Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza

Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza I’m Mike (Bro. Yoder). I’m formerly Amish. I grew up in a home where great homemade cooking & baking was the everyday norm. Even PIZZA!

I’m fulfilling a dream of opening a pizza shop. I guarantee you fresh homemade dough and ingredients every time!

Hi Everyone!GREAT NEWS FROM BRO YODERS!!….Next week I have a beautiful “8-Tray” Vulcan convection oven being installed h...
05/25/2026

Hi Everyone!

GREAT NEWS FROM BRO YODERS!!….

Next week I have a beautiful “8-Tray” Vulcan convection oven being installed here at Bro Yoders. I’m super excited!!, because I’ll be baking 96 of my famous cinnamon rolls every hour!!😊
Possibly no longer needing pre-orders!! Not sure. But possibly.

**** I’m planning to have MAPLE GLAZE again this SAT & SUN.****

**** NEW this weekend will be my special handcrafted CREAM HORNS!!! Not sure of the price yet, but I’ll post it soon! It’ll be a limited number to start. ****

Thanks to all for supporting BRO YODERS, and please stay tuned here as wonderful things continue to evolve!😊

Hope to bake for you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

05/23/2026

Sunday May 23, 12:35pm…

ALL NOON & 2PM ROLL PREORDERS ARE ON SCHEDULE!!

I ALSO JUST MADE FRESH GROUND HAM SALAD THIS MORNING!! ALREADY SELLING FAST, ONLY 14 CONTAINERS LEFT IN THE DELI CASE, SO HURRY IN!! $6.95/pound!

❤️Bro Yoder

2pm roll orders are ready!!!If you’re going to be later than 2:30pm to pick up, please DM me!Looks like I made my goal o...
05/20/2026

2pm roll orders are ready!!!
If you’re going to be later than 2:30pm to pick up, please DM me!

Looks like I made my goal of having two extra trays!!!😊
So if you did not preorder, feel free to come get some!

❤️Bro Yoder

10AM & Noon cinnamon rolls!!!!2PM ROLLS ARE ON SCHEDULE!!😋 😋😋😋IF there are any extras after 2pm, I’ll post it here then....
05/20/2026

10AM & Noon cinnamon rolls!!!!
2PM ROLLS ARE ON SCHEDULE!!
😋 😋😋😋

IF there are any extras after 2pm, I’ll post it here then.

Reminder…..
If you want rolls for this holiday weekend, then please order ASAP. This helps me plan ahead!😊

❤️Bro Yoder

05/19/2026

Hi Everyone!

A BIG THANK YOU to all the wonderful people all around Erie and beyond for making this past weekend the BIGGEST weekend yet for Bro Yoders!!!❤️❤️❤️

I am so very grateful that everyone loves my Amish Cinnamon Rolls. I put my heart into every batch.

Today, I baked many dozens of my Amish Peanut Butter Cookies! They are on the sales counter NOW, so stop in and grab a pack of 4 for $5.

I also made today big batches of my homemade Amish Ham Salad and Amish Chicken Salad, which are sure to sell out quick, so stop in soon! But I’ll make more in a few days 😉.

❤️Bro Yoder

05/16/2026

NOTE::::
**** ALL 2PM CINNAMON ROLL ORDERS FOR TODAY (SATURDAY) ARE BEING MOVED TO 3:30PM!****

Thanks!
❤️Bro Yoder

Hi Everyone!Friday evening, 7:30pm, May 15…Note::: ALL AVAILABLE MAPLE GLAZED CINNAMON ROLLS ARE PRE-SOLD FOR THIS WEEKE...
05/15/2026

Hi Everyone!

Friday evening, 7:30pm, May 15…

Note::: ALL AVAILABLE MAPLE GLAZED CINNAMON ROLLS ARE PRE-SOLD FOR THIS WEEKEND! I’ll do another set of trays of these next Saturday and Sunday.😊

As always, if you didn’t pre-order, you can check with me after 2pm Wednesday thru Sunday to see if there are any extra rolls available.
Just DM me here, or call the store (we’re open till 6pm/ 7 Days a week) 814-838-2113.

***Regarding MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND… orders are starting to stack up, so order NOW if you want rolls for the holiday!😊***

Hope to bake for you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

***Bro Yoder’s is located inside the Presque Isle Superette at 3108 W Lake Road, Millcreek. Beside the Oasis Pub, and across the street from the Riviera Motel.

Hi!All 10, Noon, and 2pm orders are on schedule!!😊I’m ‘trying’ to have some “extras” today for walk-ins, but cannot guar...
05/13/2026

Hi!

All 10, Noon, and 2pm orders are on schedule!!😊

I’m ‘trying’ to have some “extras” today for walk-ins, but cannot guarantee how many.

Hope to bake for you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

05/12/2026

Hi Everyone!

Tuesday, 5/12, 2:45pm…

Just a reminder that this Saturday & Sunday 5/16 and 5/17 I’m adding MAPLE GLAZE to the Amish Cinnamon Roll options!
So it’s;
- Vanilla Buttercream
OR
- Maple Glaze (Sat & Sun)

**** Reminder of how to order,…
Send your order to me by DM through this page! Include the following;
- Name
- Phone number
- How many rolls you’d like
- Your preferred pickup time. Times are 10AM, NOON, or 2PM.

I’m located inside the Presque Isle Superette, at 3108 W Lake Road, Millcreek. Beside the Oasis Pub, and across the street from the Riviera Motel.

Hope to bake for you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

05/10/2026

Hi Everyone!!

Sunday evening, 5/10, 7:40pm.

I hope all the Mothers out there had an AWESOME Mothers Day! You deserve it!❤️

Whew!!, this week was a whirlwind! Literally HUNDREDS of my Amish Cinnamon Rolls out the door! THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH!!!🙏❤️ Thank you also for the countless lovely comments about them!🙏

I have a huge new 30 quart mixer coming in this week, so this will TRIPLE the amount of production I can do. Much needed, I know.

To keep things “interesting” I’m planning to also offer BROWN MAPLE GLAZED Cinnamon Rolls!
To start this (and see how folks like it) I’m going to bake 50 of them (25 on Saturday 5/16, 25 on Sunday 5/17). If everyone loves them then I’ll offer these every Wednesday thru Sunday along with my original Vanilla Buttercream rolls.

There’s also a few delicious new items I’ll be offering soon! So watch for my posts as these are available.

As always, please PRE-ORDER by simply sending me a DM here.
You can also call the store (9-6 every day) at 814-838-2113.

Hope to bake for you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

Address

3108 W Lake Road
Erie, PA

Telephone

+18148382113

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category