05/23/2026
When I first asked my Aunt Elaine for her monster cookie recipe, the same one sheād been bringing to family gatherings for as long as I can remember, I expected a simple hand-me-down recipe.
What I got instead was a page full of red flags.
No flour?
No vanilla?
No salt?
Six eggs?!
And multiple measuring units, just to keep things interesting.
Surely there had to be typos.
But there werenāt.
What made this recipe so different from every monster cookie recipe Iād seen online⦠was exactly what made it so good.
So I trusted it.
I made it exactly as written, then slowly made it my ownāconverting everything to grams for consistency, tweaking here and there, and baking them over and over again until they became part of the fabric of my kitchen.
In the beginning of my sourdough era, I even asked myself: How can I turn these into a sourdough cookie?
And then it hit meā¦maybe I shouldnāt.
Not everything needs to be sourdough.
These cookies were already perfect in their own lane: naturally gluten free, nostalgic, and rooted in a vintage recipe that had already stood the test of time.
About a year ago, I transformed that recipe again, this time into a baking mix, so more of you could bring a little piece of that tradition into your own kitchens.
And every single time I make them, it feels like a quiet reminder of my Aunt Elaineā¦of family gatherings, shared recipes, and the kind of love that gets passed down through generations.
And honestly? These cookies are a lot like The Cottonwood Kitchen.
Theyāve been through tweaks and turns. Moments of uncertainty. Plenty of experimenting.
But the foundation has always stayed the same: simple ingredients, a lot of heart, and something worth sharing.
Thatās what these monster cookies are to me.
Not just our best seller.
A little window into who we are.