https://www.facebook.com/101071199063926/

The Cookie Jar

Directions

Custom decorated sugar cookies and other sweet treats in Evansville, WI

10/11/2026

Evansville! Thank you so much for coming down to the market yesterday. I absolutely loved seeing you all! And I have no words for the fact that I had people waiting in line for ME and my cookies! 🥹 It’s unreal.
Thank you thank you thank you! ❤️

✨327 W Liberty St✨

I have leftovers available on the porch!
Stop by any time today, I apologize I don’t have any bags for you to put your goodies in, I ran out yesterday!

The cinnamon roll cookies weren’t getting much attention yesterday until I started cutting some up for samples. They pack a cinnamon punch in a nice buttery little cookie.

10/10/2026

Come on down! I’ll be here until 8pm! Can’t promise all the cookies will be 😉

10/09/2026

I can’t decide which I like more, the white or the orange! I’m so excited for tomorrow!!

Hope to see you at the Monster Mash Makers Market, 3pm - 8pm! Check out what other great vendors you can expect to see via the link below!

https://www.facebook.com/share/1JFucAo8gS/?mibextid=wwXIfr

10/05/2026

68.

I made 68 lbs of cookie dough in the last 24 hours.

Now all I have to do is roll it out, ball it out, bake them, decorate them, and package them.

Oh, and make a batch of mini cakes.

That’s it 😅

See you Saturday 3pm - 8pm! Lots going on down town Evansville, check it out!

10/04/2026

🎃👻 I’m so excited to start baking for the Makers Market this Saturday!!

🍎I’ll have my Caramel Apple Toffee Pudding cookies! They are made with honey crisp apples and pudding, topped with caramel and toffee! 🍂 You don’t want to miss these!

☀️ Also the weather looks BEAUTIFUL! Hope to see you there! 🍁

09/26/2026

Remember these?

☕️Pumpkin Chai Oatmeal Crème Pie Sandwiches 🎃

Last year you all bought them faster than I could make them!! They will be available again at the Makers Market on October 10th on Main Street! Come see all the fall and Halloween treats I’ll have baked up, and check out all the other wonderful local vendors too!

💜

09/24/2026

Work in progress…..

08/29/2026

So THAT just happened 🤦‍♀️😭

08/28/2026

I was able to make a few cookies! 😏

I *can* accommodate pick ups for this evening, but I prefer pick ups for Saturday or Sunday.

🧁Buttercream stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker cookies $5/each

🍫Peanut Butter stuffed Chocolate cookies $5 each

⭐️Rice Krispie Marshmallow cookies $3/each

‼️LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE
MESSAGE ME TO ORDER ‼️

ETA: Rice Krispie Marshmallow are SOLD OUT

08/26/2026

All right! I heard you loud and clear, ya’ll want cookies! 🫡 I will bake as much as I can, and hope to have them available for pick up Friday and Saturday….but it’s all up to little Junie B 😅

I plan to have the following :

🐘Buttercream stuffed Circus Animal cookies $5 each
🍫Peanut Butter stuffed chocolate cookies
🌟Marshmallow stuffed Rice Krispie cookies

The last two I have not made yet, I’m not sure how big I will make them. I typically make them 3oz and my cookies are always priced at $1/oz. Stay tuned as I get some examples baked to figure out size, price, and get some photos!

Address

Evansville, WI
53536

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed bakery in Evansville?