃👻💀🧡🖤💚💜

Tea bag cookies 🫖☕️ made for a special new Foster Parents! 🤎 May God bless them and fill their home with peace!💚
09/16/2025

Tea bag cookies 🫖☕️ made for a special new Foster Parents! 🤎 May God bless them and fill their home with peace!💚

CLUELESS summer movie box!💛🖤🎥
07/29/2025

CLUELESS summer movie box!💛🖤🎥

SUMMER MOVIE BOXES! - Sandlot-Clueless-Parent Trap-Jaws-Fried Green Tomatoes-Dirty DancingEvery box comes with 8 cookies...
06/24/2025

SUMMER MOVIE BOXES!
- Sandlot
-Clueless
-Parent Trap
-Jaws
-Fried Green Tomatoes
-Dirty Dancing

Every box comes with 8 cookies! These are ABSOLUTELY perfect for a summer movie night with friends or family!! OR just for you! Movie boxes are always a mystery for designs.

Each box is $30

Order below or send us a message!! These will be available to order every weekend in July!!

06/24/2025

ATTENTION:

Information on Summer movie cookie boxes coming soon!!

Send a message to learn more

Teacher’s Appreciation week was last week!🤗
05/18/2025

Teacher’s Appreciation week was last week!🤗

Cookies for the best 6 year old in the whole universe!!😫😘 love baking for my babie’s birthdays!!
05/18/2025

Cookies for the best 6 year old in the whole universe!!😫😘 love baking for my babie’s birthdays!!

Available starting in April!!! 😍🥳Charcuterie cookie trays!! $35*Board not included! These are absolutely PERFECT for Eas...
03/05/2025

Available starting in April!!! 😍🥳

Charcuterie cookie trays!! $35
*Board not included!

These are absolutely PERFECT for Easter, hosting family, Memorial Day weekend, tea parties, graduation parties & more!

We can also super size these, to fit a bigger gathering for $50!

*Cookies pictured are NOT ours! Only used for inspiration. Our cookies may look slightly different, as all are hand drawn/ designed & cut out.

02/18/2025

Hi friends! March orders are full! Thank you for helping me fill my book! So excited to make your cookies!

I will have Easter season ordering open soon!

Send a message to learn more

VALENTINES 2025!🩷❤️🤍🍓So thankful for ALL the baking I got to do this week/ weekend!🩷
02/15/2025

VALENTINES 2025!🩷❤️🤍🍓
So thankful for ALL the baking I got to do this week/ weekend!🩷

HOW CUTE?! 😍🎉 we love making these!!
02/14/2025

HOW CUTE?! 😍🎉 we love making these!!

Address

Grove City, OH
43123

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Carmys Cakes & Hand Crafted Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category