Butter, Sugar, Magic

Butter, Sugar, Magic Butter Sugar Magic makes cakes, pies and breads from scratch for all occasions - order yours today! Butter, Sugar, Magic bakes everything fresh for each order.

Please give 24-48 hours notice for orders due to this. Our website is down for the time being so please message us to place an order. Thank you! Pies are available for $27 in apple, blueberry, cherry, strawberry rhubarb, pumpkin. Pie Crumble Cakes are a delicious layer of our pie filling sandwiched between 2 layers of shortbread style cake and sprinkled with our classic crumble topping. These are

available in apple, blueberry and cherry for $30. Our cakes are available in chocolate, vanilla or white and are made with a buttercream frosting. Custom decorations are available and we are happy to work with you to create the design that you want! Please see our gallery for some examples of the beautiful creations our customers have requested! Cake pricing depends on the design chosen but begins with an 8" at $28. Order 12 cupcakes for $13 or 24 cupcakes for $25! Breads made to order for $5. Only available after 10am since all are made as fresh as possible for pickup:
Italian baguette - A crusty loaf with rich flavors of olive oil. $4
French baguettes - Classic baguette. $4
Dutch Crusted Demi Baguette - A swirl of flavors come out in this slightly sweeter twist of our classic baguette topped with a crispy crunch. An excellent sandwich loaf! - $5
Caramelized Onion Focaccia - Loads of onions and a bit of sea salt on top of a soft, airy flatbread. $4
Brioche loaf - Soft, flakey loaf that pulls apart into small rolls or can be sliced for a small sandwich bread or some french toast! $5
Cinnamon Crunch Pullapart Bread - Cinnamon and sugar are twisted into a tall loaf and topped with a crunch! $4
Rosemary Garlic Pullapart Bread - A savory version of our cinnamon crunch pull apart bread. $4

Thank you for your blueberry pie crumble order, Michele!
06/19/2026

Thank you for your blueberry pie crumble order, Michele!

Scones!
06/18/2026

Scones!

Soft sandwich rolls!
06/18/2026

Soft sandwich rolls!

Thank you for your keylime cupcake order, Kristin. I hope A has a wonderful birthday!
06/18/2026

Thank you for your keylime cupcake order, Kristin. I hope A has a wonderful birthday!

Couldn’t help it - more croissants!
06/02/2026

Couldn’t help it - more croissants!

Thank you for your order, Liz! Have a wonderful time visiting your sister.
05/29/2026

Thank you for your order, Liz! Have a wonderful time visiting your sister.

Thank you for your lemon cookie purchase, Missy! I hope the shower goes wonderfully!
04/18/2026

Thank you for your lemon cookie purchase, Missy! I hope the shower goes wonderfully!

Thank you for your GF banana chocolate chip muffin order, Wendy!
04/16/2026

Thank you for your GF banana chocolate chip muffin order, Wendy!

Gluten free chocolate chip banana muffins :)
04/13/2026

Gluten free chocolate chip banana muffins :)

Croissants :)
04/13/2026

Croissants :)

Address

Dark Hawk Cir
Columbia, MD
21045

Telephone

(443) 718-0254

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butter, Sugar, Magic posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category