Once Upon A Cookie

Once Upon A Cookie Handcrafted sweets just like Grandma used to make- only fancier.
| Cookies, Cakes, and more in SWFL
🍪💌

We are almost ready for our Menu Sneek Peek Pop Up tonight (May 15th!) See you tonight at 6!
05/15/2026

We are almost ready for our Menu Sneek Peek Pop Up tonight (May 15th!)

See you tonight at 6!

💅 She's a little rebel. Unlike her New York cousin, the Basque Cheesecake is crustless, intentional scorched caramlized ...
05/14/2026

💅 She's a little rebel.

Unlike her New York cousin, the Basque Cheesecake is crustless, intentional scorched caramlized top with a creamy melt in your mouth custard!

Good things come to those who wait—and these cookies are having the ultimate "glow up" sleepover. ✨🌙​You might see a tra...
05/13/2026

Good things come to those who wait—and these cookies are having the ultimate "glow up" sleepover. ✨🌙

​You might see a tray of dough chocolate chip cookie dough but behind the scenes, a little bit of science and a lot of magic are happening over the next 42 hours. 🌿

​By slowing things down, we’re letting the starches break down into simple sugars for a deep, toffee-like richness and ensuring every bit of flour is perfectly hydrated for that signature artisan chew. It’s all part of our pivot toward small-batch, intentional treats that taste just as magical as they look.

​Think of it as a beauty rest for your tastebuds. See you on the other side of the oven! 🧚🏼‍♂️🍪

I'll be at this Friday night debuting our new menu and creations starting at 6!❤️Try our new and improved Chocolate Chi...
05/12/2026

I'll be at this Friday night debuting our new menu and creations starting at 6!

❤️Try our new and improved Chocolate Chip Cookies aged to perfection and grab a pack of Cinnamon Rolls to kick start your Saturday Morning!



🍯 Blackberry & Honey-Goat Cheese Cheesecake with a brown butter cookie crust, blackberry jam, and a drizzle of whipped h...
05/09/2026

🍯 Blackberry & Honey-Goat Cheese Cheesecake with a brown butter cookie crust, blackberry jam, and a drizzle of whipped honey

Its tangy and sweet, and oh so creamy!

Thanks Ian for your order!

Every great story has a turning point. 📖✨ For two years, we’ve loved every over-the-top, maximalist moment with you. But...
05/06/2026

Every great story has a turning point. 📖✨

For two years, we’ve loved every over-the-top, maximalist moment with you. But as we grow, we’re finding beauty in the details—trading candy bars for fresh infusions and artisan ingredients.

Our "Recipe Vault" is getting some classics, but our oven is making room for something even more magical.

🍓 The sweet girls are born in......August! Just because a child's birthday falls during summer break shouldn...
05/04/2026

🍓 The sweet girls are born in......August!
Just because a child's birthday falls during summer break shouldn't mean they have to miss out on celebrating with their classmates at school!

Strawberry Cupcakes with Strawberry Frosting (Zero dye) topped with white chocolate 2d roses ready for a princess!

Once Upon a Cookie is really in our roll era. 🍋 Raspberry-Lemom Sweet Rolls available for a limited-time. We take our li...
05/02/2026

Once Upon a Cookie is really in our roll era.

🍋 Raspberry-Lemom Sweet Rolls available for a limited-time.

We take our light and fluffy cinnamon roll dough and fill it with Raspberry-Butter, Lemon Sugar, and a Fresh Raspberry Lemon Compote. Baked till they are a beautiful golden brown, and finished will still warm with Lemon-Cream Cheese Frosting. 🤤

Available to order till May 15th!
🔗 in the Bio under Mama on a Mission

Hey everyone!​I'm coming to you tonight as a Momma on a Mission. My sweet Amelia has worked so hard this year, and after...
04/28/2026

Hey everyone!
​I'm coming to you tonight as a Momma on a Mission. My sweet Amelia has worked so hard this year, and after a rocky 2nd quarter, I promised her that if she pulled up her grades, I would treat her to a Fancy Tea-Lunch—anywhere she wanted.

​Not only did she pull up her grades by 2 letters, she did it in just one quarter! 📚✨ She picked The Cake Bake Shop at Disney’s BoardWalk (like mother, like daughter! 🥰), but I want to go "Big or Go Home" and surprise her with a full magical day at Epcot for the Flower & Garden Festival!

​How you can help:

🤫For this secret mission, I’m offering a Special Limited Princess Spring Menu. Every dollar of profit goes directly toward rewarding her incredible hard work.

​
🔗 Link is in my bio—look for the "Momma on a Mission" tab to place your order-the last day to order before our Cake Bake reservation is May 15th!

​With Love,
Lindsey

Hey everyone!​I'm coming to you tonight as a Momma on a Mission. My sweet Amelia has worked so hard this year, and after...
04/28/2026

Hey everyone!
​I'm coming to you tonight as a Momma on a Mission. My sweet Amelia has worked so hard this year, and after a rocky 2nd quarter, I promised her that if she pulled up her grades, I would treat her to a Fancy Tea-Lunch—anywhere she wanted.

​Not only did she pull up her grades by 2 letters, she did it in just one quarter! 📚✨ She picked The Cake Bake Shop at Disney’s BoardWalk (like mother, like daughter! 🥰), but I want to go "Big or Go Home" and surprise her with a full magical day at Epcot for the Flower & Garden Festival!

​How you can help: For this secret mission, I’m offering a Special Limited Princess Spring Menu. Every dollar of profit goes directly toward rewarding her incredible hard work.
​
🔗 Link is in my bio—look for the "Momma on a Mission" tab to place your order- the last day to order is May 15th!

​With Love,
Lindsey

Address

Fort Myers, FL

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Once Upon A Cookie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category