Old Rugged Bakery made by Sarah Barlow

Old Rugged Bakery made by Sarah Barlow Custom cookies, cakes, cake pops & more made with love. Inspired by my Granny, the “Cookie & Cake Lady” of Cato/Puckett.

Grateful God blessed me with this gift to help celebrate your sweetest moments! 💕

Toy Story birthday goodies for Breland!! 🤠🚀☁️This whole setup was SO much fun to create — from the custom cookies to the...
05/29/2026

Toy Story birthday goodies for Breland!! 🤠🚀☁️

This whole setup was SO much fun to create — from the custom cookies to the matching cake pops that tied everything together perfectly! 💙

We had:
⭐️ Buzz Lightyear
⭐️ Forky
⭐️ Little Green Aliens
⭐️ Woody inspired details
☁️ Andy’s room clouds
🐄 Cow print + sheriff vibes

I especially loved the custom “box” topper with all the toys popping out on the cake, such a fun centerpiece for this theme!

Happy 3rd Birthday, Breland! Hope your day was filled with all the Toy Story fun!! 🎉

“To infinity… and beyond!” 🚀✨

My Hero Academia for this birthday boy!! 💚⚡️I loved creating this fun anime-themed cake for Jonn’s 10th birthday! The br...
05/28/2026

My Hero Academia for this birthday boy!! 💚⚡️

I loved creating this fun anime-themed cake for Jonn’s 10th birthday! The bright green buttercream, sprinkles, and character topper made this one such a fun design to bring to life. 🎂✨

Happy 10th Birthday, Jonn!! Hope your day was PLUS ULTRA! 💥💚

Just look at these sweet little bunnies!! 🩷🐰🥕This set was inspired by Peter Rabbit with a girly twist—soft pinks, floral...
05/27/2026

Just look at these sweet little bunnies!! 🩷🐰🥕

This set was inspired by Peter Rabbit with a girly twist—soft pinks, florals, bows, and all the sweet details!

What made this order even more special was who it was for. A former coworker’s family was celebrating the adoption of their daughter, and I was honored to be a small part of such a beautiful day. 💕

Definitely one of my favorite cookie sets lately! 🥰💕✨

“Every good and perfect gift is from above.” James 1:17 ❤️

How fun is this colorful birthday cake?! 🌈🎂Every single “sprinkle” on this cake was hand piped in buttercream! 💙💚💛🧡❤️Thi...
05/26/2026

How fun is this colorful birthday cake?! 🌈🎂

Every single “sprinkle” on this cake was hand piped in buttercream! 💙💚💛🧡❤️

This cheerful design was made for a sweet 3-year-old and is proof that sometimes the most playful cakes are also the most fun to create. From the rainbow borders to the colorful buttercream confetti, this cake was full of birthday joy!

Happy 3rd Birthday! 🥳✨

“Every good and perfect gift is from above.” James 1:17 ❤️

I mean… how cute is this Silly Goose theme?! 🥹🪿This sweet little set was for Owen’s 1st birthday and included a two-tier...
05/25/2026

I mean… how cute is this Silly Goose theme?! 🥹🪿

This sweet little set was for Owen’s 1st birthday and included a two-tier cake, matching cookies, cake pops (which somehow escaped without a photo 🤦🏼‍♀️), and a smash cake!

The big cake was vanilla on top and chocolate on the bottom, and the smash cake was chocolate because every birthday boy deserves cake and chocolate on his face. 😆

One dozen of the cake pops were made gluten-free so guests with dietary restrictions could enjoy a sweet treat too! ❤️ I love being able to accommodate specialty diets whenever possible.

And can we talk about those soft blue and sage colors? 😍🩵💚

Happy 1st Birthday, Owen! 🪿🎉

“Commit your work to the Lord, and your plans will be established.” Proverbs 16:3 ✨

Such a dreamy cake for a 20th birthday celebration 🩷🦋✨ Soft florals, delicate butterflies, and all the dainty details m...
05/24/2026

Such a dreamy cake for a 20th birthday celebration 🩷🦋✨

Soft florals, delicate butterflies, and all the dainty details made this one feel so elegant and feminine. I absolutely loved how light and pretty everything came together 🤍

“She is clothed with strength and dignity; she can laugh at the days to come.”
— Proverbs 31:25

I loved how this Hot Wheels cake turned out!! 🏁🔥 Such a fun theme for a little boy who loves fast cars and bright color...
05/23/2026

I loved how this Hot Wheels cake turned out!! 🏁🔥
Such a fun theme for a little boy who loves fast cars and bright colors 💙

From the racing flags to the flames and little car details, this cake was such a fun one to create!

But whew… this one also came with a humbling baker moment 😅 After the cake was already at the party setup had started, the customer messaged me that I had accidentally typed Rowan instead of Roman on the edible image. ONE little letter and I so wish I could’ve just swapped it around 🤦🏼‍♀️😭

As devastating as it feels when you work so hard on something, moments like this remind me that none of us are perfect — and grace matters more than perfection 🤍

“My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.”
— 2 Corinthians 1

Simple, sweet, and sprinkled with fun 💙✨ This little smash cake and cupcake set was for the sweetest first birthday cel...
05/23/2026

Simple, sweet, and sprinkled with fun 💙✨

This little smash cake and cupcake set was for the sweetest first birthday celebration! I absolutely loved the soft blue, colorful sprinkles, and classic buttercream swirls 🧁🎂

And these treats were funfetti inside and out which made them even more fun for a first birthday celebration 🌈✨

“Taste and see that the Lord is good.”
— Psalm 34:8

Sugar cookie cake + a crawfish holding a ring?! YES PLEASE 😍🦞💍 This may just be one of the cutest engagement themes eve...
05/22/2026

Sugar cookie cake + a crawfish holding a ring?! YES PLEASE 😍🦞💍

This may just be one of the cutest engagement themes ever! I loved bringing this fun and whimsical idea to life with all the sweet little details ✨

Pinch me… we’re engaged!! ❤️

“He has made everything beautiful in its time.”
— Ecclesiastes 3:11 🤍

Another Mississippi Sports Medicine cake in the books! ❤️💙 I loved how fun and creative this one turned out for the Fir...
05/22/2026

Another Mississippi Sports Medicine cake in the books! ❤️💙

I loved how fun and creative this one turned out for the First Impressions Team! From the bold colors to the custom logo details, this cake was such a fun one to bring to life ✨

“Work willingly at whatever you do, as though you were working for the Lord rather than for people.”
— Colossians 3:23 🤍

Address

Florence, MS
39073

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 2pm

Telephone

(601) 813-6238

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old Rugged Bakery made by Sarah Barlow posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category