Ice House Bakery & Dessert Shop

05/22/2026

If you need Dessert this weekend, stop in at Ice House in Conneaut Lake… we are LOADED!!!

Pies, Brownies, Lava Cakes, Square Cakes
Cake Bombs, CheeseCake like Crazy
Cookies, More Pies, Cream Pies, Fruit Pies,
Mini Pies, Baklava, Lemon Bars, Cannolis

Check out the work we did on the Catering side the last 2 days… and lots lots more going out tonight and all weekend….

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/176ZMr4kDy/?mibextid=wwXIfrl

So let us at Ice House put the Dessert on your table and plate this weekend, and you can just sit back and relax during the holiday weekend..

Call us at 814-213-0076 for yummy stuff or stop in and be blown away with our selection.

390 Water Street, Conneaut Lake, Pa. 16316

04/19/2026

04/05/2026

We had lots of fun helping the Buckles & Breeches 4H group with an event they participated in on Saturday 04/04 in Crawford County..

If you’re ever in need of goodies that you can sell to make money on for your group or organization, let us know and we will help you out too…

Thank Buckles & Breeches 4H for letting us help you!!! It was a lot of fun for us to be here for you!

04/03/2026

Happy Easter in advance everyone..

We baked/made a bunch of Pies for this weekend, and we are having an Easter 🐣 Pie Sale for YOU!

* Dutch Apple
* Cherry
* Strawberry Rhubarb
* Peach
* Cinnamon Apple
* Blueberry
* Southern Pecan
* Banana Cream
Chocolate Cream
Boston Cream
* Coconut Cream
* Peanut Butter Cup Cream (w/ Chocolate)
(Also in Gluten Free)
Peanut Butter Explosion (no Chocolate)
(Also in Gluten Free)
* French Chocolate Silk
* Lemon Cream


$16.00 per Pie… while they last… we will make some more tomorrow, but no promised tour flavor flavor will be here, but you can call ahead and ask us to save you a flavor.

We are also making several Gluten Free Pie Flavors for our Gluten Free Friends

We also Baked lots and lots of Gourmet Cookies today.. for your Dessert Pleasure and Snacks

Call us 814-213-0076 or stop in at Ice House Bakery in Conneaut Lake, Pa. Downtown

03/12/2026

.. Well it’s that time of year again… and we are only days away….
…National PI Day - 3.14 is Saturday March 14th,
and as we do every year, we’re having a Crazy 🤪 Pie 🥧 Sale !!! - 4” Mini Pies 🥧 for $3.14 ea.
Thursday 03/12 - Sunday 03/22

We started “Baking n Making” them today, the flavors will be “Rotating” each day, but please note, flavors can sell out until we make more… so be prepared to switch it up when you come in..

Listed below are the flavors we are making during this 11-days of Pie Madness.. you can buy as many as you like, come back as often as you like.. and gobble them up.. all $3.14 each…

Here’s is a current list of Flavors.. but more are being added to this list as we make them…

* Reese’s PB Cup Cream
* PB Explosion (no chocolate)
* PB Brownie Cream
* PB Cookie Explosion (no chocolate)
* PB Fudge Cookie n Cream
* PB n Banana Cream- Elvis Presley
* Banana Cream
* Banana Split Cream w/ peanuts
* Banana Brownie Cream
* Lemon n Cream
* Lemon Blueberry n Cream
* Lemon Raspberry n Cream
* Lemon Strawberry n Cream
* Lemon Coconut n Cream
* Lemon - Lime
* Roasted Coconut n Cream
* Pineapple Coconut
* Pineapple Upside Down
* Apple Cinnamon
* Apple Caramel Pecan
* Apple Blueberry
* Blueberry White Chip n Cream
* Strawberry White Chip n Cream
* Strawberry Rhubarb White Chip n Cream
* Cherry n Cream
* Chocolate Cherry Cordial
* Mint Brownie Cream
* Mint Shamrock Cream Shake
* Grasshopper Mint Oreo Cream
* Mint Fudge Cookie n Cream
* Cheesecake Cream n Peaches
* Cheesecake Cream n Blueberry
* Cheesecake Cream n Cherries
* Cheesecake Cream n Raspberry
* Cheesecake Cream n Fudge Brownie
* Cheesecake Cream n Reese’s PB Cup
* Lemon n Cheesecake Cream
* Cheesecake Oreo Cream
* Vanilla Oreo n Cream
* Chocolate Oreo Cream
* Peanut Butter Oreo Cream
* Vanilla Cream M&M’s
* Chocolate Cream M&M’s
* Peanut Butter Cream & Reese’s Pieces
* Key-Lime Bavarian n Cream
* Key-Lime Bavarian n Roasted Coconut Cream
* Peaches n Cream
* Peaches n Blueberries
* Pineapple Jalapeño n Cream
* Raspberry Jalapeño n Cream
* Strawberry Daiquiri Cream
* Pina Colada Cream
* Chocolate Cream Explosion
* Chocolate Cream Fudge Cookie
* Chocolate Cream n Brownie Chip
* Chocolate Cream Snickers Candy Bar
* Vanilla Cream Cookie Dough
* Chocolate Cream Cookie Dough
* Strawberry Candy Nerd
* Strawberry n Cream Blast

And more Flavors “To Be Determined” & Created..
So please remember, flavors can change everyday, and new ones will be added as we make them.. we will dig up some of the unique flavors we did over the last few years and add them.. so come prepared to alter your list as the availability changes and come back often to buy more.

4” Mini Pies - $3.14 each, you can buy as many as you want!!! Thanks for keeping this Pie Sale alive, fun and Yummy

02/14/2026

So that you don’t get in the “Dog House” you can call us and we can still make you a “Sweet Treat” Valentine’s Day box of goodies… you must call in to order one of our 16 different boxes..
❤️ OR ❤️

You can stop in and grab a box of 4, 6, or 12 Chocolate Covered Strawberries that we have ready to Grab in Go…❤️

Our Prices DID NOT GO UP at all this year over last year… not even a penny!! So come to Ice House Bakery, Ice House Pizzeria in Conneaut Lake and take your sweet home a Treat!!!

390 Water St. Conneaut Lake - Downtown
814-213-0076 to place an order….
See list of boxes on the 4 picture link.

02/11/2026

Hi Everyone, thanks for accepting our invitation to our new Catering Page.. this page will be dedicated to show what we do in the Catering and Tray making world.

We can really do anything, we have no limitation in imagination or creativity

We hope you will share our page with ALL your friends, families and work places…

As we build new items we will show them off on here.

Our pricing is flexible based on your needs, we just don’t set a high price and give you little options. Also which really makes us different is WE DO NOT PRE-ADD A SET GRATUITY AT ALL!

Gratuity if something you decide to do, not imposed on you by the cater as most do…

We are ALWAYS AFFORDABLE, FLEXIBLE, and willing to make it work for you.

Thanks again and please share us and tell the places you work so they might use us for their needs too.

We would really appreciate you spreading the word and helping us get more exposure.. thanks

02/02/2026

❤️❤️ 2026 Valentine Sweet Treat Boxes ❤️❤️
Well, February is here and that mean Valentines
❤️ Day will be here shortly too… So Order from us and get the best deals and treat for your Sweetie!

Just as previous years, we’ve created 16- Valentine “Sweet Treat Gift Boxes” and Chocolate Covered Strawberries boxes for you… … and like prior years, we won’t break your budget as others places do… no one sells for less!

Listed below are all the different options available, so please order by Option # and you can get as many as you wish. We don’t have all of this year’s “Sweet Treat Boxes” pictured, but trust me, we won’t skimp on any box for your Sweet Heart!!

❤️ Option 1; Chocolate Covered Strawberry Box, with 12- Milk Chocolate dipped Strawberries, some with drizzle colored chocolate and sprinkles, and other sweet treats too. - $25.00 ea. see pic below)

❤️ Option 2; Strawberry Chocolate “Dipper Box”, w/ 12- fresh Strawberries with an 8oz cup of Milk Chocolate Dipping Icing that you heat and dip your Strawberries into. A delicious and warm Chocolate Treat that will enlighten your tastebuds with fresh strawberries, and other chocolate treats within each box, - $20.00 ea. (see pic below)

❤️ Option 3; Same as Option 2, but 18- fresh Strawberries and an 8oz cup of Milk Chocolate Dipping Icing, and other chocolate treats within each box, - $25.00 ea. (see pic below)

❤️ Option 4; 2- slices of Original New York Juniors Cheesecake, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and an assortment of other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pic below)

❤️ Option 5; 2- slices of New York Juniors “Reese’s Peanut Cups” Cheesecake w/ Peanut Butter & Chocolate drizzled over the top, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pic below)

❤️ Option 6; 2- slices of New York Juniors “Cherry Chocolate” Cheesecake with Cherry slurry and Chocolate drizzled over the top, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 7; 2- slices of New York Juniors “Hot Fudge Sundae” Cheesecake with Peanuts, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pic below)

❤️ Option 8; 2- slices of New York Juniors “Caramel Pecan Turtle” Cheesecake with Chocolate drizzled and Pecans on top, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pic below, if you don’t want Pecans, tell us when ordering)

❤️ Option 9; 2- slices of New York “Vanilla Bean”Cheesecake with Vanilla flakes on top, 4-Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pic below)

❤️ Option 10; 2- slices of New York Juniors “Death by Chocolate” Cheesecake with chocolates chunks on top, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 11; 2- slices of “Keylime Margarita Cheesecake” w/ Keylime Bavarian Cream in a side cup, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 12; 2- slices of New York Juniors Cheesecake with York Peppermint Chips and melted York Peppermint patties and chocolate drizzle on top, 4- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 13; 2- slices of Gourmet Layered stacked Tiramisu Cake (this is over the topped cake), 6- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea. (see example pics of cake below)

❤️ Option 14; 2- slices of Chocolates Caramel Brownie Cake, 6- Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more, - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 15; 2- Gourmet Red Velvet Cookie, 2 Gourmet Chocolate Chip Cookies, and 2 Salted Caramel Cookies, 6 Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more - $25.00 ea.

❤️ Option 16; 4- Large Cannolis (2 Cheese, 2
Chocolate Chip Cannolis), 6 Chocolate Covered Strawberries, and other Sweet items ranging from dipped mint cookies, chocolate candy, dipped pretzels and more - $25.00 ea.

We will also have packages of 6, 8 & 12 chocolate covered Strawberries which you can buy as “Grab n Go” treats for your sweet desire with various sizes and mixed flavors within at a lessor price. No pre-orders required, they will just be available in our cooler case for you.

So call us at 814-213-0076 to place your orders, they are available for Pick Up from 02/12-02/15 unless you need it on another date… ALL ORDERS MUST BE CALLED IN, no online orders taken. See our hours of operation to call in your order..

Don’t OVERPAY elsewhere for Less!! We strive to give you the most for your money and the most tastiest treats possible, “Gluten Free” Options are available, Call and ask for Gary for descriptions.

Call 814-213-0076 - Ice House Bakery / Pizzeria
Conneaut Lake, Pa. / Downtown on the corner

Orders can be taken for Offices and Businesses

01/13/2026

Sometimes I just amaze myself at what I can and will create for my customer…

I can make these foe you too!!, your office, your business, your customers and more!! Just Call!

Ice House Bakery / Ice House Pizzeria & Subs
814-213-0076
Conneaut Lake, Pa
We can build you trays year round to meet your needs!!!

01/01/2026

Happy New Years to all.. May 2026 be Great!!