College Hill Cakery

College Hill Cakery Boutique bakery 🌸 Try our Gooey Buttercakes!

🎂 Custom cakes. Specialty treats.

Weddings
🔗 Pre-order
💌 Custom orders/inquiries via email
🚚 Shipping nationwide

🎄❄️ HOLIDAY POP-IN MENU! ❄️🎄Join us this Saturday (12/6 from 10AM–12PM) for a cozy, sweet kickoff to the holiday season!...
12/06/2025

🎄❄️ HOLIDAY POP-IN MENU! ❄️🎄

Join us this Saturday (12/6 from 10AM–12PM) for a cozy, sweet kickoff to the holiday season! No pre-order needed — just stop by early and snag your faves while they last! 🍪✨

Menu:
• 8x8 Original Gooey Buttercake
• 8x8 Gooey Butter Coffee Cake
• Assorted Holiday Gooey Buttercups 🎄
• Pistachio Cake Slices 💚
• Chocolate Chip Cookies 🍪
• Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches
• Butterscotch Magic Bars ✨
• Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Oat Bars

📍 College Hill Cakery
📅 Saturday 12/6
⏰ 10AM–12PM

🧁 Can’t make it? Pre-order from our full holiday menu (including gluten-free options + dessert trays!) through 12/15:
👉 collegehillcakery.com/s/order

📦 Shipping sweets nationwide?
👉 Ship a sweet surprise

🍎🍁FALL POP-IN MENU!🍁🍎Join us this Saturday (9/27 from 10AM–12PM) for our Fall Pop-in! 🍪 Menu:• 8x8 Original Gooey Butter...
09/27/2025

🍎🍁FALL POP-IN MENU!🍁🍎
Join us this Saturday (9/27 from 10AM–12PM) for our Fall Pop-in!

🍪 Menu:
• 8x8 Original Gooey Buttercakes
• 8x8 Gooey Butter Coffee Cakes
• Assorted Gooey Buttercups
• S’mores Cake
• Chocolate Chip Cookies
• M&M Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Iced Maple Oat Pecan Cookies
• Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches
• Butterscotch Magic Bars
• Salted Caramel Apple Pie Bars

📍 College Hill Cakery
📅 Saturday 9/27
⏰ 10AM–12PM

No pre-order needed — grab your fall faves before they’re gone! 🍂💛

🎒✨ Back to School Pop-In! ✨🎒Pop in TOMORROW (Sat 8/23) from 10AM–12PM for our Back-to-School Pop-In Event! 🍪📚 No pre-ord...
08/22/2025

🎒✨ Back to School Pop-In! ✨🎒

Pop in TOMORROW (Sat 8/23) from 10AM–12PM for our Back-to-School Pop-In Event!

🍪📚 No pre-orders needed — just swing by and stock up on all your favorite treats!

✨ Pop-In Menu:
🍰 8x8 Original Gooey Buttercake
☕ 8x8 Gooey Butter Coffee Cakes
🧁 Assorted Gooey Buttercups
🍫 Hostess Cake Pieces
🥧 Brown Sugar Cinnamon Poptart Bars
🍪 Chocolate Chip Cookies
🎉 Dunkaroo Cookies
🍪✨ Oatmeal Crème Pie Cookie Sandwiches

See you in the morning!

👔🍰 Father’s Day POP-IN Menu! 🍰👔We’re bringing the sweets for Dad at our Father’s Day Pop-In — TOMORROW (Saturday 6/14) f...
06/14/2025

👔🍰 Father’s Day POP-IN Menu! 🍰👔
We’re bringing the sweets for Dad at our Father’s Day Pop-In — TOMORROW (Saturday 6/14) from 10AM–12PM!

No pre-order needed — just come early and grab your faves while they last! 🎉

💙 Menu:
• 8x8 Original Gooey Buttercakes
• 8x8 Gooey Butter Coffee Cakes
• Assorted Gooey Buttercups
• Cinnamon Roll Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
• Chocolate Chip Cookies
• M&M Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Reese’s PB Cup Stuffed Brownies
• Raspberry Pop-Tart Blondies

📍 College Hill Cakery
🗓️ Saturday 6/14
⏰ 10AM–12PM

PLUS — we’ll also be set up at at Summit Park from 10AM–4PM! Come stock up for the weekend. 🛍️

🧁👔Dad deserves dessert! 👔🧁Our Father’s Day Pre-Orders are LIVE on the site! 🎉We’ve got dad-approved treats to help you c...
06/02/2025

🧁👔Dad deserves dessert! 👔🧁

Our Father’s Day Pre-Orders are LIVE on the site! 🎉

We’ve got dad-approved treats to help you celebrate all the father figures in your life.

🗓️ Order Deadline: Tuesday, 6/10 at NOON
📦 Pickup: During our Father’s Day Pop-In on Saturday, 6/14 from 10AM–12PM

Not local or need to send a gift?
We ship nationwide through 📦

Join us for our Summer Kick-Off Pop-In TOMORROW Saturday, May 24th from 10AM–12PM — no pre-order needed!Menu☀️🍰Gooey But...
05/23/2025

Join us for our Summer Kick-Off Pop-In TOMORROW Saturday, May 24th from 10AM–12PM — no pre-order needed!

Menu☀️🍰
Gooey Buttercakes: 8x8 Original and 8x8 Coffee Cake

Gooey Buttercups: Original, Double Chocolate Chip, Cherry Streusel, Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel

S’mores Sheet Cake Slices

Signature Cookie: Chocolate Chip and Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip

Ice Cream Sundae Cookie Sandwiches

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Magic Bars

Mini Iced Lemon Loaves

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Come stock up on your favorites before the long weekend begins!

💐✨ Celebrate the moms, grandmas, and mother figures in your life with something extra sweet! ✨💐 ...
04/28/2025

💐✨ Celebrate the moms, grandmas, and mother figures in your life with something extra sweet! ✨💐
Our Mother’s Day Pre-Orders are available NOW on the site! 🧁🌸
🗓️ Order Deadline: Monday, 5/5 at NOON
📦 Pickup: Friday, 5/9 from 11AM–1PM
(We’ll be out of town Mother’s Day weekend—so be sure to snag your treats early!) 💖
✨Tap the link in our bio to order now!
Let’s make this Mother’s Day extra special 🌷

🐣✨ POP-IN MENU ✨🐣Swing by this Saturday (4/19 from 10am–12pm) for our Easter Pop-In! ...
04/19/2025

🐣✨ POP-IN MENU ✨🐣
Swing by this Saturday (4/19 from 10am–12pm) for our Easter Pop-In!
🐰💛 Menu:
• 8x8 Original Gooey Buttercakes
• 8x8 Gooey Butter Coffee Cakes
• Assorted Spring Gooey Buttercups
• Caramel Carrot Cupcakes
• Signature Cookies
• Iced Lemon White Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Cadbury Egg Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwiches
• Reese’s Stuffed PB Rice Krispie Treats
• Oreo M&M Sandwich Bars

🐰 Easter is almost here, and so are the sweet treats! 🐣🌷Our Easter Pre-Orders are live on the site! ✨🗓️ Order Deadline: ...
04/07/2025

🐰 Easter is almost here, and so are the sweet treats! 🐣🌷

Our Easter Pre-Orders are live on the site! ✨

🗓️ Order Deadline: Monday, 4/14 at NOON
📦 Pickup: During our Easter Pop-In on Saturday, 4/19 from 10AM–12PM

👉 Order now at collegehillcakery.com (link in bio!)

Join us this Saturday, 3/15, from 10AM - 12PM for a St. Patrick’s Day Pop-In! 🍀🌈🎉 Don’t miss out on your chance to grab ...
03/11/2025

Join us this Saturday, 3/15, from 10AM - 12PM for a St. Patrick’s Day Pop-In! 🍀🌈

🎉 Don’t miss out on your chance to grab some festive goodies for your holiday weekend!

💚 Tag a friend who needs a little extra luck (and sugar! 🍪) this weekend!

Sweeten your Saturday!! Tomorrow 2/15 from 10a-12p is our Valentine’s Pop-In! 💕 Treat yourself to all your favorites and...
02/15/2025

Sweeten your Saturday!! Tomorrow 2/15 from 10a-12p is our Valentine’s Pop-In! 💕 Treat yourself to all your favorites and more:

✨ 8x8 Original & Coffee Cake Gooey Buttercakes
✨ Variety Gooey Buttercups
✨ Mini Heart-Shaped Gooey Buttercakes
✨ Caramel Carrot Cake Slices
✨ Heart-shaped M&M Chocolate Chip Cookies
✨ Red Velvet White Chocolate S’mores Cookies
✨ Chocolate Chip Cookies
✨ Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies
✨ Oreo Stuffed Red Velvet Cookies
✨ PB Brownie Hearts
✨ Chocolate Chip Valentine Cookie Sandwiches
✨ Iced Sugar Cookie Hearts
✨ Red Velvet Cupcakes

You won’t want to miss these!

Valentine’s Day💗💗 Pop-in NEXT Saturday 2/15 from 10am-12pm! We will have a fun VDAY spread! Check back for the final me...
02/11/2025

Valentine’s Day💗

💗 Pop-in NEXT Saturday 2/15 from 10am-12pm! We will have a fun VDAY spread! Check back for the final menu!

💗 Our VDAY pre-order menu is up on the site! You can pre-order for pickup on Friday 2/14, at the pop-in 2/15, OR another time by request! Link in bio

Address

1560 Marlowe Avenue
College Hill, OH
45224

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when College Hill Cakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to College Hill Cakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category