Pewter Spoon Cafe

05/27/2026

It’s our favorite time of the year 🌞 the patio tables and chairs are out and the Prosecco is ice cold! Stop by and join us for dinner and a drink to welcome summer.

04/17/2026

Come join the team! We’re hiring for both kitchen and barista positions. Flexible hours but weekend availability a must! No formal kitchen/coffee experience necessary but a love for both is needed. DM for more info

02/25/2026

A quick moment for our scones… 😍

When we first opened the Pewter Spoon, we knew we wanted to offer a couple of options of baked goods for those looking to pair something sweet with their coffee order, and we determined that scones were just perfect for our work flow. They’re quick to prep, bake fairly quickly, and are just lightly sweet enough to give you what you’re looking for. But what we didn’t realize is just how much of a demand for baked goods we would see from the community!

What started out as “we’ll offer two different flavors of scones each day, maybe a batch of chocolate chip cookies once in a while,” very quickly became baking multiple batches of sweets every single day as you all quickly devoured what we baked up at the shop. These days we regularly bake cakes, quick breads, cookies, muffins, cardamom bullar, bars and brownies, and of course, our tried and true, our day ones — scones.

Thanks for loving our baked goods and for letting us get creative with our different offerings. We love getting to sweeten your day just a little bit. ❣️

02/18/2026

We’re excited for the best Dining Week yet! To highlight our extended hours, we’re running a dinner special from 5-8 for dine in only. Stop in after work and enjoy dinner for two!

02/13/2026

It’s a quiet winter day in Cazenovia, NY but the lake effect snow is behind us (for now!). As you shovel your driveway or start working on that house project you’ve been putting off, we hope you’ll stop in for a little caffeinated treat or some lunch. Maybe take a quick stroll down Albany St and stop by the incredible local shops our village has to offer.

You may have heard that it’s been a particularly tough winter to be a small business. It’s true. If you can, show some love to your favorite places this winter. In a fast-paced world moving seemingly ever faster, we sometimes need that gentle reminder to slow down and appreciate the local spots that make our community so special ❤️

02/10/2026

Back in October, published this piece about Medhat and our family who hosted him when he was a foreign exchange student in Caz from 2022-2023. It’s an excellent piece written by journalist Patrick McCarthy, who listened to our story with care and delivered it with thoughtfulness and intentionality. We are so grateful for the opportunity to have it all in writing.

So much has changed since Medhat returned home to Gaza in May 2023, and we are grateful that both he and Andy (his foreign exchange student “brother”) were able to step into our lives and make as big of an impact on us and on Cazenovia as they did. We’ve had people share their stories about how Medhat left an impact on them, and we absolutely cherish hearing those.

For those of you who had the pleasure of meeting Medhat while he was here, you know just what a nice kid he is. Sadly, he and his family have gone through a lot since October 2023, including both his father’s and mother’s homes being demolished by airstrikes, being displaced to Egypt, and missing his senior year of high school due to displacement. While they don’t live in constant fear or aerial strikes, the emotional scars of what they witnessed will live within them forever.

Please help us by visiting the link in our bio and donating what you can to Medhat’s family. We are thrilled to have the opportunity to visit him, his mom, and two little sisters in April where we will be able to deliver the donations in-person. We’re hoping to make the biggest possible impact, so considering donating what you can and share the link to this GoFundMe to a few other people in your life who are willing to listen to our story. While you’re at it, leave a comment about your Medhat story — how you met or what you remember of his short time here in Cazenovia.

Thank you ❤️

DONATE HERE: https://gofund.me/531c1a320

READ THE ARTICLE HERE: https://centralcurrent.org/a-home-for-medhat/

02/08/2026

Sorry folks, but we have to close tomorrow (Sunday) due to a broken furnace. We hope to be able to open on Tuesday!

02/02/2026

Winter Fest in Caz is THIS weekend! That means it’s your last week to purchase raffle tickets to benefit and enter for a chance to win a super cool raffle basket made with goods collected by yours truly. Our lucky winner will be announced on Monday 🎉

All the participating small business owners work really hard to make events like Winter Fest special, so we hope you’ll take advantage of all the wonderful activities we’ve got lined up! Whether you go cross country skiing on the local trails, partake in ice skating at Burton Street, try out the offerings from , or sip all the hot cocoas on the hot cocoa crawl, there’s something going on for everybody. Go follow to check out the weekend lineup!

11/23/2025

Become the ultimate Pewter Spoon super fan! Live right above us. Charming historic upstairs apartment with new amenities and appliances for rent in the heart of Cazenovia village. Live a minute’s walk away from your favorite Cazenovia shops, cafes, and restaurants, and enjoy one of only two apartments in the village with a balcony overlooking the comings and goings on Albany St!

This 2+ bedroom, 1.5 bathroom apartment is suitable for a work-from-home couple as there is ample space for 2 separate offices. Full kitchen with an induction range, microwave, refrigerator, and dishwasher. Large living room and optional dining room opportunities in the space, or living room and very spacious primary bedroom!

Parking for two cars available in lot behind building. No access to the apartment from the back parking lot. Apartment is located on the second floor, and is directly above a local coffee shop and vintage store. Rent includes heat and electric.

More info at the listing here! https://www.facebook.com/marketplace/item/2919940465061469/?ref=search

10/31/2025

Please consider donating! Thank you to our friends at Critz Farms for setting up this important fundraiser.

Our hardworking crew at Critz Farms needs your help. Their isl… Patrick Allen needs your support for Disaster Relief for Jamaican Families of Critz Farms Crew