Eileen Blake's Pies and Otherwise

Directions

Eileen Blake's Pies and Otherwise In the summer of 1973, there was a bumper crop of island blueberries. Our family was allowed on a property in Chilmark to pick as many as we could.

We had six sets of hands picking, and ended up with an overabundance of blueberries. We decided to set up a card table on the side of the road and sell the extras. A man came to buy blueberries, but he didn't want them fresh, he wanted a pie. Eileen's theory always was if you're making one you might as well make a dozen. Those first pies sold so quickly that it made her realize that she could share her love of baking and support her family.

Baked apple fritters heading to Reliable Market this morning.
10/15/2026

Baked apple fritters heading to Reliable Market this morning.

Strawberry filled jumbo cookies, chocolate/peanut butter frosted cake slices, and of course pies 🥧. Delivered to Reliabl...
10/13/2026

Strawberry filled jumbo cookies, chocolate/peanut butter frosted cake slices, and of course pies 🥧. Delivered to Reliable Market this morning.

Caramel stuffed, toffee chocolate chip jumbo cookies, little carrot cakes, and of course pie 🥧. Delivery to Reliable Ma...
10/05/2026

Caramel stuffed, toffee chocolate chip jumbo cookies, little carrot cakes, and of course pie 🥧. Delivery to Reliable Market tomorrow morning.

Cookie butter stuffed giant cookies, cosmic brownies, granola, and of course pies, heading to Reliable Market tomorrow m...
09/21/2026

Cookie butter stuffed giant cookies, cosmic brownies, granola, and of course pies, heading to Reliable Market tomorrow morning.

New stuffed cookies heading to Reliable Market tomorrow morning. These are big, thick, and stuffed with homemade reeses ...
09/14/2026

New stuffed cookies heading to Reliable Market tomorrow morning. These are big, thick, and stuffed with homemade reeses filling. Topped with peanut butter ganache, reeses pieces, and a mini reeses pumpkin.

Key lime bar or pumpkin? My vote is for pumpkin! Either way, both are heading to Reliable Market this afternoon. We are ...
09/03/2026

Key lime bar or pumpkin? My vote is for pumpkin! Either way, both are heading to Reliable Market this afternoon. We are taking a short break and our next delivery will be Tuesday 9/8. Little pies will be making a return then.

Slight delivery schedule change for this week. Tuesday morning, Wednesday afternoon and Thursday late afternoon.
08/23/2026

Slight delivery schedule change for this week. Tuesday morning, Wednesday afternoon and Thursday late afternoon.

We have cherry 🍒 pie! I was asked to announce when cherries were in so, delivery to Reliable Market this morning🥧
07/27/2026

We have cherry 🍒 pie! I was asked to announce when cherries were in so, delivery to Reliable Market this morning🥧

Next weeks Reliable Market schedule is Monday and Tuesday morning and Wednesday and Thursday afternoon. I am closing 4th...
06/27/2026

Next weeks Reliable Market schedule is Monday and Tuesday morning and Wednesday and Thursday afternoon. I am closing 4th of July orders on 6/29 pick up is Thursday 7/2 2:30 pm at Reliable.

We have 3 deliveries heading to Reliable Market this week. Monday and Wednesday morning, and Thursday afternoon. Churros...
06/21/2026

We have 3 deliveries heading to Reliable Market this week. Monday and Wednesday morning, and Thursday afternoon. Churros dulce de leche crumbl cookies and of course pies 🥧🥧.

Address

39 Rebecca Ann Lane
East Falmouth, MA
02536.

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Eileen Blake's Pies and Otherwise posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category