Sweets by Sarah Bakery

Sweets by Sarah Bakery Scratch made fresh baked goods including specialty cakes, cookies, breads, pies, pastries , muffins, cinnamon rolls and much more!

Mobile order - cash.app/$sweetsbysarahbakery

🥇VOTED #1 Bakery in the FLX 2024
🥇 VOTED #1 Bakery in the FLX 2025

08/31/2026

🍂SWINGING BACK INTO FALL/WINTER HOURS! 🍂

As we head into the new season, we’re switching back to our fall/winter schedule starting this week!

📅 Monday – CLOSED
📅 Tuesday – CLOSED
📅 Wednesday – CLOSED

✨ Thursday – 7 AM–4 PM (Previously 7-1)
✨ Friday – 7 AM–4 PM
✨ Saturday – 7 AM–4 PM
✨ Sunday – 7 AM–3 PM

We can’t wait to see you Thursday through Sunday for all your favorite Sweets By Sarah Bakery goodies! 🥐🍪☕️🍓

Thank you for continuing to support our small business!

Happy Thursday! 🍪 We are OPEN with all of your favorites! Scones, mega cookies, pie bars, cinnamon rolls and more! 🧁Gran...
08/27/2026

Happy Thursday! 🍪

We are OPEN with all of your favorites!

Scones, mega cookies, pie bars, cinnamon rolls and more! 🧁

Granola , popcorn and oatmeal is also fully stocked!

OPEN 7-4
📞 315-947-2135
📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven!

It’s mega cookie week here at Sweets By Sarah Bakery! 🍪 Mega cookies flavors:•Cookie monster (Oreo stuffed)•Gingerdoodle...
08/20/2026

It’s mega cookie week here at Sweets By Sarah Bakery! 🍪

Mega cookies flavors:
•Cookie monster (Oreo stuffed)
•Gingerdoodle white chip - NEW
•Peanut butter buckeye - customer favorite!
•Loaded Oreo - NEW
•Cosmic

We also have maple cinnamon scones, blueberry scones, muffins, an array of cookies, pie bars & more! The bakery is OPEN 7-4 today! 🧁

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven, NY!

Our fresh homemade sourdough is ready for you! 🍞
08/14/2026

Our fresh homemade sourdough is ready for you! 🍞

✨ Another beautiful wedding! ✨📍 The Fallbrook House , Canandaigua Check out this beautiful spread of cookies, cupcakes, ...
08/14/2026

✨ Another beautiful wedding! ✨

📍 The Fallbrook House , Canandaigua

Check out this beautiful spread of cookies, cupcakes, dessert cups, cake pops , bars and more!
This cake was a beautiful white scalloped design. Each scallop hand piped and shaped! 🥂

A beautiful venue right on Canandaigua lake!

Wedding set up and delivery #2 of 2 for 8/1/26! 💕

✨ Wednesday Wedding Post! ✨📍 Colloca Estate Winery Check out this beautiful array of desserts! From mini cookies to dess...
08/12/2026

✨ Wednesday Wedding Post! ✨

📍 Colloca Estate Winery

Check out this beautiful array of desserts! From mini cookies to dessert cups, cake pops & French macarons this dessert bar included something for everyone including gluten free items! 🍪

This was wedding delivery/set up #1 of 2 for 8/1/26!

🍪✨ A SNEAK PEEK at this week’s specialty cookie lineup! ✨🍪We’ve got some seriously delicious flavors coming your way thi...
08/11/2026

🍪✨ A SNEAK PEEK at this week’s specialty cookie lineup! ✨🍪

We’ve got some seriously delicious flavors coming your way this week! 😍

🥜 Peanut Butter Buckeye Cookie
🌌 Cosmic Cookie
🍋🫐 Lemon Blueberry Cookie

Open normal hours Wednesday through Sunday! ☀️

Recent special orders! 🍰
08/10/2026

Recent special orders! 🍰

A little history on our building! Fair Haven railroad days are today! 🚂 Stop into town to read all about the old railro...
08/08/2026

A little history on our building! Fair Haven railroad days are today! 🚂 Stop into town to read all about the old railroad

🌸 Happy Saturday from beautiful Fair Haven,NY! 🌸We’re OPEN 7–4 today and stocked up with all the good stuff! 🥐🍞🍪✨ Fresh ...
08/08/2026

🌸 Happy Saturday from beautiful Fair Haven,NY! 🌸

We’re OPEN 7–4 today and stocked up with all the good stuff! 🥐🍞🍪

✨ Fresh yeast breads -Plain, Everything, Cinnamon & Seeded oat
🍞 Sourdough bread - Plain
🧁 Lots of sweet treats
🥤 Refreshing drinks
💜 Acai bowls
☕ Coffee & more!

Come see us and grab something delicious for your Saturday!

📍 591 Main Street in Fair Haven, NY!

Address

591 Main Street
Fair Haven, NY
13156

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7am - 1pm
Thursday 7am - 4pm
Friday 7am - 4pm
Saturday 7am - 4pm
Sunday 7am - 3pm

Telephone

+13159472135

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sweets by Sarah Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category