Made by Marty

Made by Marty Handmade treats for your special occasion! Home to the original Waffle Wagon- dessert waffles on a stick! Welcome to my cookie page!

Like and folllw this page for the latest updates on the Wagon’s events and where you can come get a delicous MbM waffle! I’m so glad you’re interested in custom, handmade cookies for your special occasion. All of my cookies are homemade with fresh, high quality ingredients. I strive to make each cookie with love and perfection. Your cookies will come individually packaged, for freshness and ease o

f sharing, at no additional cost to you. They open very easily and can be stored at room temperature for 2-4 weeks and frozen for up to 4 months and stay fresh! All special order cookies will be Classic Almond, unless you request another flavor. I have a 1 dozen minimum for any special order and request a two week advance, if possible. One dozen iced sugar cookies begins at $36 per dozen and will increase with size, amount of colors requested and detail of the design. I have hundreds of cutters and I’m always adding to my collection.

***My cookies may contain ALLERGENS, such as nuts, soy, wheat or dairy. ***

Let me relieve some of your stress and make your special occasion even sweeter! �

Are you or someone you know looking for a unique and delicious dessert for your wedding guests? Made by Marty is availab...
04/14/2026

Are you or someone you know looking for a unique and delicious dessert for your wedding guests? Made by Marty is available to come to your weddings and large parties!

The red Waffle Wagon is available for large events. If you prefer your guests remain inside and you don’t want the Waffle Wagon at your event, I also have a mobile cart the delivers the same, yummy waffles!

Your guests will love it and they’ll be talking about it for years! Now booking for large parties and events, message me for more info! ❤️

Just had to do it! 😝🤷🏼‍♀️
02/03/2026

Just had to do it! 😝🤷🏼‍♀️

Happy New Year! ❤️
01/01/2026

Happy New Year! ❤️

Hi! If you ordered a cookie tray from me, they are on my porch and ready for pick up! My daughter has agreed to restock ...
12/24/2025

Hi! If you ordered a cookie tray from me, they are on my porch and ready for pick up! My daughter has agreed to restock it today. Unfortunately the bows on the lower ones might be a little squished- hopefully not!
Thank you everyone and Merry Christmas to you all! 😃🌲❤️

For those who have reached out about ordering a cookie platter, here are my QR codes. Again, platters must be pre-paid ...
12/15/2025

For those who have reached out about ordering a cookie platter, here are my QR codes. Again, platters must be pre-paid to secure your purchase! If you do not use these and want to pay cash, please message me. Thank you!

All of the treats and none of the work! Here is a sweet treat platter for your Holiday gathering, or office party, from ...
12/15/2025

All of the treats and none of the work! Here is a sweet treat platter for your Holiday gathering, or office party, from my family to yours. What is included:
* 6 peanut butter kiss cookies
* 6 chocolate crinkle cookies
* 6 MbM cut outs with a marbled icing (saves you money and saves my back) you’ll receive 3 trees and 3 stockings.
* 10 pieces of peanut butter fudge
* 6 chocolate chip cookies
* 6 molasses cookies, dipped in white chocolate.

That’s 40 treats for $50. They will be packaged on a platter with a bow (the ones I purchased are too small- ordering larger ones now)
I’ll accept Venmo, PayPal or Cashapp. Prepayment required to secure your order. I’ll only have 10, so they’ll go fast!

Pick up will be in Geneva on 12/24, Christmas Eve.
Thank you! 😃🌲❤️

Holiday cookie tray dropping this week! Keep an eye on my page if you’re interested. I’ll have a very limited number an...
12/06/2025

Holiday cookie tray dropping this week! Keep an eye on my page if you’re interested. I’ll have a very limited number and they will be first come, first served via Venmo, PayPal or Cashapp. Pickup will be anytime on 12/24.
😃🌲❤️

09/28/2025

Line dancing today until 3 in the hangar!

Day two! Come out for some line dancing. Or wine slushies and great food! Stop by the waffle wagon for dessert! 👏🏼
09/28/2025

Day two! Come out for some line dancing. Or wine slushies and great food! Stop by the waffle wagon for dessert! 👏🏼

It's Day TWO of our annual Fall Fest!! Here's the rundown ⬇️

🪓 Axe Throwing 11am - 5pm at Bagg Dare

💃 Line Dancing (11am-3pm) in the Hangar

🎵 Live Music 1-5pm in Courtyard

🛍️ Local Vendors until 3p - , , , Cedar Pine Creations, Sweet Art by Stacey, Peg's Palette, , , Krafterlys, , , ,

🍗 Big Daddy's BBQ Food Truck 1pm-5pm

🧇 Made by Marty Gourmet Waffle Bar

⭐ PLUS, special fall themed Singria cocktails available in Bagg Dare, donuts available to add on to your slushie and our Beer Truck serving up brews by the hangar. See y'all soon!

09/27/2025

Stein holding contest every hour! It weighs approximately 5 pounds, and she said the world record is 45 minutes! So far today, the record is 4 minutes 30 seconds. The winner gets a $25 gift card. 💪🏼

Introducing “The Nikki”. My BFF came up with this idea so that each bite is a different flavor/topping and they’re not ...
09/27/2025

Introducing “The Nikki”. My BFF came up with this idea so that each bite is a different flavor/topping and they’re not all mixed. Ask for “The Nikki” if you’d like your toppings like this! ❤️

Address

Geneva, NY
14456

Telephone

(315) 576-6525

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Made by Marty posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category