Frankie's NY Bagels

Frankie's NY Bagels A taste of New York in the Redwoods
hand-crafted bagels, sandos, donuts & more
Dine in or take out Hello...my name is Frankie.
(203)

I am from Upstate NY and have been missing that NY Style bagel (a crispy outer layer and soft & chewy inside) ever since I moved away. So....I decided to start making them myself. This passion has evolved into a business so I can share my love for NY bagels with the greater Humboldt community. Each bagel is hand-shaped, boiled and baked fresh every day!

Custom donuts for a special Toy Story-themed birthday celebration -- crafted in house by our dream team .margaret and .d...
06/03/2026

Custom donuts for a special Toy Story-themed birthday celebration -- crafted in house by our dream team .margaret and .dreams!

If you have a special occasion coming up, let us whip up some gorgeous and tasty custom donuts just for you!

Email [email protected] to place your custom donut order. (12piece minimum, five days lead time required)

Thank you for nominating us for three categories!Best Bagel Best CookieBest Donut Voting is now open at boh.northco...
06/03/2026

Thank you for nominating us for three categories!
Best Bagel
Best Cookie
Best Donut

Voting is now open at boh.northcoastjournal.com, and you can cast a vote every day! We are incredibly grateful for your support.

Artisanal donut flavors for June 2-5
06/02/2026

Artisanal donut flavors for June 2-5

Specials for June 2-5 >>>
06/02/2026

Specials for June 2-5 >>>

We are hiring! If you're a morning person who loves bagels, thrives in a fast-paced environment, and has commercial kitc...
05/30/2026

We are hiring!
If you're a morning person who loves bagels, thrives in a fast-paced environment, and has commercial kitchen/baking experience, send us your cover letter, resume and availability via email [email protected].

NO DROP INS PLEASE.

Artisanal donut flavors for May 30-31 >>>
05/30/2026

Artisanal donut flavors for May 30-31 >>>

05/30/2026
Cinnamon raisin challah is available at Frankie's for a limited time! Get yours today while supplies last.
05/29/2026

Cinnamon raisin challah is available at Frankie's for a limited time! Get yours today while supplies last.

Artisanal donut flavors for May 26-29Crème Brûlée (v)Dubai chocolate (dairy)Chocolate peanut butter pretzel (v)Raspberry...
05/26/2026

Artisanal donut flavors for May 26-29

Crème Brûlée (v)
Dubai chocolate (dairy)
Chocolate peanut butter pretzel (v)
Raspberry cream (v)
Confetti cookies and cream (v)

Specials for May 26-29 >>>
05/26/2026

Specials for May 26-29 >>>

Address

3750 Harris Street
Eureka, CA
95503

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7:30am - 2pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 2pm
Thursday 7:30am - 2pm
Friday 7:30am - 2pm
Saturday 7:30am - 2pm
Sunday 7:30am - 2pm

Telephone

+17075993305

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Frankie's NY Bagels posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Frankie's NY Bagels:

Shortcuts

Share

Category