Peggy Jean's Pies

Peggy Jean's Pies Visit us at one of our two Columbia locations:

South: 503 Nifong Blvd., Ste C
West: 421 N Stadium B

September Pie of the Month:  Coconut Caramel!  We whip up a batch of from-scratch caramel sauce, pour it into a baked pi...
09/10/2024

September Pie of the Month: Coconut Caramel! We whip up a batch of from-scratch caramel sauce, pour it into a baked pie shell, and cover it with our bestselling coconut cream filling. And if that didn't sound divine, we add homemade whipped cream, toasted coconut, and caramel drizzle. This flavor won our July Epic Pie Tasting and it is easy to see why it was it was the crowd favorite!

In stores now and available for pre-order in both the nine-inch and six-inch size.

Happy Birthday, Jean!  She’s the pie baking GOAT (obviously), but that’s the very least of it.  She’s as apt to clean th...
09/08/2024

Happy Birthday, Jean! She’s the pie baking GOAT (obviously), but that’s the very least of it. She’s as apt to clean the drain into the grease trap with bleach and a scrub brush as she is to speak in front of 800 people about the power of the matriarchy. She fears nothing (well, maybe snakes but never spiders), defines unconventionality, convinces us that absolutely anything is possible, and has watched every single Korean drama in the Netflix catalog. We are the luckiest to have her❤️

MIZ-PJP!  Our popular Tiger Tailgate Packages are back for the fall season!  We've created the best way for you to order...
09/05/2024

MIZ-PJP! Our popular Tiger Tailgate Packages are back for the fall season! We've created the best way for you to order our tarts (our three inch pies) by the 10, 20, and 40 pack. Whether you are the tailgate host or tailgate guest, our tart packs are the perfect addition to a tailgate dessert table! Available for pickup at either location on each home football game Saturday. Let's go Tigers!

More information and purchasing links here: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/tailgate-party-packs

Just a few tickets remain for this Friday's Epic Pie Tasting!  We made a few test flavors yesterday and you aren't going...
08/27/2024

Just a few tickets remain for this Friday's Epic Pie Tasting! We made a few test flavors yesterday and you aren't going to want to miss this! More information and purchase link here: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/pie-tasting

Our darling Lemon Raspberry pie is only here for a few more days🗓️. Soon we will say goodbye until next summer, so if th...
08/26/2024

Our darling Lemon Raspberry pie is only here for a few more days🗓️. Soon we will say goodbye until next summer, so if this is a favorite of yours, hurry in this week! (And if you haven’t tried, it’s our from-scratch lemon filling layered with fresh raspberries, plus raspberry whipped cream!)

Tickets for our August Epic Pie Tasting are now available!  Scheduled for Friday, August 30th, this will be the PERFECT ...
08/21/2024

Tickets for our August Epic Pie Tasting are now available! Scheduled for Friday, August 30th, this will be the PERFECT family & friends event for Labor Day weekend. More information and purchasing link for pickup at either store now available here: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/pie-tasting

Listen, Team PJP is hiring and we are the best group of people to work with!  Enjoy easy scheduling (we close at 6pm and...
08/20/2024

Listen, Team PJP is hiring and we are the best group of people to work with! Enjoy easy scheduling (we close at 6pm and are closed Sundays!). Plus we offer employee discounts, opportunities for growth, health insurance, and more! We are on a quest to World Pie Domination and you should join us. Application available on our website! ♥️

We did win the Gold Metal for Best Dessert in the annual  Best of Columbia, so…***
08/14/2024

We did win the Gold Metal for Best Dessert in the annual Best of Columbia, so…
***

We promise this is the last time (at least for the summer😂) that we are going obsessively discuss our mention in Elin Hi...
08/11/2024

We promise this is the last time (at least for the summer😂) that we are going obsessively discuss our mention in Elin Hilderbrand’s New York Times best-selling novel, Swan Song. This week we flipped through and admired our page while at The Hidden Lantern, the most charming bookstore in Rosemary Beach, Florida❤️
***
(In full disclosure, if we see the book anywhere beyond the immediate mid-Missouri area, we are probably going to discuss it. And goodness help us all if we ever make it to Nantucket. Iykyk😂)

August Pie of the Month: Lemon Supreme!  This was a crowd favorite in our June Epic Pie Tasting👏. This pie features a wh...
08/07/2024

August Pie of the Month: Lemon Supreme! This was a crowd favorite in our June Epic Pie Tasting👏. This pie features a white chocolate and cream cheese base, covered with our from-scratch lemon filling and then generously topped with freshly made whipped cream🍋. It’s the perfect way to finish our summer days❤️. In the refrigerator at both stores!

We can’t tell you where we went this week, who we met, or what we did…but we can promise it was pretty epic and WE LITER...
08/03/2024

We can’t tell you where we went this week, who we met, or what we did…but we can promise it was pretty epic and WE LITERALLY CAN’T WAIT TO TELL YOU (when are are allowed, of course, because yes to baking pies but no to defending litigation).
****
In our travels, we noticed the latest book by - Swan Song - in EVERY airport bookshop. It is #5 on the New York Times bestsellers list this week…AND features PJP on page 198❤️.
***

There are so many great things about being a family business with a long local history!  When a customer came in with a ...
07/29/2024

There are so many great things about being a family business with a long local history! When a customer came in with a gift certificate from January 6, 1999, not only were we thrilled to honor it, but also thrilled to have glimpse at who we were back then❤️ Our logo has changed and paper gift certificates are long gone, but we are still so honored to create the finest pies for our sweet customers!

Epic Pie Tasting is so much fun!  Order a tasting kit of six flavors of pie we've never made before, pick it up Friday, ...
07/22/2024

Epic Pie Tasting is so much fun! Order a tasting kit of six flavors of pie we've never made before, pick it up Friday, make all your guesses with family and friends and let us know how we did! It's the best activity and only $27.99 (one kit easily feeds 1-4 people). More details and purchase link: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/pie-tasting

National Women-Owned Business Day is celebrated on a lone calendar day but honestly, it should on our minds EVERY DAY OF...
07/17/2024

National Women-Owned Business Day is celebrated on a lone calendar day but honestly, it should on our minds EVERY DAY OF THE YEAR👏
****
There are 114% more female entrepreneurs in 2024 than there was 20 years ago. Now, women own approximately 43% of all businesses in America✅
****
In 20 years, let’s be the majority of business owners in America👊
****

Tickets for July's Epic Pie Tasting are now available!  We make six flavors of pie we've never made before.  Maybe they ...
07/13/2024

Tickets for July's Epic Pie Tasting are now available! We make six flavors of pie we've never made before. Maybe they are amazing and maybe they aren't...we rely on you to tell us! (We provide a scoring template, but love the creativity of the templates created and shared with us.) Winners become future Pie of the Month contenders! Details and purchasing links available at: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/pie-tasting

July Pie of the Month!  PINEAPPLE PEACH.  This adorable combination won an Epic Pie Tasting earlier this year and we've ...
07/09/2024

July Pie of the Month! PINEAPPLE PEACH. This adorable combination won an Epic Pie Tasting earlier this year and we've just been patiently waiting for the perfect month to add it to our shelves! This is a combination of crushed pineapples and sliced peaches, finished with our iconic diagonal latticework. On shelves now in both the six-inch and nine-inch sizes!

Gold: Best Dessert!❤️***We are honored and so proud of PJP💯. Thank you so much to our community of fans who took the tim...
07/03/2024

Gold: Best Dessert!❤️
***
We are honored and so proud of PJP💯. Thank you so much to our community of fans who took the time to vote for PJP!
****
This was a quick and easy picture to take at the awards ceremony…but one picture could never capture the depth of talent on our staff that work so hard to make PJP an icon. Team PJP continues to amaze us with creativity and dedication to the art of pie baking. THANK YOU.
****
And for all PJP customers and our thousands of social media fans, you deserve a part of this award as well. We simply couldn’t be us without you. THANK YOU. We are the luckiest to have you along with us to world pie domination.
****

We were so honored to speak earlier this year at That's What She Said Columbia 2024 - Presented by Stephens College abou...
06/27/2024

We were so honored to speak earlier this year at That's What She Said Columbia 2024 - Presented by Stephens College about our secret ingredient: the matriarchy. If you missed out, you can watch us discuss generational leadership AND Taylor Swift in under 20 minutes and it’s now available on YouTube🫶. We recommend watching the entire event but PJP makes an entrance around the 12 minute mark: https://youtu.be/_MnXBSoIjoA?si=KPJB1P3ggs-dK_jS

She’s beauty, she’s grace…well, she’s the best pie in the United States!  Our nationally recognized White Chocolate Stra...
06/25/2024

She’s beauty, she’s grace…well, she’s the best pie in the United States! Our nationally recognized White Chocolate Strawberry pie goes patriotic with the addition of fresh blueberries and strawberries for the loveliest addition to your holiday celebration🇺🇸
****
Order the American Flag pie now online by phone for pickup at either location for your July 4th festivities. To allow for the fresh fruit decoration, this pie is only available in the nine-inch size. It is available gluten-free and/or with a vegan crust but is not available sugar-free. The cost is $29.
****
We are just certain this pie will be the best addition to your holiday dessert table! We can’t wait to see you soon!
****

Just a few tickets remain for this Friday's June Epic Pie Tasting!  Purchase online now to pick up your tasting kit and ...
06/23/2024

Just a few tickets remain for this Friday's June Epic Pie Tasting! Purchase online now to pick up your tasting kit and scoring template this Friday afternoon from either location. This is a super fun summer weekend activity! Details, pricing, and purchase information found here: https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/pie-tasting
****

We promise this is our last  post (unless she’s invites us to visit us Nantucket, because then WE WILL NEVER SHUT UP).  ...
06/20/2024

We promise this is our last post (unless she’s invites us to visit us Nantucket, because then WE WILL NEVER SHUT UP). But anyway, we met Elin last night and it was a total dream. We couldn’t be more honored and she couldn’t be more gracious and kind in real life. When there is a PJP in towns across America and we have a corporate headquarters, best believe this picture is going on the wall! 💕

06/19/2024

So many have stopped by our stores and our email inbox is full with the news that PJP was name dropped in the newest bes...
06/16/2024

So many have stopped by our stores and our email inbox is full with the news that PJP was name dropped in the newest bestseller by this week! You’ll find a nod to PJP (and Columbia!) on page 197 of “Swan Song”.
*****
We are so fortunate to have so many cool and interesting things happen for PJP. But this - a mention by a New York Times Bestselling author - for millions around the world to read our name and the character to fly our pies to Nantucket from Columbia? Well, this ranks high on the list of our favorite things ever for our sweet PJP❤️

Father's Day is this Sunday, June 16th! And we know from selling pies for over 10 years that dads (and grandpas too!) re...
06/12/2024

Father's Day is this Sunday, June 16th! And we know from selling pies for over 10 years that dads (and grandpas too!) really love pie to celebrate their special day!

The day before Father's Day is one of our most heavily shopped days in-store and often we do sell out early at both locations. Secure dad's favorite pie by pre-ordering - it doesn't cost extra to pre-order...it just assigns your name to your pie choice and guarantees availability at pickup on a busy holiday weekend!

Visit us online now at https://www.peggyjeanspies.com/preorder-pies-new or call either store to order via phone!

Earlier this spring, we were honored to speak to a packed Missouri Theater audience about PJP’s secret ingredient:  the ...
06/10/2024

Earlier this spring, we were honored to speak to a packed Missouri Theater audience about PJP’s secret ingredient: the matriarchy. We shared some thoughts about generational leadership and it ALMOST felt like a TED Talk, until we veered off into a group performance of Taylor Swift lyrics…because if anything, the matriarchy is about remaining true to oneself.

June Pie of the Month: Chocolate Chip Cookie!  Our secret ingredient is what we DON’T add - baking soda or baking powder...
06/07/2024

June Pie of the Month: Chocolate Chip Cookie! Our secret ingredient is what we DON’T add - baking soda or baking powder. This exclusion allows homemade cookie dough to be poured in a pie shell, baked for an hour, and still have a gooey center. It’s all the joy of cookie dough (minus the risk of salmonella). On shelves now in both stores for the month of June. (Graphic: .miller )

06/04/2024
Occasionally, we wonder exactly what we are doing with our lives🤷‍♀️  Entrepreneurship offers notoriously long hours (an...
05/31/2024

Occasionally, we wonder exactly what we are doing with our lives🤷‍♀️ Entrepreneurship offers notoriously long hours (and then even more worry because we want PJP to be the very best she can be - all day, every day).
***
So when a customer dropped off an envelope addressed to PJP earlier this week, our self-deprecating selves prepared for the worst. But inside we found the loveliest of handwritten notes from a new resident of Columbia. She was thrilled to find PJP so welcoming - and so delicious with each flavor of pie she has tried.
****
That’s all we want for our sweet business - for our customers to feel like they have a consistent place to find a delicious dessert…and the friendliest of staff with a warm welcome. We are so lucky to do this work❤️
****

May's Pie of the Month - Strawberry Pop Tart - holds the record as our MOST POPULAR PIE OF THE MONTH EVER.  If you haven...
05/28/2024

May's Pie of the Month - Strawberry Pop Tart - holds the record as our MOST POPULAR PIE OF THE MONTH EVER. If you haven't tried it yet, it is outrageously delicious (and pretty!). AND it is the perfect accompaniment to Netflix's Unfrosted movie because watching a movie about pop tarts while eating Strawberry Pop Tart pie is really next level).

Address

503 C Nifong Boulevard
Columbia, MO
65201

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+15734477437

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Peggy Jean's Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Peggy Jean's Pies:

Videos

Share



You may also like