It Must Have Been the Bake

It Must Have Been the Bake Beautiful created to order cookies, perfect for any occasion such as a birthday, a special occasion, or 'just because'. Vegan and gluten free available as well.

All my cookies are baked "from scratch" and designed to your specifications.

Day 2 at Ithaca Reggae Fest!!!
06/28/2026

Day 2 at Ithaca Reggae Fest!!!

06/18/2026
06/17/2026

Chocolate chip cookies anyone?
It Must Have Been the Bake

We all had a great time at celebrating Pride month in White Plains last weekend. Here are some photos. Anyone in the I...
06/09/2026

We all had a great time at celebrating Pride month in White Plains last weekend. Here are some photos. Anyone in the Ithaca area? We will be at Reggae Fest the end of June. Tom, thanks for the photos. ❤️

Getting ready for White Plains’ The Loft Pride Festival on the 7th!!! Cookies are ready of racking and the first batch o...
05/30/2026

Getting ready for White Plains’ The Loft Pride Festival on the 7th!!!
Cookies are ready of racking and the first batch of royal icing is made. 🌈
See everyone there.
It Must Have Been the Bake

Decorate your own cookie will be back again. We will be at the Bedford Music Festival at Caramoor again this September! ...
05/21/2026

Decorate your own cookie will be back again.
We will be at the Bedford Music Festival at Caramoor again this September! Last year was a blast and we can't wait to see everyone again this year.

Happy Thanksgiving! It Must Have Been the Bake
11/27/2025

Happy Thanksgiving!
It Must Have Been the Bake

Address

PO Box 542
Armonk, NY
10504

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when It Must Have Been the Bake posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to It Must Have Been the Bake:

Shortcuts

Share

Category