Sweetie Pies

Sweetie Pies Sweetie Pies bakes lovingly handcrafted pies in Door County, WI. Like our page to follow along, and come see us sometime!

Door County's favorite pie by the slice. Full size baked pies require a reservation at least one day in advance. Arrangements to pick-up frozen pies on days we're closed can generally be made.

Come on in TODAY, Sat April 4th. We’re open until 4pm. Plenty of delicious goodies for your family or your hosts, baked ...
04/04/2026

Come on in TODAY, Sat April 4th. We’re open until 4pm. Plenty of delicious goodies for your family or your hosts, baked and ready to go OR get FROZEN full size pies in 30 different flavors to bake at home. Imagine the smell when your guests arrive 😋.

03/31/2026

Text 920-646-2743 or call 920-868-2743.

Sweetie Pies bakes lovingly handcrafted pies in Door County, WI. Like our page to follow along, and come see us sometime!

We’re OPEN this week & it’s the last week to get “fresh yesterday” slices for only $4.75!!Come take advantage of our bes...
03/25/2026

We’re OPEN this week & it’s the last week to get “fresh yesterday” slices for only $4.75!!
Come take advantage of our best deal before it disappears forever.
10-2 Wed & Thurs
10-4 Fri & Sat
10-1 Sun

EXTRA hours this week!! Stop by for delicious PIE!!
03/22/2026

EXTRA hours this week!! Stop by for delicious PIE!!

03/14/2026

Happy Pi Day!! You should probably celebrate with Pie! We’re open 10-4 today Sat 3/14.
We will be CLOSED due to weather tomorrow! 🥧💕

01/10/2026

Whelp, I’m throwing in the towel. Gotta get myself home in this low riding front wheel drive minivan. Closing at 2pm.

EDIT: SOLD!!!!
01/04/2026

EDIT: SOLD!!!!

12/29/2025

Due to this morning’s inclement weather and continuing high winds, Sweetie Pies is closed today 12/29. We are planning on being open tomorrow & Wednesday 10-2. To reserve your baked full size pie, text us at 920-646-2743.

Happy New Year! We’re OPEN extra hours. Come over and grab a truly homemade Door County treat. Get your cinnamon sugar p...
12/27/2025

Happy New Year! We’re OPEN extra hours. Come over and grab a truly homemade Door County treat. Get your cinnamon sugar pie crust cookies. Shop our DoCo gifts sale: 20% off.
12/27-12/31
Saturday 10-4
Sun-Wed 10-2
Call to reserve baked pies 920-868-2743 or text 929-646-2743.

We're OPEN!!! 12/22 and 12/23 10am-2pm You're not too late to RESERVE your pie for pick up tomorrow. Call 920-868-2743 o...
12/22/2025

We're OPEN!!! 12/22 and 12/23 10am-2pm You're not too late to RESERVE your pie for pick up tomorrow. Call 920-868-2743 or text 920-646-2743.
OR pick up a frozen pie, gift cards and Door County merch.
Give the gift of nostalgia this year.

EDIT: Again with the awesomeness!! I have several great explanations on how to test parts as well as how to connect the ...
12/02/2025

EDIT: Again with the awesomeness!! I have several great explanations on how to test parts as well as how to connect the wiring to the new terminals and Bonus: I got one of the world’s bestest of friends coming over yo show me in person tomorrow!!! Thanks again SP followers & my community! 💕🥧

Friends, you were so helpful when I didnt have the parts!! Now I do and I need your help again😅

Note: I’m sure glad I purchased the element along with the thermostat “just in case”. It snapped as I removed the plate.

Help me with some vocabulary so I can you tube this. I’ve never attached wiring before. What should I search? What are these little connectors called?

Address

9106 Highway 42
Fish Creek, WI
54212

Opening Hours

Saturday 10am - 4pm
Sunday 10am - 1pm

Telephone

(920) 868-2743

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sweetie Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share