07/16/2026
BAKED OATMEAL UPDATE!
I've been experimenting with my Baked Oatmeal Recipe over the last couple months. I really like something hearty for breakfast, whether it be baked oatmeal, or overnight oats. Here's the latest version:
2 lg eggs
1/4 tsp salt
2 tsp baking powder
2-2 1/2 c old fashioned oatmeal (no substitute)
2 tab honey or real maple syrup (can add up to 4 tab, or even sugar substitute, but I'd add a banana or applesauce if using a powdered sweetener)
1/2-2/3 c milk, any kind
1 c greek yogurt (vanilla or plain, for more protein)
1 tsp vanilla
1/2 c natural peanut butter, or nut butter of choice, melted to make pourable if swirling in after in the pan
1/2 c strawberry jam, or jam of choice to swirl in after in the pan
Mix wet ingredients together, add dry ingredients. You can either mix the peanut butter with the wet ingredients or swirl it into the oatmeal once it's in the pan along with the jam. Bake 350⁰ about 30-45 min. Will be firm and browned around the edges. Pan should be full; I use a 9x9 or 9x7. Makes 6 servings. Make sure you spray the pan. Smelled just like peanut butter cookies!
Store in fridge. I heated up this morning with a drizzle more of milk. I freeze in portions and just take one out the night before.
For the last few batches of baked oatmeal I've made, I let sit in the pan for 30-45 minutes before baking. You can add a banana or two if you'd like, too, to sweeten up, or just because you like pb&j with banana. You'll need to add some bulk, whether it be unsweetened applesauce or banana, if using sugar substitute.
If you use the basic recipe (minus the pb&j) as a base, you can add just about anything to it. Get crazy! I've made some interesting combinations over the last few months! Use up to 2 cups of whatever mix-ins you like: chocolate chips, fruit, apples & cinnamon, raisins, dried fruit, etc...
If you use the name brand old fashioned oats, they stay more whole and have a bit of a bite. I use whatever I have, but be sure it's old fashioned and not quick cooking.
I'm sure you can sub out whatever dairy, or non-dairy, milk/yogurt you use. You can also sub out the ingredients with GF ones to make GF.