Mulligan’s Pie Shop

Mulligan’s Pie Shop Scratch-made pies and custom sugar cookies

Stocking Stuffer idea!! Set of 4 mini cookies $5 🎅🏻🎄☃️🍪
11/30/2025

Stocking Stuffer idea!! Set of 4 mini cookies $5 🎅🏻🎄☃️🍪

What is your preferred chocolate chip cookie? For me, I love a thin, extra crispy cookie with mini chips for a better co...
07/05/2025

What is your preferred chocolate chip cookie?

For me, I love a thin, extra crispy cookie with mini chips for a better cookie to chip ratio.

Made quick biscuits last night and they were SO good. Had the leftovers for breakfast with strawberries and whipped crea...
06/19/2025

Made quick biscuits last night and they were SO good. Had the leftovers for breakfast with strawberries and whipped cream 😋 YUM!

Summer time is the best time for fruit pies! Berries, cherries, and more! Yum 😋
06/17/2025

Summer time is the best time for fruit pies! Berries, cherries, and more! Yum 😋

Look at these Baptism cookies!!! I say it every time, but this time I mean it: this is my favorite set!
06/06/2025

Look at these Baptism cookies!!! I say it every time, but this time I mean it: this is my favorite set!

This color palette 🩷🩵💜💚
06/03/2025

This color palette 🩷🩵💜💚

Sketches for upcoming cookie set! Can’t wait for this one!Sketches are always a part of the design consultation for my c...
05/29/2025

Sketches for upcoming cookie set! Can’t wait for this one!
Sketches are always a part of the design consultation for my custom cookie orders. It’s a chance for clients to see various options and for me to work out any kinks. For example, I sketched two sets for this client but I ended up only sending one for approval. After sketching, the second set just didn’t look right for what the client wanted. (Since she was a friend I sent her the second set and she agreed it wasn’t exactly right for this specific order)
Stay tuned for the final results!!

Sometimes I need my own sweet treat 🍋‍🟩
05/20/2025

Sometimes I need my own sweet treat 🍋‍🟩

Can you tell this is a Gluten-Free pie? Me either! I love being able to accommodate customers with gluten allergies or s...
05/14/2025

Can you tell this is a Gluten-Free pie? Me either! I love being able to accommodate customers with gluten allergies or sensitivities. Now no one has to miss out on delicious pies!
Hoping to find a GF cookie recipe too!!!

May is always a busy month: first communions, graduations, Mother’s Day, the pool opening. I hope these cookies make you...
05/12/2025

May is always a busy month: first communions, graduations, Mother’s Day, the pool opening. I hope these cookies make you smile on this Monday!

Tea party baby shower! These were a delight from start to finish 🫖🩷🩵🩷🩵🫖
05/08/2025

Tea party baby shower! These were a delight from start to finish 🫖🩷🩵🩷🩵🫖

These might be my favorite cookies I’ve made to date! First communion set!
04/30/2025

These might be my favorite cookies I’ve made to date! First communion set!

Address

Cincinnati, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mulligan’s Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mulligan’s Pie Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category