Bay Pony Bakery

08/05/2023

Bridal shower prep! 👰‍♀️😍🍪

07/08/2023

Thank you to everyone who ordered Cookies for Willow! Orders are underway and will start shipping/delivering this week.

Thank you for your help!

07/03/2023

Life got busy, but then it slowed down. The very pony after which this home bakery is named got sick, and all of a sudden it was easier to focus on what was important, one of those things being lots and lots of time with her.

Long story short, she showed no signs of illness until she showed ALL the signs of illness. She was diagnosed with a squamous cell carcinoma tumor in her bladder, had it removed by an incredible team at Cornell University, and just over two weeks post-surgery, continues to show us how brave, trusting, and freaking solid she is. She's a rockstar and has officially inspired the re-launch of our favorite hobby.

When you purchase Cookies for Willow, every dime goes straight to her care fund. If we go above and beyond, we'll pay on someone else's balance at our vet (Finger Lakes Equine Practice).

The love Willow (the Bay Pony) has received so far is overwhelming. From friends and family and barn friends that have become family. She is so loved. Thank you for helping us give her another shot at living.

05/03/2022

It's Derby week and Bay Pony Bakery is donating a raffle basket to for their super fancy Kentucky Derby Gala! If you're going, toss a ticket into our Derby-themed basket and get yourself a dozen sugar cookies, horse treats, dog treats, a gift card, AND everything you need to make yourself a few Mint Juleps - the official drink of the Derby! Fun, fun!

Who are you betting on?! Our money is on Cyberknife or maaaybe his half-brother, Taiba. Gun Runner keeps making babies that look just like him! Super exciting, we'll see!

04/16/2022

Happy 3rd Birthday Symone! We’re glad you liked your cake! 😋🐶

03/28/2022

Chocolate cupcakes with sugar cookie toppers!

03/23/2022

Ready for long summer days at the farm...

03/15/2022

Can’t get enough of Enable and her very first baaaby! They’re the sweetest. 😍❤️

A huge part of our little mission is helping to change the overall perception of horse racing the general public has. Don’t get me wrong, this industry has done pleeeenty to disappoint, but we stand with the farms, breeders, trainers, jockeys, owners, rescues, and backside workers that work tirelessly and never ever fail to put the horses first. We know change is necessary on so many levels, and we’re up for the challenge.

Now, who wants cookies? ;)

03/14/2022

1 delicious cupcake + 1 sugar cookie topper = The best dessert ever!

Have you tried our Sugar Cookie Cupcakes yet?