Conestoga Cookie Co.

Conestoga Cookie Co. Decorated custom sugar cookies for every occasion, drop cookies, sweet buns with and without nuts and other baked goods

01/01/2026

Hello 2026! Can’t wait to be back to baking once my shoulder is fixed. Starting the year off learning even more patience and persistence. Dream big and do epic things.

12/18/2025

That’s a wrap on 2025. However I’m ending it early with a torn labrum in 2 places in my right shoulder, ugh, my dominant arm. That means no cookies for me. When I’m fixed back up I’ll be waiting for your sugar cookie orders. Thank you for making this little cookie business everything it has become.

Some super cute cookie houses created with our kits.
12/05/2025

Some super cute cookie houses created with our kits.

It’s been a bit of a slower cookie season and it’s partly due to the shoulder issue I’m having. It makes it difficult to...
12/04/2025

It’s been a bit of a slower cookie season and it’s partly due to the shoulder issue I’m having. It makes it difficult to roll dough and mix icing since it’s my dominant arm. But I’m getting done what I can. I love this twin cow set.

Happy first birthday Jesse. As fellow Phillies fans we hope your year rings the bell ⚾️
12/01/2025

Happy first birthday Jesse. As fellow Phillies fans we hope your year rings the bell ⚾️

Happy birthday Brooks! We hope this year is like winning the Master’s.
11/19/2025

Happy birthday Brooks! We hope this year is like winning the Master’s.

What a fun evening learning to decorate thanksgiving cookies. We had some repeat decorators and some new ones, one spell...
11/16/2025

What a fun evening learning to decorate thanksgiving cookies. We had some repeat decorators and some new ones, one spelling mistake which gave us all a good laugh and some of us have eyeballs that don’t work well at this time of night. Watch for our next class, you’ll be guaranteed at least one laugh.

11/14/2025

Come see us at Perfect Pots today and tomorrow.

You’ll find these cookies at the cookie trailer Friday and Saturday at Perfect Pots in Strasburg for their open house. W...
11/12/2025

You’ll find these cookies at the cookie trailer Friday and Saturday at Perfect Pots in Strasburg for their open house. We condone playing with your food here at Conestoga Cookie Co 🙂

I am so excited to partner with Perfect Pots in Strasburg for their open house. You’ll find the cookie trailer there Nov...
11/11/2025

I am so excited to partner with Perfect Pots in Strasburg for their open house.

You’ll find the cookie trailer there November 14-15. Stop in for all your Thanksgiving deliciousness and something to spruce up your table or front door.

11/11/2025

To all the Veterans out there.

Thank you for your service 🇱🇷

Cameron is turning one and I would LOVE it if it was strawberry season right now. Is it May yet?
11/10/2025

Cameron is turning one and I would LOVE it if it was strawberry season right now. Is it May yet?

Address

1121 Indian Marker Road
Conestoga, PA
17516

Telephone

+17176291058

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Conestoga Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Conestoga Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category