The Cookie Jar

The Cookie Jar NYS Home Processor Certified in Arkport, NY. Making Homemade baked goods like your Mom or Grandma would make!

To every single person who's ever supported my business in any way whether it was a like, a kind word, sharing a post wi...
08/27/2026

To every single person who's ever supported my business in any way whether it was a like, a kind word, sharing a post with your friends, placing an order, recommending me, cheering for me or following along on this journey I just wanted to take a moment to say thank you!! ❤️ Running a business isn't the easiest job in the world, but the family that's been built over these last 5 years of The Cookie Jar has been the most amazing, rewarding part of what I do and why I do it.

I've had families come back year after year for their Christmas cookies, I've made cookies for kids birthday parties as they have grown up and change from 1 to 2 and up or each year when I get to make a fun new themed cookie set for their birthday celebration, through baby showers, bridal showers, weddings and graduations each and every cookie is made with a whole lot of love and heart and it's been so special to be a small part in those special days! Today I just want to say how grateful I am and always will be for each and every one of you! Thank you for being here I'm truly blessed with the best followers and customers! 🙏❤️🤗

Little late night baking! 🍂Something cinnamon, spice and all things nice is heading to CYs this morning! 🍪🍁Are you a nig...
08/25/2026

Little late night baking! 🍂

Something cinnamon, spice and all things nice is heading to CYs this morning! 🍪🍁

Are you a night owl or early riser?

Drop a 🦉 in the comments if you are up late and seeing this or a ☀️ if you are up bright and early!

Happy Monday! How is it the last week of August?! 🥹Before you know it school will be back in session and Fall will be co...
08/24/2026

Happy Monday! How is it the last week of August?! 🥹

Before you know it school will be back in session and Fall will be coming, but before that let's savor every bit of these last few weeks of Summer! ☀️

This is the last week for Summer cookies and Fall cookies are officially available to order as well!

It's been a crazy few days I started Instacart deliveries and signed up today for Doordash so you may see me out and about shopping and delivering!

I'm really excited and I'm definitely not giving up cookies I have some fun things coming up like a Labor Day Pop up here at The Cookie Jar for all your labor day and back to school treats on September 4th from Noon-4pm and will be at The Old Soul Shop on Main Street in Hornell on September 20th for Ladies Night with all the Fall goodies!! 🍪🍂

For this week here's what's available to order!

Cutouts - $15-$20
🍂Simple Fall Cutouts (white/colored frosting and sprinkles) - $15 or 3 dozen for $40
🍪Summer, Camping or Fall decorated Cutouts - $18/doz or 3 doz for $50
🌻Large Sunflower Cookies - $20

As always the Everyday Menu Cookies are available to order! This is a fun week as we say goodbye to Lemon Frosted and Strawberry Crunch and Hello to Pumpmin Frosted and Pumpkin Chocolate Chip...that means you get the best of both worlds if you would like Summer and fall!

Classic Cookies - $15/doz or 3 doz for $40
🍋Lemon Frosted
🍓Strawberry Crunch
🎃Pumpkin Frosted
🍪Pumpkin Chocolate Chip

Orders are due by Wednesday 8/26 at 8pm!

Pickups:
Thursday 8/27 - 4-6pm
Saturday 8/29 - 10am-Noon

Thank you all for your likes, comments, shares and supporting The Cookie Jar! Hope you have a great day!

🍂🍪 FALL IS OFFICIALLY MAKING ITS WAY TO THE COOKIE JAR 🍪🍂Some of you are holding tightly to Summer (and I don't blame yo...
08/17/2026

🍂🍪 FALL IS OFFICIALLY MAKING ITS WAY TO THE COOKIE JAR 🍪🍂

Some of you are holding tightly to Summer (and I don't blame you! ☀️) while others of you are already dreaming of pumpkins, fall scents, cozy days and all things Fall! So we are going to do both!

I'm so excited to share The Cookie Jars Fall Collection with you! 🍂🌻🧡

I'm keeping some of your favorite cozy classics, fun Fall cookie themes and also adding a NEW Fall Flavor - Maple Frosted! 🍁 (Thank you Christopher Lomax for your idea)

Everything you need is right here in today's Fall Collection Drop! 👇

🍪 Fall Cookie Menus + Prices
🍁 NEW Maple Frosted
📋 How to Order
🍎 Sponsor Cookies for a Teacher
🌻 Labor Day & Back to School Popup

Consider this your one-stop shop for everything happening at The Cookie Jar this Fall! 🍂

Over the next few days I will be talking more about the Labor Day & Back to School pop up and Spread Some Sweetness sponsor program. ❤️

Fall is one of my favorite times to bake and I'm so excited for all the smells of cinnamon, spice and all the coziness to fill The Cookie Jar kitchen! 🎃

☀️ P.S. Summer isn't going anywhere just yet! The Summer Cookie Collection is still available to order through the end of August!

So tell me, which cookie are you grabbing FIRST? 🍂👇 Tell me below!

Ready to Order? Just check out the How to Order graphic, then send me a message with what you would like, your preferred pickup date and any details or questions! ❤️
(If for any reason you get an error when trying to message please contact me on my personal page Lisa Summers)

Welcome to Fall at The Cookie Jar! 🧡

All likes, comments and shares are greatly appreciated! Remember your friends and family like cookies too! 🍂🍪

In honor of the Fall Menu dropping tomorrow, quick question...are you ready for all things Fall 🍂 or hanging on to ever...
08/16/2026

In honor of the Fall Menu dropping tomorrow, quick question...are you ready for all things Fall 🍂 or hanging on to every bit of Summer ☀️?

🍂 Something cozy is coming soon to The Cookie Jar 🍂🍪I've been working behind the scenes on the Fall Menu and it's almost...
08/14/2026

🍂 Something cozy is coming soon to The Cookie Jar 🍂🍪

I've been working behind the scenes on the Fall Menu and it's almost time to share it!

Fall 2026 Menu drops on Monday! 🍪🍁🌻

Let's have some fun.

What's YOUR favorite fall cookie? 🍪🍂

🎃 Pumpkin
🍎 Apple
🍪 Chocolate Chip
🧡 Molasses
💛 Snickerdoodles
🌻 Something decorated
👀 Something else?

Tell me your favorite! 👇

Who knows it may just make the menu! 👀🍪

🍪 Okay, I promise I'm done with the menus and posts for tonight! 😂If your feed was filled with a little more Cookie Jar ...
08/14/2026

🍪 Okay, I promise I'm done with the menus and posts for tonight! 😂

If your feed was filled with a little more Cookie Jar than usual today, I appologize and promise there was a reason! ❤️

With all the changes I've been making as I head into this next chapter and Year 6, I wanted to get everything in one place. The Everyday Cookie Menu, the new Cutout Pricing Tiers, August Seasonal Menu, How to Order, Where to Start and Pickup Days and Times.

I've also pinned these posts so they are easy to find for anyone new to The Cookie Jar or who wants a quick reference.

So, thank you so much for putting up with my information overload today! 😂❤️

I also want to say THANK YOU for all the love on my 5-year anniversary post yesterday. 🥹

Reading your comments, messages and memories meant more to me than I can even put into words, I read each and every one and it made my entire day! I'm still in the process of responding back, but they meant the world to me.

I'm so grateful for every person who's ordered cookies, shared posts, recommended me to a friend, cheered me on or has stuck around and watched The Cookie Jar grow and change over the years, I truly wouldn't be able to do any of this without you all!! ❤️

I think all the important stuff is posted and we can get back to the fun stuff!

And trust me...there's lots of fun stuff coming and maybe a little pumpkin spice too! 🍂

P.S. Hope you got to catch a glimpse of the beautiful sunset and wishing you a wonderful evening!

🫙 WHERE DO I START?New to The Cookie Jar or not sure which menu to choose? Start here! 🍪🍪 Want your favorite everyday co...
08/13/2026

🫙 WHERE DO I START?

New to The Cookie Jar or not sure which menu to choose? Start here! 🍪

🍪 Want your favorite everyday cookies?
→ Start with the Everyday Menu

🎨 Want cutout cookies?
→ Choose from Simple, Themed or Custom Cutouts

🍂 Looking for what's available right now?
→ Check the Weekly/Monthly Seasonal Menu
(for example this month look at August's menu)

🧁 Want to decorate cookies yourself?
→ Ask about our DIY Kits

📝 Ready to order?
→ Check out the How to Order post for all the details!

📆 Planning ahead?
You can always reach out about a future date! Whether you are planning a birthday, shower, holiday party or Christmas cookies, early orders are always welcome and encouraged as holiday dates fill up quickly! You don't have to wait for that month's menu to be posted to order!

Still not sure? Just send me a message! ❤️

I'm happy to help you figure out which option is right for you.

📝 How to Order from The Cookie Jar🍪 Ready to order? I’ve made it a little easier!With the *New* Everyday Menu, Cutout Ti...
08/13/2026

📝 How to Order from The Cookie Jar

🍪 Ready to order? I’ve made it a little easier!

With the *New* Everyday Menu, Cutout Tiered Options, and seasonal menus, there are now more ways to find exactly what you're looking for, whether you want a simple dozen of your favorite cookies, themed cutouts for a special occasion, or completely customized cookies.

Here’s how it works:
✨ Choose what you'd like
✨ Choose your quantity
✨ Pick your preferred pickup date
✨ Send me your order
✨ I'll confirm availability, pricing, and all the details with you!

For Custom Cutouts, please send any pictures, inspiration, names, wording, or other details you'd like included when you inquire. This helps me determine the appropriate custom tier and pricing.
And remember — if you don't see exactly what you're looking for, just ask! I'm always happy to talk through your ideas and see what we can create. ❤️

📆 Planning ahead? You can always order ahead!
If you already know you will need cookies for a future date, you don't have to wait til that months menu. Many of my regular customers place holiday orders months in advance to get their date on the calender before the holiday rush. ❤️

The goal is simple: make ordering your Cookie Jar favorites easier, clearer, and give you more choices. 🍪🫙

📩 Ready to order? Send me a message!

I have been having issues occasionally with messenger if you get an error or don't hear back, please message my personal page Lisa Summers

I look forward to baking for you and making your celebrations extra sweet! ❤️🍪

☀️ 🍦 ONE LAST TASTE OF SUMMER 🍓 🌻Before we deep dive into all things Pumpkin Spice and Fall, we are squeezing every last...
08/13/2026

☀️ 🍦 ONE LAST TASTE OF SUMMER 🍓 🌻

Before we deep dive into all things Pumpkin Spice and Fall, we are squeezing every last bit of Summer with a few seasonal favorites that will carry us into the first week in September! ❤️

Seasonal Cutouts - $18/doz or 3 doz for $50 (Individually packaged $2/doz extra)

☀️ Summer
🌻 Sunflowers
🍦 Ice Cream
🏕 Camping
🎒 Back to School/Teacher or Bus Driver
🇺🇸 Labor Day

And remember the Everyday Cookie Menu is available too, so you can mix & match your favorites for all your end of summer celebrations!

🍋🍓 LAST CALL FOR SUMMER FLAVORS!

Lemon Frosted and Strawberry Crunch available til September 1st when we transition to all things FALL 🍂

All orders due by Wednesdays at 8pm!

Pickup Days:
Thursdays- 4pm-6pm
Saturdays - 10am-Noon

Comment or message to grab your favorites!

Thank you all for supporting this little bakery dream and to year 6!! ❤️ 🎉

Address

Arkport, NY
14807

Opening Hours

Thursday 4pm - 6pm
Friday 2pm - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 12pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category