Heavenly Pies

Heavenly Pies Homemade pies made to order. Over 20 Varieties! $25 each. Not limited to pies only however! Delivery Available in Brookville area.

Every pie is baked with the freshest of ingredients using delicious homemade recipes that were passed on to me from the "Pie Lady of Franklin County." Offering buckeyes, cheesecakes & cake truffles

Now taking orders for the Holidays, call today! Pie choices are Apple, Dutch Apple, Candy Apple, Caramel Apple, Cherry, Peach, Pumpkin,Blackberry, Butterscotch, Banana Cream,Custard, Coconut Cream, Key

Lime, Pecan, Peanut Butter, Sweet Potato, Raisin, Rhubarb, Strawberry - Rhubarb, Sugar Cream, Coconut Custard, and Chocolate. You have a choose of a whipped topping of meringue on cream pies. Cheesecakes, plain, caramel, and caramel pecan.

If simple questions can not be answered regarding orders the answer will be no!
06/25/2025

If simple questions can not be answered regarding orders the answer will be no!

Time is ticking to get your pie orders ASAP. I am limited on the number I can donwoth working as well. All baked in glas...
11/22/2024

Time is ticking to get your pie orders ASAP. I am limited on the number I can donwoth working as well.
All baked in glass pie plates and boxed nicely for easy transport. All options are $25 each.

Pick up at Shear Designs Beauty Salon Tuesday and Wednesday 11am - 6:00 pm
Return pie plates at the same location.

What can I bake for you?

11/13/2024

What is your favorite pie for Thanksgiving?

Mine is Bourbon Pecan Pie 🥧 😋

Get those pie orders in before it's too late.No orders except after November 22rd.Time ⏲️ is ticking!
11/12/2024

Get those pie orders in before it's too late.

No orders except after November 22rd.

Time ⏲️ is ticking!

Message me for your holiday pie orders. All pictures are my pies!
11/08/2024

Message me for your holiday pie orders. All pictures are my pies!

It's that time of year again where I am taking those holiday orders. I make almost any pie you can think of. All are $25...
10/15/2024

It's that time of year again where I am taking those holiday orders. I make almost any pie you can think of. All are $25 baked in glass pie plates that need to be returned asap after use.

Let me know what you need and date requested. Pick up at Shear Designs in Brookville.

04/03/2024

Does anyone have 4 walkie talkies I can use for Monday for the eclipse??

I will be baking this Friday. If you are wanting a pie let me know.
01/17/2024

I will be baking this Friday. If you are wanting a pie let me know.

I hope you all enjoyed your Thanksgiving pies. Please return your pie plates asap to Shear Designs or my daughter's hous...
12/03/2023

I hope you all enjoyed your Thanksgiving pies.

Please return your pie plates asap to Shear Designs or my daughter's house. Christmas order are coming in.

Why don't I just use disposable? They are nit sturdy. The glass adds a homemade touch. You could also pass it off as your own if yiu wish 😆. It's my personal touch and a way to stay small town.

Address

6059 Neukam Road
Brookville, IN
47012

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Heavenly Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Heavenly Pies:

Shortcuts

Share