Cheesecake & Company

Cheesecake & Company Cheesecake & Company would like to provide cheesecake for any occasion you choose to celebrate.

Whether you are celebrating a birthday, a holiday, a bridal shower, a wedding, or simply "just because"--consider cheesecake as a unique dessert alternative. Our recipes create a lighter and fluffier cheesecake texture (resembling a rich mousse) as compared to some of the denser versions that traditional techniques and recipes produce.

A little life update --In June, my husband and I had our 2nd child. Following his birth, we moved back to Ohio this Summ...
10/30/2025

A little life update --

In June, my husband and I had our 2nd child. Following his birth, we moved back to Ohio this Summer to be closer to our families.

In terms of baking and cheesecakes, I am taking steps towards certifying my new kitchen as a Licensed Home Bakery and obtaining my business license. I currently don't have a set timeline for accepting orders, but I will keep you posted. Thank you for the continued support.

I hope everyone has a great holiday season!
Mikaela

Today is the end of a sweet chapter in my baking journey as we closed on the sale of my building at 39 S. Main St. I'm f...
01/03/2025

Today is the end of a sweet chapter in my baking journey as we closed on the sale of my building at 39 S. Main St.

I'm forever grateful to my husband, family, friends, and the community that has supported me and my business.

Here are some of my favorite bakery memories over the past few years.

I am completely sold out of cheesecake. The line started at 7:40am and was steady until my supply depleted. That was the...
11/23/2024

I am completely sold out of cheesecake.
The line started at 7:40am and was steady until my supply depleted. That was the most I've ever baked for a single week (not even day) of sales.
Thank you for a great turn out.
I appreciate the support! ❤

Happy Thanksgiving!

Saturday is THE day! I will be open in the bakery (39 S. Main St.) from 8am until I'm sold out. Buy now, freeze for late...
11/21/2024

Saturday is THE day!
I will be open in the bakery (39 S. Main St.) from 8am until I'm sold out.
Buy now, freeze for later!

I will ONLY have half and whole cheesecakes available. Everything is sold first come, first serve. No pre-orders, no holds, or reservations.

Cheesecake Halves:
- Classic Vanilla $19
- Classic w/ Strawberry $21
- Classic w/ Cherry $21
- Plain Pumpkin $21
- Caramel Apple $22
- Turtle $22
- Cookies & Cream $22
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate $22
- Caramel Pecan $22
- Christmas Tree $23

Whole Cheesecakes:
- Classic Vanilla $38
- Classic w/ Strawberry $42
- Chocolate Chip $42
- Plain Pumpkin $42
- Triple Berry $44
- Caramel Pecan $44
- Turtle $44
- Cookies & Cream $44
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate $44
- Pumpkin Streusel $44
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch $44
- Caramel Apple $44

***Edited to Add: This is not an official re-opening. I am in the process of selling my building. This is a just a popping open to sell some cheesecake for Thanksgiving. Thanks!

If you're in or around Mt. Sterling... I'm set up today at Freedom Church from 10am-2pm for their first Merry Marketplac...
11/02/2024

If you're in or around Mt. Sterling... I'm set up today at Freedom Church from 10am-2pm for their first Merry Marketplace !

I have slices of Pumpkin Streusel and Triple Berry Cheesecake, Triple Chocolate Brownies, Pumpkin Bread, and a list of whole cheesecakes available as well.

Stay tuned, I will be popping open in my storefront closer to Thanksgiving for some holiday cheesecake 👀

Thank you!!!It's been a pleasure baking for you all over the past few years.I'm now sold out and will be closed.
08/29/2024

Thank you!!!
It's been a pleasure baking for you all over the past few years.
I'm now sold out and will be closed.

Open:Thursday 2pm - 7pmFriday 2pm - 7pm (as inventory permits)Slice + Flight Flavors:- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch- Blackberr...
08/28/2024

Open:
Thursday 2pm - 7pm
Friday 2pm - 7pm (as inventory permits)

Slice + Flight Flavors:
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch
- Blackberry
- Classic Vanilla
- Apple Butter
- Baker's Choice
- Cinnamon Roll 📸

Cheesecake Halves:
- Classic Vanilla
- Classic w/ Strawberry
- Classic w/ Cherry
- Triple Berry
- Blackberry
- Strawberry Swirl
- Caramel Pecan
- Turtle
- Cookies & Cream
- Salted Caramel
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate
- Butterscotch Chip
- Chocolate Chip
- Pumpkin Streusel
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch
- Apple Butter
- Cinnamon Roll

Whole Cheesecakes:
- Classic w/ Strawberry $40
- Chocolate Chip $40

I will also have Triple Chocolate Brownies and mini loaves of Pumpkin Bread available!

Lastly, a run down of some of the items on the sale table...
Coffee maker, microwave, coffee carafes with pump, cake stand, electric water kettle, wooden crates, flower pots, potted plants, picture frames, coffee mugs, cardboard serving boats, and whatever other items get added before tomorrow...

Today has been a Thursday SELL OUT 😳I will be closed the remainder of the week and will reopen next Thursday at 2pm. I'l...
08/22/2024

Today has been a Thursday SELL OUT 😳

I will be closed the remainder of the week and will reopen next Thursday at 2pm. I'll be busy baking in the meantime.

From the bottom of my heart, thank you for all of the support!

Apparently I was really feeling the Caramel flavors this week 😅Open:Thursday 2pm - 7pmFriday 2pm - 7pmSaturday 8am - noo...
08/21/2024

Apparently I was really feeling the Caramel flavors this week 😅

Open:
Thursday 2pm - 7pm
Friday 2pm - 7pm
Saturday 8am - noon (as inventory permits)

Slice + Flight Flavors:
- Butterfinger
- Classic Vanilla
- Mixed Berry Streusel
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch
- Turtle
- Caramel Apple 📸

Cheesecake Halves:
- Pumpkin Streusel
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch
- Apple Butter
- Caramel Pecan
- Turtle
- Chocolate Chip
- Strawberry Swirl
- Classic Vanilla
- Classic w/ Strawberry
- Classic w/ Cherry
- Peach Cobbler
- Caramel Apple
- Butterfinger
- Cookies & Cream
- Cinnamon Roll
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate

Whole Cheesecakes:
- Classic w/ Strawberry $40

I am SOLD OUT and will be closed, Saturday August 17.I will reopen Thursday at 2pm.Thanks!!
08/16/2024

I am SOLD OUT and will be closed, Saturday August 17.

I will reopen Thursday at 2pm.
Thanks!!

Open until 7pm tonight!**Flavor options will change as inventory sells. I'll try to update as I get time.The only slices...
08/16/2024

Open until 7pm tonight!

**Flavor options will change as inventory sells. I'll try to update as I get time.

The only slices I have left are Pumpkin Streusel 📸

Cheesecake Halves:
- Classic Vanilla
- GF Classic Vanilla
- Classic w/ Strawberry
- Classic w/ Cherry
- Caramel Pecan
- Salted Caramel
- Turtle
- Cookies & Cream
- Butterfinger
- Pumpkin Streusel 🎃
- Chocolate Chip
- Butterscotch Chip

** All the Triple Chocolate Brownies are gone.

I will be closing the end of August, and although it's a little early I wanted to give my Fall flavors a chance to hit t...
08/14/2024

I will be closing the end of August, and although it's a little early I wanted to give my Fall flavors a chance to hit the menu over the next few weeks.

Also, just for some clarification since I've gotten a few questions...only the building is for sale. I am not selling my actual cheesecake business or recipes.

Open:
Thursday 2pm - 7pm
Friday 2pm - 7pm
Saturday 8am - noon (as inventory permits)

Slice + Flight Flavors:
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate
- Triple Berry
- Sugar Cookie
- Pumpkin Streusel
- Apple Butter 📸🍎🍏
- Baker's Choice

Cheesecake Halves:
- Classic Vanilla
- GF Classic Vanilla
- Classic w/ Strawberry
- Classic w/ Cherry
- Blackberry
- Triple Berry
- Caramel Pecan
- Pineapple Upside Down
- Salted Caramel
- Turtle
- Cookies & Cream
- Butterfinger
- Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate
- Apple Butter
- Pumpkin Streusel 🎃
- Pumpkin Caramel Crunch 🎃
- Chocolate Chip
- Butterscotch Chip

Whole Cheesecakes:
- Classic Vanilla $36

Triple Chocolate Brownies will be available while supplies last!

Items will continue to be added to the sale table as I prepare to close!

Address

County Road 28
Cardington, OH
43315

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cheesecake & Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category