M and M's Sweet Retreat

10/18/2026

Look who’s back! 🍪✨

It’s been a few weeks, but our house-made Oatmeal Cream Pies are officially back in the case today!

Soft, chewy, and packed with sweet cream filling—stop by and grab one before they're all gone! 😋👇

10/18/2026

🤤🤤 yummm! Football and pizza? Nothing beats this combo!!

🏈 SUNDAY FAMILY PIZZA DAY! 🍕🥤

Skip the cooking and bring the crew to Cheesy Does It today! Catch the games on our 6 SCREENS while the kids relax in our open family room. 📺✨

⭐️ TODAY'S DINE-IN FAMILY BUNDLE: $19.99 (+tax)

• 1 Large 1-Topping Pizza 🍕
• 3 Drinks of Your Choice (Including custom Dirty Sodas!) 🥤
(Save nearly $9 off regular price! Valid today 11 AM - 8 PM for sit-down tables only.)

We are self-serve—just order at the counter and grab any open table! 🙌

📍 133 South Broadway St. Butler, Indiana
📞 260-337-0222
🌐 eatcheesy.com

10/16/2026

Brrr… it’s chilly and drizzly out there! 🌧️ This calls for sweet treats! 🍂☕

Warm up today with our Apple C***r Rice Krispie Treats or a classic Monster Cookie—the absolute ultimate coffee companions!

Stop by and grab yours today!

10/15/2026

Think you know pumpkin pie? Think again. 🥧🔥

​We took the classic cozy favorite and gave it a gooey, melt-in-your-mouth upgrade: Marshmallow Pumpkin Pie! 🍂✨

​Picture rich, warmly spiced pumpkin filling folded with light, gooey melted marshmallows and whipped cream. It’s light, creamy, and ridiculously good. 🤤

​📍 Drop by today and grab a slice before the batch sells out!

10/14/2026

Fall flavors and fan-favorite returns! 🍂✨

Here’s what’s fresh on our menu this week:

🍎 The Big Comebacks: Candy Apple Dumplings & Caramel Apple Pie

🍪 Seasonal Treats: Angel Gingerbread & a Ginger & Spice Crackle cookie

🫐 Bakery Classic: Blueberry Muffins

Stop by and grab your cozy treats before they’re gone! ☕

10/11/2026

Big news! 🎉 Our brand-new sign is officially complete and we couldn’t be more happy with how it turned out! 🎨✨

Huge thank you to local artist Chris Lesley for bringing our vision to life so masterfully. If you’re looking for custom murals or artwork, he’s your guy! 🙌

Come by, check it out, and let us know what you think! 👇

10/11/2026

Thank you to everyone who came out to support and participate in yesterday's Harvest Festival! 🌾🍂 And a big thank you to all who stopped in for sweet treats—we appreciate all the support this community continues to give us! ❤️

Speaking of support, we had another special order go out this weekend for a class reunion! 🎓✨

Keep us in mind for any of your upcoming events—we’d love to help make them extra sweet! 🧁🎉

10/10/2026

Ready for the Harvest Festival here in Butler today! 🍂🎃🍁

The bakery case is FULL today! 🥧✨

Stop by today for:

Coconut Cream Pie
Butterscotch Pecan Pie
Cookie Butter Brownies
Chocolate Strawberry Puppy Chow
Chocolate Peanut Bars
Plus a few slices left of our Sugar Cream Pie and Pumpkin Shortbread Bars

🎃🍂 Fall Cookie Alert: We’ve added a limited run of Caramel Sugar Cookies and Pumpkin Snickerdoodles to our usual cookie lineup!

🍦 Don't forget to cool down with some ice cream—enjoy it in a cup, topped high, as an ice cream sandwich, or in a float!

Come treat yourself before your favorites sell out! 😋

10/07/2026

🎃 It’s officially Pumpkin Season at the bakery! 🍂

Here’s what’s fresh in the case this week:

✨ Pumpkin Snickerdoodle Cookies
✨ Pumpkin Shortbread Bars (so fresh they’re literally still cooling, so no picture yet!)
🥧 Sugar Cream Pie
🍏 Caramel Apple Pie

Stop by and grab your fall favorites before they’re gone! Which one are you trying first? 👇

10/04/2026

🎃 ONE WEEK UNTIL BUTLER'S HARVEST FESTIVAL! 🎃🍂
Saturday, October 10, 2026
2–5 PM
Downtown Butler
Bring the whole family for an afternoon packed with FREE family fun! ❤️
🎃 Kids Pumpkin Decorating Contest
🎯 Kids Games
🌾 FFA Straw Maze
🏆 Farmer Olympics
🌱 Rooted in Butler Planter Auction
🚗 Cruise-In
🍂 And SO MUCH MORE!
Come celebrate fall, support our community, and enjoy a fun-filled afternoon right here in Downtown Butler!