The Cookie Jar

Directions

The Cookie Jar NYS Home Processor Certified in Arkport, NY. Making Homemade baked goods like your Mom or Grandma would make!

It's that time of year again! With a slight chance of snow in the forecast for the weekend, it's time to start planning ...
10/14/2026

It's that time of year again! With a slight chance of snow in the forecast for the weekend, it's time to start planning ahead for the holidays!

Thank you so much to everyone who's already booked their Christmas cookie orders, if you haven't now is the time as dates are filling up!

This year's Christmas menu:

🎅 Decorated Christmas Cookies - $18/doz or 3 doz for $50

🍪 Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🎅Simple Christmas Cutouts (white frosting and sprinkles)
🥜 Peanut Butter Blossoms
🍂 Snickerdoodles
🍫 Chocolate Crinkles

🎄DIY Christmas Cookie Kits - $15
(Includes 1 dozen cutouts, 3 frosting colors and sprinkles)

Cookie platters for parties and events are available, let me put together something special for you!

Orders due by December 5th! (Or when completely booked)

📍Pickups:
Fridays - 4-6pm
Saturdays - 10am-Noon

📆Last Day for Pickups Christmas Week:
Tuesday 12/22 - 4pm-6pm

💳 Prepay through Venmo or Paypal
Venmo - @-Summers-26
PayPal- [email protected]

Thank you for supporting The Cookie Jar this holiday season!

🍂 FALL & HALLOWEEN COOKIE OPENING!! 🎃I have a little room for 6-8 dozen Fall or Halloween decorated sugar cookie cutouts...
10/07/2026

🍂 FALL & HALLOWEEN COOKIE OPENING!! 🎃

I have a little room for 6-8 dozen Fall or Halloween decorated sugar cookie cutouts for Saturday morning pickup!

🍪 $18/doz or 3 doz for $50 for Decorated Cutouts
💳 Prepay via Venmo or Paypal
📆 Orders must be placed by 8pm tonight
📍 Pickup Time - Saturday 10/10 from 10am-Noon

Comment below Fall or Halloween and how many dozen to claim yours and I will message you with payment and pickup info!

Thank you so much for supporting The Cookie Jar!

Happy Menu Monday! 🍪🏈🍂Hope everyone had a terrific weekend and enjoyed the beautiful weather, the changing leaves and ma...
10/05/2026

Happy Menu Monday! 🍪🏈🍂

Hope everyone had a terrific weekend and enjoyed the beautiful weather, the changing leaves and maybe a fall festival or Pumpkin patch! 🍂🎃

Here's to a new week, new blessings and fresh starts! Here's a few pics from this weekend! So grateful to go to the Cohocton Fall Festival with my Mom and Sister and bake some fall treats!

This week's menu:
Decorated Cutouts - $18 or 3/doz for $50
🍂 Fall
🎃 Halloween
🏈 Football (All teams available)

Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🍁 Simple Cutouts (white frosting with sprinkles)
🥜 Peanut Butter Blossoms
🎃 Pumpkin Frosted or Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
🍪 Snickerdoodles
🍂 Molasses

Orders due by Wednesday, October 7th at 8pm!

Pickups:
Thursday 10/8 - 4-6pm
Saturday 10/10 - 10am-Noon

📍Reminder that Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas preorders are open, don't forget to get your orders in early!

Drop a favorite fall photo you have taken below 👇

Truer words have never been spoken!! It may not solve everything, but a cookie sure helps!! 😆
10/03/2026

Truer words have never been spoken!! It may not solve everything, but a cookie sure helps!! 😆

Happy Wednesday, hope you get to enjoy this beautiful day! 🍂☀️Just a reminder that all orders for this week are due toni...
09/30/2026

Happy Wednesday, hope you get to enjoy this beautiful day! 🍂☀️

Just a reminder that all orders for this week are due tonight by 8pm!

Pickups are Thursday 10/1 4-6pm and Saturday 10/3 from 10am-Noon

Message me to order your fall treats and goodies for game day!

Happy Menu Monday!! 🍪🍁🎃It felt amazing to have a full weekend of fall, football and Halloween goodies!! I'm so incredibl...
09/28/2026

Happy Menu Monday!! 🍪🍁🎃

It felt amazing to have a full weekend of fall, football and Halloween goodies!! I'm so incredibly grateful for the blessing to be able to bake for you all!! 🙏 ❤️

This week's menu is full of all the Fall treats:

Decorated Cutouts - $18/doz or 3 doz for $50
🍂 Fall Cutouts
🎃 Halloween
🏈 Football (All teams available)
☕️🍩 Lattes and Donuts
🍁 Cozy Girl Fall

Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🍂 Simple Fall Cutouts (Leaves and pumpkins with white/colored frosting and sprinkles)
🥜 Peanut Butter Blossoms
🍪 Snickerdoodles
🍁 Molasses
🍫 Chocolate Crinkles

🎃 DIY Decorate Your Own Pumpkin Cookies - $15
Includes 1 dozen pumpkin Cutouts, 3 colors of frosting and sprinkles

Orders due by Wednesday 9/30 at 8pm!

Pickups:
Thursday 10/1 - 4-6pm
Saturday 10/3 - 10am-Noon

Hope you have a great week! Likes, comments and shares are greatly appreciated...remember your family and friends like cookies too! 🍪❤️

Fall is officially here, cooler weather is in the air, pumpkin spice is everywhere and football season is back!! 🏈🍂I rar...
09/22/2026

Fall is officially here, cooler weather is in the air, pumpkin spice is everywhere and football season is back!! 🏈🍂

I rarely have Sunday pickups, but this week I will be open from 10am-Noon for all your game day sweets!!

What team cutouts or goodies can I make for you?

Let's see how many different team cookies I can make this week! 🏈

Cutouts- $18/dozen or 3 doz for $50
🏈Football (All teams available or plain footballs)
🍂Fall or Halloween Cutouts

Want to have fun decorating your own footballs or Pumpkins? 🏈🎃
DIY Cookie Kits are available - $15
Includes 1 dozen football or Pumpkin Cutouts with coordinating frosting colors and sprinkles

Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🍂Simple Fall Cutouts (white/colored frosting and sprinkles)
🎃Pumpkin Frosted or Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
🥜Peanut Butter Blossoms
🍪Snickerdoodles
🍁Molasses

All orders due by Wednesday 9/23 at 8pm!

MENU MONDAY IS HERE!! 🍂🍪🏈All things Fall is officially here at The Cookie Jar, and this week's menu is full of everyone'...
09/21/2026

MENU MONDAY IS HERE!! 🍂🍪🏈

All things Fall is officially here at The Cookie Jar, and this week's menu is full of everyone's fall favorites!

🍁 Fall, Halloween and Football Cutouts (All teams available) - $18/doz or 3 doz for $50

🍪 Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🍂 Simple Fall Cutouts (white/colored frosting and sprinkles)
🎃 Pumpkin Frosted or Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
🥜 Peanut Butter Blossoms
🍫 Chocolate Crinkles
🍁 Molasses

Orders are due Wednesday 9/23 at 8pm!

Pickups:
🍂Thursday 9/24 - 4-6pm
Please note time/day change for this week:
🏈 Sunday 9/27 - 10am-Noon (Great for game day cookies!!)

Thank you again for everyone who stopped out to ladies night! It was such a fun evening and great to see all of you, it was the absolute sweetest to see so many familiar faces and meet new Cookie Jar friends!!

Can't wait to bake for you. What are you celebrating this week? ❤️

Happy Monday!! Thank you so much to all the ladies who stopped by yesterday whether it was to say hi, grab some cookies,...
09/21/2026

Happy Monday!! Thank you so much to all the ladies who stopped by yesterday whether it was to say hi, grab some cookies, shop the amazing vendors, or just have a fun ladies night out!! And thank you for a sell out night, it meant the world to me!! I was left with only 2 boxes of Snickerdoodles!! I think the consensus was the cutouts were "so cute" so will definitely bring more of those next time!

I loved seeing so many familiar faces and catching up, meeting so many new people and hearing "oh I know you I've had your cookies from so and so", "I've heard great things about you", "I've seen you on facebook" or even ladies who had never heard of me asking what my business name was or where I was located because even after 5 years so many are just finding out about The Cookie Jar!

I was honored to be a part of such a fun event and can't wait to do it again!! And a special thank you and shout out to The Old Soul Shop for organizing such a fun event for ladies to come out and shop and vendors to get together...the music was fun, the refreshments were great and it brought back some of what I remember from being a kid the stores filled with people shopping in Hornell!!

Thank you all again and hope you have a wonderful and blessed week!!

Can't wait to see everyone tonight...grab your friends and have a fun girls night out!! Lots of great vendors, antiques,...
09/20/2026

Can't wait to see everyone tonight...grab your friends and have a fun girls night out!! Lots of great vendors, antiques, jewelry, treats and Fall drinks next door at Hush!! 🍂🍪

Address

Arkport, NY
14807

Opening Hours

Thursday 4pm - 6pm
Friday 2pm - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 12pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category