What are the opening hours?

Thursday 7am - 4pm Friday 7am - 4pm Saturday 7am - 4pm Sunday 7am - 3pm

Sweets by Sarah Bakery

Home
United States
Fair Haven, NY
Sweets by Sarah Bakery

Call Directions Website

Scratch made fresh baked goods including specialty cakes, cookies, breads, pies, pastries , muffins, cinnamon rolls and much more!

Mobile order - cash.app/$sweetsbysarahbakery

🥇VOTED #1 Bakery in the FLX 2024
🥇 VOTED #1 Bakery in the FLX 2025

10/17/2026

☀️ Happy Saturday! ☀️

It’s 🍃🍁🍂LEAF PEEPER WEEKEND! 🍂 🍁🍃
Stop in to get your card punched! We are stop #3

Cookie sale : We have extended our 5 regular cookies for $5 for the rest of the month to celebrate our ✨ 5 year anniversary ✨ 🍪

Bread : We have classic white bread and everything bread! 🍞

Sunday 🏈 :
🍿 Homemade Popcorn sale 🍿
1 bag for $6
2 bags for $10
GO BILLS ❤️💙

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven
📞 315-947-2135

10/16/2026

We have fresh pumpkin bread 🎃

10/15/2026

Thursday is here already! 🍂

It’s Leaf Peeper weekend Saturday and Sunday! We are stop #3 🍪

Scones lovers: We have BOTH maple cinnamon scones & Pumpkin scones! 🤤 Two of my favorites!

We are OPEN normal hours 7-4 today!

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven
📞 315-947-2135

10/14/2026

A customer favorite is coming back this week!! 🤩

Our DELICIOUS peanut butter buckeye cookies 🤤

Available Thursday - Sunday / normal hours! 🍪

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven
📞 315-947-2135

10/10/2026

Happy Saturday from Sweets By Sarah Bakery!! 🤩

Our bakery cases are FULL of cookies and sweet treats today! 😍🍪 Whether you’re craving something chocolatey, a classic cookie, or a little something sweet to go with your morning coffee, we’ve got you covered!

✨ CLYDE FRIENDS:✨ We will be a vendor tonight for Terror Fest! Stop on down to see us 🍞 We will have sourdough bread, regular yeast breads, cookies, brownies & more! 🍪

Bakery is OPEN normal hours 7-4! 😊

10/09/2026

We have bread! 🍞

🎃 Pumpkin bread
🍞 Classic Sourdough
🥖 Everything Sourdough

10/08/2026

☀️Happy Thursday! ☀️

We have NEW pumpkin muffins 🎃 🤤

Lots of other delicious sweets ready for you!

We are OPEN normal hours 7-4 today 😊

09/29/2026

🎉🍰 5 YEARS OF SWEETNESS! 🍰🎉
Celebrating 5 years of being open on Friday October 2nd!

I can hardly believe it… Sweets By Sarah Bakery is celebrating 5 YEARS in business! 💕

Five years of early mornings, long days, countless cookies, cinnamon rolls, sourdough loaves, cakes, acai bowls, coffee, and SO many sweet memories. What started as a dream has grown into something I am incredibly proud of.

But the best part of these five years has been YOU — our amazing customers, friends, family, and community who have supported us, cheered us on, shared our posts, recommended us to others, and continued to walk through our doors. ❤️

To celebrate 5 years we are offering 4 days of AWESOME specials! (Thursday - Sunday this week only)

• 5 regular size cookies for $5! 🍪
• 5% off your purchase of $50 or more
• 2 muffins for $5
• Large iced coffee for $5 ☕️

With love & gratitude,
Sarah & the Sweets By Sarah Bakery family 💕

We are OPEN normal hours this week
• Thursday 7-4
• Friday 7-4
• Saturday 7-4
• Sunday 7-3

09/25/2026

Fresh warm sourdough 🤤

Cooling now and will be ready to bag up soon! Snag one while they’re available! 🍞

Open 7-4 today! 🍪

09/24/2026

Happy Thursday! 🧁

We are back open for the week! Stocked with all of your favorite sweets, drinks, acai bowls, cinnamon rolls & more! 🍪

OPEN 7-4 today! 🍞

Address

591 Main Street
Fair Haven, NY
13156

Opening Hours

Thursday	7am - 4pm
Friday	7am - 4pm
Saturday	7am - 4pm
Sunday	7am - 3pm

Telephone

+13159472135

Website

http://sweetsbysarahbakery.com/, http://cash.app/$sweetsbysarahbakery

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sweets by Sarah Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Fair Haven?