06/21/2026
Cookie Butter Sourdough might just be my new favorite loaf.
Want to make one yourself? Every great loaf starts with a healthy , and we've made it easy to get started. Our active organic starter is available now at TheDailyKnead.com and is perfect for beginners and experienced bakers alike.
This bread starts with a long, slow fermentation that develops incredible flavor, then gets filled with creamy cookie butter before being shaped, proofed, and baked to golden perfection. The result is a crispy artisan crust with a soft, slightly sweet center that tastes amazing toasted with a little butter.
Ingredients:
β’ 500g Bread Flour
β’ 100g Sourdough Starter
β’ 350g Water
β’ 30g Raw Organic Honey
β’ 15g Avocado Oil
β’ 10g Salt
β’ 1 cup Cookie Butter + 1/2 cup crumbled cookies or less to taste
Directions:
-Mix the sourdough starter, water, honey, and avocado oil until combined.
-Add the bread flour and sea salt and mix until a shaggy dough forms.
-Let rest for 30 minutes.
-Perform 4 sets of stretch and folds, 30 minutes apart.
-Bulk ferment until doubled and bubbly.
-After the first proof, gently turn the dough out and stretch it into a rectangle.
-Spread the cookie butter evenly across the dough.
-Shape into a boule, creating tension on the surface.
-Place in a banneton and refrigerate overnight for the second proof.
-Score and bake in a preheated Dutch oven at 425Β°F for 25 minutes covered and 375Β°F 10-20 minutes uncovered. Until the internal temperature reaches 205Β°F.
-Cool completely before slicing.
If you've been thinking about starting your sourdough journey, now is the perfect time. Grab your active sourdough starter from TheDailyKnead.com and start baking homemade artisan bread in your own kitchen.
Have you ever tried in sourdough?