Everything Pie Bakery

05/07/2026

Pies of every flavor and size, Mother’s Day cookies, and a variety of bakery goodies too

🌸 Mother’s Day Weekend at the Farmers Market 🌸

In addition to all the great vendors we’re going to have stocked with lots of great Mother’s Day gifts, there will be a planting station available to the first 50 kiddos to come on over and plant up a cute little plant for mom !

And while the kids are doing that, the first 25 moms at the market bright and early in the morning can head on over to Kornerstone Coffee for a FREE cup of black coffee :)

05/01/2026

See you soon!🥧🥧

04/25/2026

A week from today!!! Yay!!

Opening day at the EAST AURORA FARMERS MARKET
Saturday May 2nd !

Featuring our opening day
Kentucky Derby Pie and an assortment of fruit, savory and specialty pies of all sizes

Our bakery is also bringing cookies, cinnamon rolls, muffins, and more.

Stop by and order your Mother’s Day pies for Sat May 9th pickup

03/18/2026

Hey Pie Fans!!!
Easter Pies 🥧 🥧 and
Cinnamon rolls available to order!

Order deadline is Saturday March 28th
Pickup at our West Falls location Saturday April 4th

716.949.0668 Call/ text

Coconut Cream $25
Banana Cream $25
Chocolate Cream $25
Key Lime $25
Boston Cream $25
Caramel Cookie Butter $28
Chocolate Cherry $28
Apple $23
Apple Crumb $25
Cherry $25
Cherry Crumb $28
Peach Blueberry $23
Pecan $28

Cinnamon Rolls with cream cheese frosting or glaze
Single $5
4 pk. $20
Cinnamon rolls Orange Honey Habanero
Single $6
4 pk. $24

02/02/2026

Valentine pies!

Pictured is a Chocolaholic Explosion pie with chocolate cookie crust, chocolate mouse layers and cookie crumble top

Assorted fruit and cream pies are also available

Pickup at our West Falls location Sat Feb 14th.
Order deadline is Feb 11th
💘💘💘💘💘💘💘💘
Call or text us for details and to reserve your pies

716.949.0668

12/04/2025

Happy Holidays and Merry Christmas!

Order deadline for pies and pound cakes is Sunday Dec. 14th

call or text 716.949.0668

Pickup is at our West Falls location Sat 12/20-Tues12/23

Here is this year’s list: 🥧🥧🥧

Eggnog
Cannoli cherry chip
Banana cream
Coconut cream
Key lime
Peanut butter fudge
Chocolate chess
Lemon meringue
Layered lemon mousse
Mincemeat ( also with brandy)
Apple( also with crumb top)
Cherry ( also with crumb top)

NEW !! Introducing our farm market favorite…🍊🍊🍊
Orange Creamsicle Pound Cake
( serves 10-12)

11/25/2025

Extra pies!

Including cream pies( limited supply)

Coming to East Aurora Farmers Market tomorrow! 7a-1p
See you soon!

11/17/2025

This Saturday, Nov 22nd and the following Wed Nov 26th are the last 2 East Aurora farmers market days before Thanksgiving! 7am-1pm

🥧Orders are now closed!

Any extra pies will be available for sale at the market on a first come first serve basis.

Thank you so much to our wonderful customers!!

10/31/2025

This Saturday, Nov 1st we’ll be at the East Aurora Farmers Market taking orders for Thanksgiving pies. Shown below is our Pumpkin Crumb maple glazed pie. It is one of several pies available for your holiday table. See complete pie list below.
Pickup will be Wed 11/26 at the East Aurora Farmers Market 7a-1p

You can also call 716-949-0668 to place your order.

Apple, Apple Crumb
Cherry, Cherry Crumb
Pumpkin
Pumpkin Crumb Maple Glaze
Four Berry
Boston Cream Pie
Mincemeat,
Mincemeat with Brandy and
Pecan

09/20/2025

Some of today’s bakery lineup for the East Aurora Farmers Market…

Maple Glazed Pear pies,
Concord Grape pies,
Orange Honey Habanero Cinnamon Rolls,
Banana blueberry bread,
Apricot cheesecake and Raspberry cheesecake pie pockets and more…