Sweets by Sarah Bakery

05/30/2026

Happy Sourdough & Cinnamon Roll Saturday! 🍞

We are open normal hours 7-4 today! 😊

05/28/2026

You already know, it’s Thursday! 🍪

We are fully stocked and ready for a busy day!

Bakery is OPEN 7-1
&
We will be at Wolcott Farmers Market 1:30-5

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven!

05/26/2026

A few special orders! ✨

•Vintage piped 2 tiered baby shower cake 🎂
•Black forest cake 🍰
•Chocolate peanut butter cake 🥜 🍫
•Cinnamon roll order for Sterling Campground! ⛺️

05/23/2026

Happy Saturday & Memorial Day Weekend! 🇺🇸

We are OPEN 7-4 today! Stop in to grab your sweets and enjoy our covered porch! ☀️

05/22/2026

Happy Memorial Day weekend from all of us at Sweets By Sarah Bakery 🇺🇸✨

We’re fully stocked with all your weekend favorites including sourdough bread, fresh scones, cookies, refresher drinks, smoothies, acai bowls & so much more! 🍪🥤🍓

Be sure to swing in this weekend and grab the goods before they’re gone! We can’t wait to see you 🍪

05/21/2026

Happy Thursday! We are back for Farmers Market Season! 🍓

Stop in and see us in Wolcott from 1-5 today!
🍪

05/18/2026

A few special orders! 🎂

•Cakes
•Cupcakes
•Cake pops
•Rice Krispies
•Mini cheesecakes

05/17/2026

What a beautiful day in Fair Haven! ☀️

BEACH BUCKETS 🏖️ - grab your favorite iced drink in a to go bucket!

We are OPEN 7-3! 🍪

05/15/2026

Fresh baked Coconut Macaroons are available today at Sweets By Sarah Bakery 🥥✨

Crispy on the outside, soft and chewy in the center — the perfect sweet treat to pair with your morning coffee or afternoon pick-me-up! Stop in before they’re gone!

We are OPEN 7-4! ☀️

05/14/2026

We are SO excited to announce that we are stop #22 for the Sweet Treat trail of 2026! 🍪

The Finger Lakes Sweet Treat Trail 🍦is back and sweeter than ever!
🍨From ice cream and baked goods to honey, maple syrup, and farm-fresh favorites, this self-guided trail is your excuse to explore Cayuga County one delicious stop at a time.
📸 Show us your Sweet Treat Trail adventure!
Snap a photo at your favorite stop, scan the qr code on the STT poster, and enter to win a sweet prize!
🍦For more information and to download a brochure visit: https://www.tourcayuga.com/eat-drink/restaurants/sweet-treat-trail/

Auburn Bagel Company
Cafe 108
Combgrown Mead
MAZZA Cravings
Morgan's Half Acre Produce
King Ferry Corner Store
Northville Arts Center King Ferry
Potters Farm to Fork
Smokey Hollow Maple Syrup
Sweets by Sarah Bakery
Reese's Dairy Bar
White Rabbit Roasting Company
Taste NY at the NYS Equal Rights Heritage Center