Fivethumbsup

10/10/2026

We have some special slice flavors in the shop today. White chocolate raspberry, Reese’s pieces, pumpkin, and salted caramel. Hurry in to snag one, because they won’t last long.

10/07/2026

The outdoor Farmer’s Market season is officially over, but Fivethumbsup is just getting started! We are staying open to keep your sweet tooth satisfied. Starting today, our new Wednesday hours are 8:00 AM – 2:00 PM and 5:00 PM – 8:00 PM. Stop on in and treat yourself to our famous cheesecake tacos or a delicious slice!

10/06/2026

Just a few more days to vote!

Discover the Best in Green Bay contest, celebrating the local businesses, restaurants, services and attractions chosen by the Green Bay, WI community.

10/04/2026

Thank you to all the Fivethumbsup followers who always show up when called upon. We asked for your help and you showed up! Thank you for always supporting us!

10/03/2026

We need your help! We have way too much product and would love for you to come in and take some of it off our hands. If you mention this post you will get $2 off $10, $5 off $30 and $10 off $50 or more. We have slices, tacos, minis, balls dipped in chocolate and much more! It a beautiful day to visit our shop.

10/02/2026

Available this weekend we have the following delicious offerings!

1. Extra slices: cherry vanilla bean, bourbon caramel apple, chocolate espresso, and pineapple swirl! $7

2. Samplers: flavors are berry, salted caramel, white chocolate raspberry, and Heath. $50

3. Half of a caramel apple cheesecake. $25

4. New flavor of the month salted caramel bourbon pecan.

10/02/2026

Thank you Stillmank B**r Company for your hospitality hosting this event tonight. I must say theses were some great pairings!! Great b**r with some delicious cheesecake! Let’s do it again soon.