Lisa's Pie Shop

Lisa's Pie Shop A local family owned and operated business specializing in handmade/homemade
pies and other baked goods. Made fresh every day. Serving you for 23 years!

Lisa's Pie Shop...home of Pie-n-Jar and handmade/homemade pies! We have a wide variety of baked goods for any occasion, or simply just for your mid-night snack! We use all fresh fruits and nothing over 24 hours old is kept, for gauruntee freshness. From pies to cupcakes, cinnamon rolls to cookies, quiche to pumpkin rolls, and chicken pot pies, we have it all! Stop in today and enjoy some of our d

elicious handmade/homemade pies and baked goods. In a hurry? No problem! Have a special occasion? Call in and order ahead and we will have it ready when you get here!

12/11/2022

Good evening everyone! We will not be taking orders for Christmas. Everything will be first come first serve basis. We are only open Thursday thru Saturday. Christmas week the hours might be changing depending on if product comes in or not. Remember that we only accept check and cash. We will be unable to respond to facebook questions and emails as we are to busy to try and stop.

11/23/2022

Come in and get your Thanksgiving Pies! We have lots ready as well as frozen take and bake so your house smells amazing while you enjoy time with your family! Remember we accept check and cash only. Thank You all for the support and Happy Thanksgiving! God Bless You all!

11/11/2022

Share Share Share!!!

Come in and beat the crowd. Get your take and bake pies for Thanksgiving! This is a reminder that we will not be taking any orders for Thanksgiving. We will be open Tuesday Nov 22nd and Wednesday Nov 23rd from 8am-6pm. It will be on a first come first serve basis. Our normal hours are now Thurs and Fri from 8am-6pm and Saturday from 10am-5pm.
Also we accept check and cash only. Mask are certainly appreciated! And we certainly appreciate all the support from our amazing customers. We would not be who we are without each and everyone of you. God Bless!

11/05/2022

We would like to thank everyone for your continued support. Due to the lack of help, inability to get our products we will be unable to take any orders for Thanksgiving this year. We will have fresh and frozen pies available on a first come, first serve basis. The cost is $18, Specialty (that includes Pecan) will be $20 and Black Raspberry will be $30. We will be open Tuesday 11/22 and Wednesday 11/23 from 8am to 6pm.

We apologize for the inconvenience but we thank you for your understanding and pray for your continued support. We know these are trying times for ALL of us and hope that we take this in consideration throughout the holiday season. Please be kind and show patience and understanding. ***We only accept cash and checks, masks are appreciated. We love you all. 🙂

Spring time special just in time for Mother's Day! Redbud, Dandelion and Violet Jelly! Limited supply so call in your ...
05/01/2022

Spring time special just in time for Mother's Day! Redbud, Dandelion and Violet Jelly! Limited supply so call in your order today. 317-758-6944

04/07/2022

We will be re-opening on Thursday April 7th. Our hours will be Thusday-Friday 8am to 6pm and Saturday 10am to 5pm. Unfortunately we will have limited supplies and have had to make some price increases. We ask for your patience and understanding. We have all experienced issues with supplies and hopefully it will only be a temporary issue. Looking forward to seeing everyone. God Bless.

10/30/2021

We would like to thank everyone for your continued support. Due to the lack of help, inability to get our products and Lisa's health issues we will be unable to take any orders for Thanksgiving this year. Right now our plan is to be open Tuesday 11/23 and Wednesday 11/24 from 8am to 5pm. This plan is subject to change due to Lisa starting her radiation treatments this week. We will be posting updates as we know how she does with the treatments. Your prayers are much appreciated.

We apologize for the inconvenience but we thank you for your understanding and pray for your continued support. We know these are trying times for ALL of us and hope that we take this in consideration throughout the holiday season. Please be kind and show patience and understanding. Lisa thanks you for all of the love and prayers as she continues to fight her health issues. We love you all. :)


05/06/2021

Right in time for Mother's Day! Tomorrow we will be reopening at 10am! We are looking forward to seeing our awesome customers. If you need something specific please call and place an order. We are still requiring face masks at this time due to employees with compromised immune systems. We want to help keep everyone safe and healthy. We will have Fresh Strawberry pies but they will be limited so make sure you get it reserved.

Please share!

Good morning! This is a reminder to get your Christmas orders in. Next week will be the last week to to place them. Don'...
12/12/2020

Good morning! This is a reminder to get your Christmas orders in. Next week will be the last week to to place them. Don't wait until the week of Christmas because we may not be able to fit you in.
If you need Christmas gifts that are under $10 we got you covered. We have stocking stuffers as well! We have stocked the Pie-n-jar and jams. We also have sweet breads that make great tasting gifts too. You can order cookies trays for gifts or for your table too. If you need breakfast covered we got Quiche and Giant pecan cinnamon rolls.
Christmas Eve will be our last day open. We will be closed the entire month of January and depending on Covid possibly longer. So if you need freezer pies to bake yourself or any other sweet treats make sure to order them now to get you through.
As always we love serving our customers! This year we want to encourage everyone to spread kindness! This year has been hard on many people and businesses. We accept check and cash only. We are requiring face mask and following social distancing. Please call orders in at 317-758-6944. Do not put them on Facebook or email. We will not be monitoring them.

Share Share Share

We are back!!! Wow it is already time for Christmas. Just some friendly reminders to start calling in your orders for th...
12/04/2020

We are back!!! Wow it is already time for Christmas. Just some friendly reminders to start calling in your orders for this month. Do not wait until it's too late. Make sure you order your Christmas gifts! We have stocked the Pie-n-jar and jams. You can order sweet breads and cookie trays as well. Something else to keep in mind. Christmas eve is our last day until after January. So if you need frozen take and bake or any other sweet treats make sure to get an order placed to pick up before our last day. As always we only accept cash and check. We are requiring face mask. Please call in orders at 317-758-6944. Do not put on Facebook or email we will not monitor it.

Share Share Share!

SHARE SHARE SHARE We are down to the last full week before Thanksgiving. We have been working around the clock to fill t...
11/15/2020

SHARE SHARE SHARE

We are down to the last full week before Thanksgiving. We have been working around the clock to fill the freezers full this past week. Please get your orders in this week before it is too late and we have to cut orders off. We are encouraging people to come in and get take and bake freezer pies to beat the crowd and lines. We will be strict on face masks they will be MANDATORY to come into the shop. As well as following social distancing. We are not only trying to keep our employees safe we want to keep our customers safe. We will be sanitizing everything touched around the clock as well to ensure everyone's safety. We are asking that you not bring smaller kids as they like to touch all the cases and items. Items to remember to order:

Breakfast: Giant pecan cinnamon rolls
Breakfast Quiche( Ham and cheese, Spinach, Bacon, Western).

Sweet Breads: Caramel pecan banana bread, blueberry zucchini, pumpkin bread, pumpkin with chocolate chips.

Lisa's Ginormous Pumpkin Rolls
Jim's Fabulous Loaded Party Mix
Pie-n-jar
Jams

Remember we only accept check and cash. Also we want to encourage everyone to be kind this season. There are people hurting everywhere. And we want to encourage people to go out and support your small businesses as this year has been very difficult for them.

Address

5995 S US Highway 31
Atlanta, IN
46031

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 8am - 6pm
Thursday 8am - 6pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+13177586944

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Lisa's Pie Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Lisa's Pie Shop:

Shortcuts

Share