P.Betty's Cookies

Call Directions

P.Betty's Cookies Quality, homemade cookies. Hello! My name is Paige Elizabeth, or as my family jokingly refers to me, P.Betty.

When I was born, an elderly lady in the church my dad was pastoring at didn't like my name and so she advised my dad that I should be referred to as P.Betty. Fortunately, my parents did not take her advice but the nickname stuck and is now the name for my new cookie business. I love baking cookies and I've spent many years perfecting some of my favorite recipes. I would love to share my cookies with you and your loved ones!

Long overdue life/cookie update:As many of you have probably noticed, I have really slowed down in the cookie department...
09/23/2026

Long overdue life/cookie update:
As many of you have probably noticed, I have really slowed down in the cookie department. Life has been busy and my time at home has decreased significantly the past year as I’ve spent more time subbing and running around at sports events for my kids. On top of that, I will be starting my Master’s on October 1 and have, therefore, decided to take a break from cookies. There may be periodic stocks of cookies at The Local and you can still message me for orders, but my availability will be limited. I have loved doing cookies for you all these last 5 1/2 years! You have been the best customers and it has been a blessing to be P.Betty’s Cookies!

06/03/2026

New cookies down at The Local:
Brown Sugar Cookie with a Brown Sugar Peach Tea Glaze (yes, it is as delicious as it sounds!) and a Dark Chocolate Raspberry Cookie.
Enjoy!

05/26/2026

The Local is restocked with cookies:
Hazelnut Chocolate Filled & Triple Berry White Chocolate.
Happy Summer break everyone!
☀️🍪 ☀️ 🍪 ☀️ 🍪 ☀️

04/14/2026

The Local has been restocked with cookies!
London Fog and Reese’s Pieces Peanut Butter Cookies.
🍪 Enjoy! 🍪

03/31/2026

The Local has (finally!) been restocked with cookies:
Cadbury Chocolate Egg Cookies.
✝️ Happy Easter! ✝️

Address

Gillette, WY
82716

Telephone

+13072994151

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when P.Betty's Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share