Good Pie Y’all was born out of a desire to love and serve our community well during a difficult season in our family.
In 2017 our church began a campaign to raise money for Back2Back Ministries. Our hearts were much bigger than our very meager finances, so we sat down around the kitchen table on a snowy Winter afternoon to brainstorm how we might be able to help. Suddenly our oldest daughter said, “Mom, you’re great at making pie. Let’s make pies and sell them.” A few days later we began making pies to support orphan-care around the globe and in one short month we had met our goal of raising $1,000.
What started out as a family project to help others, became a way to help our family make ends meet through a long, hard season of unemployment.
In the Spring on 2018, Good Pie Y’all moved from our home kitchen to St. Paul United Methodist Church. Thousands of pies later here we are.
Good Pie Y’all is truly a labor of love. With every pie, batch of yeast dough and family-friendly meal we make, we hope to make your busy life a little easier, give you a few more precious minutes with your family and sweeten your most special days. Our goal is to bring people together one slice at a time.
At Good Pie Y’all our Mission is to love and serve our community well. We donate ten percent of all our profits to help families and children facing challenging circumstances. It is our joy to share what God has given with our community.
“When you reap the harvest of your land, you shall not reap your field right up to its edge, neither shall you gather the gleanings after your harvest. And you shall not strip your vineyard bare, neither shall you gather the fallen grapes of your vineyard. You shall leave them for the poor and for the sojourner: I am the Lord your God” Leviticus 19:9-10
SWEET PIES
Good Pie Y’all desserts are a great way to turn a regular weekend meal into a celebration! Every pie is inspired by the freshest ingredients of the season.
Sweet Pies come in a variety of sizes; 2” Pie Babies, 3” “Cutie Pies”, 5” “Pint Size Pies”, 9” Pies. Prices range from $3 for pie babies to $25-$30 for full sized pies.
We offer a variety of sweet pies each week and are happy to accommodate special orders for special milestones and events and as we are able.
Our signature flavors include, Salted Caramel Apple Streusel Pie, Key Lime Pie, Southern Peach Pie, Fudge Pie, White Chocolate Raspberry Pie, Coconut Cream Pie, Lemon Berry Tart, Triple Berry Pie. We also offer many seasonal options in addition to our signature flavors.
FAMILY-FRIENDLY MEALS
SAVORY POT PIES
We offer one dish family-friendly take and bake pot pies every week. They are picky eater approved and are great meals for busy school nights or to take to a friend going through a hard time.
Pot Pies can be purchased in several sizes; Set of 4 - 5” personal pies, 9” (serves 4-5), 9x13 (serves 8-10). Prices range from $22.50-$60.
Some of our signature flavors include Chicken Pot Pie, Pot Roast Pot Pie, Taco Pie, Spaghetti Pie and Shepherd’s Pie. Our menu also includes seasonal pot pies and quiches in addition to our signature flavors.
HOLIDAY CINNAMON ROLLS
One of our very favorite Christmas traditions has become baking hundreds and hundreds of cinnamon rolls to give to our friends, family, neighbors and teachers. We’d love to share our tradition with you.
Cinnamon rolls are available in 9” pans and 9x13” pans. They make fantastic holiday gifts, come packaged in cellophane tied with holiday ribbon, and are wonderful warmed up on Christmas morning.
