I Like Pie

I Like Pie I Like Pie is permanently closed. We could not have anticipated the outpouring we witnessed during our final two weeks in Pasadena and Claremont.
(487)

To say we feel loved would be an understatement. Thank you for 14 wonderful years.

Missing you all so much this Pi Day!! 🥧 💕.
03/14/2025

Missing you all so much this Pi Day!! 🥧 💕.

Well…none of us want to go home because we don’t want it to end, so our bakers just put out another wave of pies. If you...
02/24/2025

Well…none of us want to go home because we don’t want it to end, so our bakers just put out another wave of pies. If you’re still in the neighborhood, we’re still here 💕.

Remember the ?! A stroll down ILP memory lane would never be complete without it. Thank you Claremont for giving us a c...
02/23/2025

Remember the ?! A stroll down ILP memory lane would never be complete without it. Thank you Claremont for giving us a chance to spread our wings. We’ll be here today until we sell out. Love you all❤️🥧.

Tomorrow, Sunday 2/23 will be the last day of ILP. Seeing you all has brought back so many wonderful memories. 15 years ...
02/22/2025

Tomorrow, Sunday 2/23 will be the last day of ILP. Seeing you all has brought back so many wonderful memories. 15 years ago, I started making these baby pies out of a shared kitchen in Chino and served them at builder grand openings. Opening our first store in Claremont was like coming home. I know so many of you have already made your final visit. I can’t thank you enough for showing up for us. If you haven’t been by yet, maybe we’ll see you tomorrow. XO.

Thank You for Your Support !We are beyond grateful for the love and support you’ve shown us during this time. As we head...
02/21/2025

Thank You for Your Support !
We are beyond grateful for the love and support you’ve shown us during this time. As we head into our final days, here are answers to some of your most asked questions:

🥧 Can I pre-order pies?
We are no longer accepting pre-orders so we can focus on keeping the Claremont shop stocked each day.

🥧 Are there limits on how much I can buy?
To ensure as many of you as possible get to enjoy ILP before we close, we are limiting purchases to 1 per flavor, per item. That means if we have 10 flavors of Jelly Jar pies today, you can grab 1 of each flavor!

🥧 Do you still have ILP mugs, hats, or t-shirts?
These sold out quickly after our announcement, but if we find any extras while packing up, we’ll post about it here!

💬 We know there are still lots of questions, like why we’re closing, what’s next for ILP, and if Annika will share her recipes (or maybe even write a cookbook?!). Stay tuned—Annika will be answering these soon!

For now, come see us, grab your favorite pies, and share your ILP memories with us. We can’t wait to see you. ❤️

🥧 We’ve been selling out early, sometimes as early as 2 or 3 PM! If you want to grab your favorite pies, make sure to co...
02/18/2025

🥧 We’ve been selling out early, sometimes as early as 2 or 3 PM! If you want to grab your favorite pies, make sure to come by earlier. Remember, our last day open in Claremont is the 23rd. Stop by, get your pies, and say hello! 🥧❤️

Dearest friends,After 13 years of crafting pies for our favorite people, I Like Pie will be closing. Thank you for belie...
02/11/2025

Dearest friends,

After 13 years of crafting pies for our favorite people, I Like Pie will be closing.

Thank you for believing in us and supporting us throughout this journey. Your smiles have brightened countless days, and you are the reason we get out of bed at 4 AM every morning. We will miss you more than you can imagine.

Thank you to the people on our team, both past and present. They have enriched our lives and shaped the I Like Pie experience in too many ways to mention. I have had the privilege of working and laughing with these vibrant, resourceful, talented people every day for over a decade. Without them, I Like Pie would not exist.
We will miss being part of our local small business communities. The people behind these businesses are generous and creative, and they contribute significantly to the quality of life in your town. Cherish them, as they need your support now more than ever.

Our final day of operation in Pasadena will be Sunday, February 16, and in Claremont it will be Sunday, February 23. We hope you’ll stop by and say hello one last time.

Thank you all!

Love always,
Annika

Onion Potato Quiche 🥔🧅A classic, cozy quiche that’s all about simple, rich flavors. Buttery crust, roasted potatoes, car...
02/07/2025

Onion Potato Quiche 🥔🧅
A classic, cozy quiche that’s all about simple, rich flavors. Buttery crust, roasted potatoes, caramelized onions, and a blend of Swiss and goat cheese, all baked into a creamy, savory custard. Finished with a sprinkle of fresh parsley.
It’s the kind of pie that feels like home. Stop by our Pasadena or Claremont shop to try it!

Rainy days call for something warm, cozy, and absolutely delicious! Come escape the cold and cozy up at I Like Pie with ...
02/07/2025

Rainy days call for something warm, cozy, and absolutely delicious!
Come escape the cold and cozy up at I Like Pie with our staff favorite—Onion Potato Quiche Pie! Made with a buttery, savory crust, filled with roasted diced potatoes, caramelized onions, and a perfect blend of Swiss and goat cheese, all baked into a rich, savory custard and topped with fresh parsley.

It’s a comfort meal for a chilly day- any day really! Stop by our Pasadena or Claremont shop and treat yourself.

Warm, gooey, and filled with cinnamon-spiced goodness—our Cinnamon Roll Hand Pie is the perfect cozy treat! 🥰✨ With a fl...
01/31/2025

Warm, gooey, and filled with cinnamon-spiced goodness—our Cinnamon Roll Hand Pie is the perfect cozy treat! 🥰✨ With a flaky crust, a rich cinnamon-sugar filling, and a sweet vanilla glaze, it’s like your favorite cinnamon roll but in the perfect handheld form. Who’s grabbing one? 🙋‍♀️🥧

It’s National Chocolate Cake Day! But let’s be real—if cake isn’t your thing (we get it, it’s not for everyone), why not...
01/27/2025

It’s National Chocolate Cake Day! But let’s be real—if cake isn’t your thing (we get it, it’s not for everyone), why not celebrate with our Turtle Brownie Pie instead?
This chocolate lover’s dream has:
🍫 A rich chocolate custard filling
🍶 Sweet cream cheese both inside and on top
🌰 Candied pecans
🍮 A drizzle of caramel to tie it all together

Who needs cake when you can have pie that’s basically a brownie in disguise? Soooo come have some Pie on National Chocolate Cake Day... But it's also a brownie..... Just stop on by! :P

One of your favorite classic desserts is now in pie form! Banana Split Pie—a slice of pure joy you didn’t know you neede...
01/27/2025

One of your favorite classic desserts is now in pie form! Banana Split Pie—a slice of pure joy you didn’t know you needed. 🥧

Here’s what’s packed into this masterpiece:
✨ A buttery graham cracker crust
🍫 Layers of fresh sliced bananas, rich chocolate fudge, creamy vanilla pastry cream, and tangy pineapple cream cheese
🍒 Topped with fluffy fresh whipped cream, candied pecans for a little crunch, and of course—a cherry to complete the perfect bite!

This pie is bursting with all the flavors of a classic banana split but made even better with a buttery crust and the care only a handmade pie can bring. It’s nostalgia served on a plate.

Don’t miss out—this sweet treat won’t be around forever! Stop by and grab a slice (or the whole pie!) before it’s gone.

Address

175 North Indian Hill, Suite 102B
Claremont, CA
91711

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when I Like Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to I Like Pie:

Shortcuts

Share