Mueller's Bakery

Directions Website

Mueller's Bakery "Where Quality Makes the Difference" The signature product of Mueller's has to be the crumb cake. The product line has something for everyone.
(1073)

Mueller's began over 100 years ago and has evolved as far as modern baking is concerned, while holding tight to the old-fashioned appeal of yesteryear where service, quality, product and atmosphere exist in a storybook-setting town. The original formula is still used and hoards of people come from near and far to get Mueller's crumb. It is shipped all over the world for those who have to have it and can't find anything comparable locally. There are donuts, danish and gourmet pastries along with a wide selection of cakes, cookies and pies as well as all of the holiday and seasonal favorites. In addition, many a future bride and groom have found their "dream" cake at Mueller's. We have built a strong reputation for our wedding cakes, pastry and cookies platters and so on. Also, a section of sugar-free products is available offering more choices for those with diet restrictions.

We ♥️ Saturday afternoons w/ raspberry pretzels @ Mueller’s! Open today until 6!🥨
10/17/2026

We ♥️ Saturday afternoons w/ raspberry pretzels @ Mueller’s! Open today until 6!🥨

Addie and Kaylee say today is an awesome day for a Mueller’s breakfast! Open today 6:30-6!✨🥐🍂☕️
10/17/2026

Addie and Kaylee say today is an awesome day for a Mueller’s breakfast! Open today 6:30-6!✨🥐🍂☕️

We say never skip dessert and our Fall layer cakes are a weekend must! Open until 6 today!🎃🍂🍰✨
10/16/2026

We say never skip dessert and our Fall layer cakes are a weekend must! Open until 6 today!🎃🍂🍰✨

Makana says it’s a good day for chocolate croissants and a new Mueller’s mug for your morning coffee! We’re OPEN TODAY 6...
10/16/2026

Makana says it’s a good day for chocolate croissants and a new Mueller’s mug for your morning coffee! We’re OPEN TODAY 6:30-6!☕️🥐✨

All of the Fall/Halloween happy vibes @ Mueller’s✨Never skip dessert, we’re here until 5 today!🍰🧡🖤
10/15/2026

All of the Fall/Halloween happy vibes @ Mueller’s✨Never skip dessert, we’re here until 5 today!🍰🧡🖤

NEW signature Mueller’s mugs are here! Open today until 5!😍🍂✨
10/15/2026

NEW signature Mueller’s mugs are here! Open today until 5!😍🍂✨

Look who made her way back over the bridge—just in time for pumpkin season! Open today until 5!🎃🍰✨
10/14/2026

Look who made her way back over the bridge—just in time for pumpkin season! Open today until 5!🎃🍰✨

Some midweek happy @ Mueller’s🍩Open today until 5!🍂
10/14/2026

Some midweek happy @ Mueller’s🍩Open today until 5!🍂

10/13/2026

We have tiramisu cake slices back in our fridge case! Open today until 5!🍰✨🍂😋

Lil monster cookies for October because everyone loves Halloween! Open until 6 today!👁️👾🍪👻
10/10/2026

Lil monster cookies for October because everyone loves Halloween! Open until 6 today!👁️👾🍪👻

Address

80 Bridge Avenue
Bay Head, NJ
08742

Opening Hours

Tuesday 6:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 6:30am - 5pm
Thursday 6:30am - 5pm
Friday 6:30am - 6pm
Saturday 6:30am - 6pm
Sunday 6:30am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mueller's Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category