Go Frost Yourself

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Go Frost Yourself You're in the right place. Mollie Recktenwald is now the sole owner since early 2025.
(1)

Are you looking for a bakery that offers kickass cakes, cinnamon rolls and baked goods, made from scratch by women who are overly-caffeinated, mildly sarcastic and hell bent on bringing you the best quality items you can find? Go Frost Yourself is a small batch, made from scratch bakery that specializes in custom cakes, cinnamon rolls and creating deliciously unique desserts for any occasion.

✨🎃3rd annual kids Halloween cupcake competition voting starts this week!!🦇✨We have gone through so many pumpkin coloring...
10/18/2026

✨🎃3rd annual kids Halloween cupcake competition voting starts this week!!🦇✨

We have gone through so many pumpkin coloring sheets, and now we need you to... turn them in lol.

If you have one, bring it in! If you don't have one, print this out and BRING IT IN!

This is the last week for it!

2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester NY
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

10/17/2026

✨Let's talk about Cinnamon Roll Saturday✨

This Saturday we have THREE specialty flavors:

-SAUSAGE GRAVY
this is a buttery, savory roll with seasoned hashbrowns, scrambled eggs and shredded cheddar cheese rolled up on the inside! Then we top it all off with homemade sausage gravy. Quickly become a huge staple, we have it once a month because having it just in rotation every few months wasn't enough.

-PUMPKIN CHOCOLATE CHIP
this is a soft pumpkin roll with chocolate chips mixed into the dough, and a chocolatey spread rolled up on the inside. Then we topped it all off with a little soft chocolate ganache, and a pumpkin spice buttercream AND a soft mini pumpkin chocolate chip cookie.

-CRANBERRY ORANGE SUGAR COOKIE
this is a zesty and fluffy orange dough with fresh cranberries mixed into it and stuffed with a citrus brown sugar, cranberry and once sugar cookie dough. Then we topped it off with a cranberry glaze, orange buttercream and a little cranberry orange sugar cookie!

And as always, our tried and true, our big boys that started it all... you will ALWAYS find our OG's in the case too.

Which ones are you excited for?!

See you soon, and as always... G*Y 🖤

7am-2pm
2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester NY
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

It's chilly out, and we are getting into the fall flavors big time this week!1) pecan pie cheesecake? Are ya kidding me?...
10/15/2026

It's chilly out, and we are getting into the fall flavors big time this week!

1) pecan pie cheesecake? Are ya kidding me?
2) soft, pillowy stuffed pumpkin cheesecake rolls...
3) who the hell needs A.I. when we have Jenn trying to not have her hands shake and Ang on a stepladder?

I have been home sick this week, and not like the cough and sniffles sick ... like... I will have flashbacks of being this sick for years to come lol.

And I have to say, nothing brings me more pride than knowing the team I have at the bakery is doing the damn thing without me.

Do I want to be there? Yes.
Do I miss them? You betcha.

But as always, I'm so proud of the girls that are there holding it down and working together.

If you haven't stopped in this week, please do. The lineup they have this week is off the charts, and CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY IS GOING TO BE NUTS TOO!

-pumpkin chocolate chip
-cranberry orange sugar cookie
-sausage gravy

See you soon, and as always... G*Y 🖤

2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

We are all excited for Cinnamon Roll Saturday, yes, but we are working late and I thought you should know we have some p...
10/10/2026

We are all excited for Cinnamon Roll Saturday, yes, but we are working late and I thought you should know we have some pretty amazing items that are ready first thing in the morning:

✨TIRAMISU SLICES
✨Cream puffs (filled with Italian pastry cream and dipped in semi-sweet chocolate ganache)
✨Matilda cake slices
✨Tres Leches with fresh berries

For Cinnamon Roll Saturday specialty flavors we will have:
-Banana bread 2.0
-Caramel pecan sticky bun
-OG

See you in the morning, and as always... G*Y 🖤

2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester NY
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

It's a friggin' miracle.I remembered to take pictures of some of the cakes that we finished today, this hasn't happened ...
10/09/2026

It's a friggin' miracle.

I remembered to take pictures of some of the cakes that we finished today, this hasn't happened in a bit. So I'm going to need all of you to be a little proud of me.

Also, imagine that drippy chocolate cake with big juicy fresh berries on it, those go on tomorrow morning! 😍

I love them all, but I'm obsessed with the cow.

What's your favorite one?

✨TOMORROW MORNING IS STICKY BUN AND BANANA BREAD ROLLS FOR SPECIALTY FLAVORS!✨

2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester NY
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

Strawberry cheesecake crunch cake slices are going into the case as soon as I cut them and box them up!These are a straw...
10/08/2026

Strawberry cheesecake crunch cake slices are going into the case as soon as I cut them and box them up!

These are a strawberry vanilla cake, with a strawberry cheesecake filling and cheesecake buttercream. Then I made some strawberry cookie momo to cover it with and we added a little chunk of cheesecake for the garnish.

Stop in today until 3pm, we can't wait to see you!

2544 A. Ridgeway Ave, Rochester NY
(585)355-4668
[email protected]

10/07/2026

I want to remind everyone that is either new to us or maybe does not know me personally:

My name is Mollie, I am the owner over here at G*Y. I love this community, I love this business, I love the other businesses that run in the same industry as mine and all small business owners out here just trying to do the damn thing.

But mostly, I love the women that help make my business what it is.

And I have to come on here and say this, because it tends to be around this time of year that we run in to people who assume that they are allowed to speak to the women in this bakery however they want.

I am here to tell you that will never fly with me.

I will ride or die for these women.

No one is perfect, sometimes you have to wait a little bit for your items, sometimes we are already booked for the weekend when you call on Friday for a 3 tiered custom cake for Saturday morning at 7am, sometimes we have off days...

While I will always be open to constructive criticism, because that is how we grow as a business, I will not allow:

-yelling (over the phone or in person)
-talking down to (over the phone or in person)
-posting reviews about how you think my employee did something to your food because they took a minute to go get you an extra side of something
-hanging up on them
-kicking the door when you leave instead of opening it with your hands because we ran out of an item you wanted
-commenting on ANYTHING about the appearance of my employees in a negative or derogatory way
-anything that puts my employees in a negative light mentally, physically or emotionally

The fact that this is even something I have to say is, frankly, kinda nuts.

I don't know if it's the cold snap in weather, stress of the holidays or the world just being wild right now. But I won't allow these women to continue to be spoken to the way that they have been.

WE SELL COOKIES, CUPCAKES, CINNAMON ROLLS, SCONES... friggin' baked goods and happiness frosted and sprinkled with rainbow jimmies.

If you can't act right, you aren't welcome.

And if this rubs you the wrong way, you're exactly who I am talking to.

So that's that, thanks for coming to my TED talk.

Happy Wednesday.

This Saturday is sticky bun and banana bread... set your alarms!

Okay, love you, bye.

Mollie

https://bestof.roccitymag.com/foodCity Magazine for Rochester has us named at art of their "Best of Rochester 2026"!We a...
10/06/2026

https://bestof.roccitymag.com/food

City Magazine for Rochester has us named at art of their "Best of Rochester 2026"!

We are nominated for the bakery category and for the sweets category!

If you have a second today during your scrolling to give us a vote, we would love it 🖤

I'd like to thank every single person who either donated or came in to G*Y on Saturdays and contributed to donations by ...
10/05/2026

I'd like to thank every single person who either donated or came in to G*Y on Saturdays and contributed to donations by buying an OG.

September is always for 🎗️CURE Childhood Cancer Association here at G*Y and we are always so grateful to see people come out and show up in any way for the families in our community in need.

Address

2544 Ridgeway Avenue #A
Greece, NY
14626

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7am - 3pm
Wednesday 7am - 3pm
Thursday 7am - 3pm
Friday 7am - 5pm
Saturday 7am - 2pm

Telephone

+15853554668

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Go Frost Yourself posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Go Frost Yourself:

Shortcuts

Share

Category