Sugar Goat Baking and Grazing Co.

02/09/2026

Our first class back at it was a huge success!!! Thank you to all who attended!!

We are considering doing two classes in March on the 13th from 7-9pm and the 14th from 7-9pm. All new cookies and some fun new techniques! Please reach out to us if you’re interested in possibly reserving a spot. Depending on interest we might offer a weekend afternoon class as well!!

We appreciate the support so much and we were proud and happy to turn another set of lights on in Park Square Saturday evening!!

02/02/2026

Have you missed us? We’ve missed you!
We are booking classes again, and there is no better time than Valentine’s Day! Learn to decorate cookies and leave with a half dozen creations, made by you! Champagne, mocktails and charcuterie are included to elevate your experience.
Message today to reserve your spot; they are limited!
7-9pm
$45
26 Park Square, Franklinville NY

12/01/2024

This morning was a sad day as I locked the door at the bakery for the last time. I want to thank each and every guest who came in to support us during our time at Sugar Goat. I hope that Shaun and Kristen find someone who loves this building just as much as I do. For right now, I will focus on my health and getting to feel better. As for what I will do next…. I will continue on with Be Kind Baked Goods as a cottage bakery until I get my new building completely set up and running. The Sugar Goat building is a great place if anyone is interested in renting it out. It is a beautiful building and it would be great to see someone in there doing something fun with it. Thank You Again Shaun and Kristen! I am grateful for you both.

10/29/2024

We are sorry to say, but yes our Store Front is closed. I am happy to take customer orders up until the day we officially leave the bakery. If you have something in mind, please message us. Also…. If anyone is interested in renting this beautiful place, the amazing owners of the building are looking for someone who can turn it into a dream come true. They would love to chat with you.

09/28/2024

Good morning
We are open today.

We have:

Apple Pie
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin Crème Pie

Breakfast sandwiches available

09/21/2024

Good morning

Lots of variety in our case which includes some gluten free options thanks to OFF DUTY DESSERTS.

Have cannolis and 3 types of cheesecakes

Cherry
Maple Bacon
NY w/ chocolate top with PB frosting
Strawberry cheesecake cup

Have a great day. Stay safe as you venture out to all the rt 16 sales!

09/15/2024

09/15/2024

Happy Sunday
We are open till 4pm today.

We have (5) slices of NY style cheesecake

Will have an assortment of fresh cookies. 1 new fall flavor about to hit the case — PUMPKIN chocolate chip

Items available:

Gluten free brownies
Gluten free cookies (2) left
Sweet and salty harvest mix
Blueberry crumb bars

Made available by our friend at OFF DUTY DESSERTS.

Other items:
Peanut butter crumb cake
Brownies with pb frosting
Apple hand pies
Cinnamon buns
Danishes

Breakfast Sandwiches are available.
As always, FREE COFFEE with any purchase.

We also accept custom orders. We range from a dessert box, event cakes, cupcakes, charcuterie… etc.

Have a great day!!

09/14/2024

English muffin
$2.99 + tax

Bagel
$3.99+tax

$0.50 extra meat

*** FREE coffee with any purchase

09/14/2024

Good morning.

Today we have the following cheesecakes available:

Butter Pecan
Maple Bacon
Cherry NY Style
2 slices of peanut butter

We have a wide variety of things in our case. We have a selection of cookies , hand pies, peanut butter butter crumb cake (who doesn’t like peanut butter?)… we also have a selection of products from OFF DUTY DESSERTS.

Breakfast sandwiches are available

09/13/2024

Gluten Free Chocolate Chips made by Off Duty Desserts! $1 Wow!!!!