Simply Sugar & Spice LLC

05/31/2026

Graduation cookies aren’t just for high school! From preschool to nursing school and everything in between, celebrate with personalized cookies 😁

05/30/2026

Grad season is in full swing! I have a few more openings in June if your grad party needs a personalized touch 🙂

05/24/2026

EDIT- SOLD
Available today: half price cake pops!

1.5 dz ugly vanilla cake pops 😂
approximately half blank and half with messed up prints (but they all taste good!)

regular price $42, today’s price $21

05/14/2026

Available today:

1 dz buckeyes $10 *SOLD

1.5 dz buckeyes $15 *SOLD

1 dz chocolate gooey butter cookies $10

1.5 dz chocolate gooey butter cookies $15

05/09/2026

Available now:

1 dz chocolate peanut butter cupcakes $33 *SOLD

8x8 pan of brownies $17 *SOLD

2 dz chocolate gooey butter cookies $10/ dz

(2) 4 packs chocolate peanut butter cupcakes $12 each

*pick up in Farmington tomorrow morning (Sunday)

05/07/2026

Ohhh my heart! ♥️
I can take a verrrry limited amount of these sweet photo cookies for Mother’s Day. Message me asap if you need a last minute gift! $5 each
*EDIT- SOLD OUT*

05/01/2026

Long time, no post 🫣

It’s taken me a little time to get into a new groove baking from home, but I’m officially back at it! You’ve kept me busy with custom orders over the past few months—thank you! I’m excited to now start offering some ready-made desserts as well.

To claim an item, simply comment or pm with your email address. I’ll send an invoice that can be paid online. The first person to claim an item will have one hour to complete payment. If the invoice isn’t paid within that time, it will be canceled and offered to the next person in line.

I have a few desserts available today:

2 dz chocolate gooey butter cookies
$10/ dz

SOLD* 1 dz cupcakes- half chocolate, half white wedding, all vanilla buttercream
$30

1 dz oatmeal raisin cookies
$10

SOLD* 1 dz chocolate chip m&m cookies
$15

SOLD* 1 dz chocolate chip cookies
$15

P.S. As always, text subscribers get first dibs- if you’d like a heads up too text VIP to 573-670-4070 then reply YES to the confirmation text!

04/02/2026

EDIT 2: There are 5 cookies left!

EDIT: I was able to make a few more!

I have 2 extra cookies ready to be personalized and printed for Easter! $5 each, pick up is Saturday 🙂

02/11/2026

Today’s the last day to order- I can take a few more!

paint-your-own Valentine cookies are now available for preorder! $5 each includes one large cookie and one mini paintbrush- your choice of design ⬇️ Orders close Wednesday!

02/08/2026

paint-your-own Valentine cookies are now available for preorder! $5 each includes one large cookie and one mini paintbrush- your choice of design ⬇️ Orders close Wednesday!