The Cookie Jar

The Cookie Jar Custom decorated sugar cookies and other sweet treats in Evansville, WI

So THAT just happened 🤦‍♀️😭
08/29/2026

So THAT just happened 🤦‍♀️😭

I was able to make a few cookies! 😏 I *can* accommodate pick ups for this evening, but I prefer pick ups for Saturday or...
08/28/2026

I was able to make a few cookies! 😏

I *can* accommodate pick ups for this evening, but I prefer pick ups for Saturday or Sunday.

🧁Buttercream stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker cookies $5/each

🍫Peanut Butter stuffed Chocolate cookies $5 each

⭐️Rice Krispie Marshmallow cookies $3/each

‼️LIMITED AMOUNTS AVAILABLE
MESSAGE ME TO ORDER ‼️

ETA: Rice Krispie Marshmallow are SOLD OUT

All right! I heard you loud and clear, ya’ll want cookies! 🫡 I will bake as much as I can, and hope to have them availab...
08/26/2026

All right! I heard you loud and clear, ya’ll want cookies! 🫡 I will bake as much as I can, and hope to have them available for pick up Friday and Saturday….but it’s all up to little Junie B 😅

I plan to have the following :

🐘Buttercream stuffed Circus Animal cookies $5 each
🍫Peanut Butter stuffed chocolate cookies
🌟Marshmallow stuffed Rice Krispie cookies

The last two I have not made yet, I’m not sure how big I will make them. I typically make them 3oz and my cookies are always priced at $1/oz. Stay tuned as I get some examples baked to figure out size, price, and get some photos!

I have someone who wants a few circus animal cookies, but I’d have to make a whole batch. Anyone else interested in some...
08/23/2026

I have someone who wants a few circus animal cookies, but I’d have to make a whole batch. Anyone else interested in some? They would be available later this week!

I’m also thinking of trying a new Rice Krispie marshmallow cookie recipe…a Costco copy cat recipe, thoughts?

🎉Last day for this weekends porch pop up!!⏰Stop by now until 6 pm🏠327 W Liberty St 🦄I did restock the Frosted Animal Cra...
07/25/2026

🎉Last day for this weekends porch pop up!!

⏰Stop by now until 6 pm

🏠327 W Liberty St

🦄I did restock the Frosted Animal Cracker cookies, but there are still only 9. If you missed out this weekend let me know and I can certainly make more another day!! I’m more than happy to make whatever you guys want 😊
There are only a few of each mini cake left as well, but I did restock the S’mores cookies!

❤️Thank you everyone who has preordered and already stopped by! I really appreciate you supporting me, and I’m so glad I can bake up delicious treats for you all! ❤️

*sold out of the Frosted Animal cookies today, will have more tomorrow!!* 🎉PORCH POP UP🎉Friday 3pm-9pm Saturday 10am-6pm...
07/24/2026

*sold out of the Frosted Animal cookies today, will have more tomorrow!!*

🎉PORCH POP UP🎉
Friday 3pm-9pm
Saturday 10am-6pm

🏠327 W Liberty St

🍪
S’mores cookies $3
Strawberry Crunch cookies $3
Stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker cookies $5

🍰
Key Lime Pie cakes $5
Chocolate Peanut Butter cakes $5

🦄 I currently have low stock of the Stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker cookies, but will be making more today!

If you would like to pick up outside of those hours, just message me!

Thank you everyone! ❤️

🔥I made a couple upgrades to my S’mores cookies…A butter dipped graham cracker to create a caramelized, crunchy bottom a...
07/23/2026

🔥I made a couple upgrades to my S’mores cookies…

A butter dipped graham cracker to create a caramelized, crunchy bottom and topped with a piece of Hershey’s chocolate! 🍫

Crunchy, gooey, chocolatey….order yours now or stop by my porch pop up this Friday and Saturday!

Also available are my Stuffed Frosted Animal Cookie cookies (featured yesterday), Strawberry Crunch cookies, Key Lime Pie mini cakes, and Chocolate Peanut Butter mini cakes.

✨Stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker Cookies✨A 6 oz cookie stuffed with pink buttercream, drizzled with white chocolate, spri...
07/22/2026

✨Stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker Cookies✨

A 6 oz cookie stuffed with pink buttercream, drizzled with white chocolate, sprinkles, and topped with a frosted animal cookie!

Available at my porch pop up this Friday and Saturday! Preorder or just stop by 😊

Also available will be S’mores cookies, Strawberry Crunch cookies, Key lime pie mini cakes, and chocolate peanut butter mini cakes.

🍪PORCH POP UP🍰FRIDAY 7/24 and SATURDAY 7/25 -S’mores cookies $3/ea-Strawberry Crunch cookies $3/ea-Stuffed Frosted Anim...
07/19/2026

🍪PORCH POP UP🍰

FRIDAY 7/24 and SATURDAY 7/25

-S’mores cookies $3/ea
-Strawberry Crunch cookies $3/ea
-Stuffed Frosted Animal Cracker cookies $5/ea

-Key Lime Pie mini cakes $5/ea
-Chocolate peanut butter mini cakes $5/ea

If you would like to preorder, just send me a message! 😊

So as if losing my heart dog at a young age wasn’t enough, 6 days later this little lady made her appearance 💕 Please be...
07/17/2026

So as if losing my heart dog at a young age wasn’t enough, 6 days later this little lady made her appearance 💕 Please bear with me as I navigate life with three children, I won’t be accepting as many orders for a bit.

However, I do feel as though I may have some time to bake next week! Am I delusional? Probably. It’s not like I’ve been getting great sleep 😅

So I would like to do a small pop up to try to pay off these vet and hospital bills! 💸

Please tell me what you’d like me to bake!! Here are some ideas of what I was going to bake for the market:

-S’mores cookies
-Strawberry Crunch cookies
-Cookies n Cream cookies
-Frosted Animal Cracker cookies

-Strawberry Lemonade mini cakes
-Chocolate Peanut Butter mini cakes
-Key Lime Pie mini cakes

Comment below which of these you’d like to try, and stay tuned for more details regarding my porch pop up!

❤️ Thank you!!

Address

Evansville, WI
53536

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category