Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe Bagel Island specializes in New York Style Bagels made fresh daily along with a full line of breakfast and lunch options.

She’s juicy, she’s stacked, she’s everything we’ve ever wanted. 😮‍💨🥪 Our roast beef sandwich is giving main character en...
10/22/2026

She’s juicy, she’s stacked, she’s everything we’ve ever wanted. 😮‍💨🥪 Our roast beef sandwich is giving main character energy, and honestly? Your usual order could never. Come hungry, leave happy, and try not to fall in love on the first bite. 🤍

10/22/2026

We will be closed today.
We will reopen Friday for the weekend!
🥯🏝️🧟‍♂️🧞‍♀️🦄

Wish you were here… preferably with a bagel in hand. ☀️🥯Sending a little sunshine, salty air, and island flavor straight...
10/15/2026

Wish you were here… preferably with a bagel in hand. ☀️🥯

Sending a little sunshine, salty air, and island flavor straight from Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe. Stop by and taste a little piece of paradise in the Florida Keys!

📍Big Pine Key, Florida — your postcard from paradise awaits.

Ocean breeze, bagel dreams. Shakespeare could never.Come get your little slice of paradise (and your favorite bagel) her...
10/13/2026

Ocean breeze, bagel dreams. Shakespeare could never.

Come get your little slice of paradise (and your favorite bagel) here at Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe. The view is better with a bagel in hand. 🥯🌴

10/13/2026

What more could you need than a little Jimmy Buffett, a bagel by the water, and nowhere else to be? 🌴🥯

10/08/2026

Money can’t buy happiness… but it can buy you a bagel from Bagel Island, and that’s pretty much the same thing. 🥯

Treat yourself to the bagel you’ve been thinking about all day. Stop by Bagel Island, grab your favorite, and make your day a little better.

Come get your bagel — you know you want to. 👀

The yin and yang of the everything bagel. 🥯Sesame. Poppy. A little salty, a little nutty, and somehow the perfect match ...
10/06/2026

The yin and yang of the everything bagel. 🥯

Sesame. Poppy. A little salty, a little nutty, and somehow the perfect match every time.

Which side are you picking? 👀

10/01/2026

Nothing is wrong with me. I just think you should keep me in your thoughts the next time you need a bagel.

You know… for my well-being. For your well-being. Really, it’s a public service.

See you at Bagel Island. 🥯

09/29/2026

So sorry to make you drool like this… but we HAD to show you the breakfast sandwich lineup.

Fresh bagels, stacked sandwiches, crispy bacon, melty cheese… you get the idea.

Consider this your sign to stop scrolling and come get breakfast. We’ll see you at Bagel Island. 🥯

Address

205 Key Deer Boulevard
Big Pine Key, FL
33043

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7am - 2pm
Thursday 7am - 2pm
Friday 7am - 2pm
Saturday 7am - 2pm
Sunday 7am - 1pm

Telephone

+13058729912

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe:

Shortcuts

Share

Category