Stephie's Outlaw Bakery

Stephie's Outlaw Bakery "MADE FROM SCRATCH" custom, made to order, baked goods made with premium ingredients. Registered with the PA Dept of Agriculture

Located in South Annville Township Pennsylvania. About myself & my Outlaw Bakery…. I’ve been in the kitchen either helping or baking since I was old enough to sprinkle sugar on Christmas cookies & roll an Easter peanut butter egg many, many moons ago with my Great Grandmother & Grandmother. I have continued many family traditions with my baking & have family recipes that are generations old. I kee

p to the tradition with the original recipe and use REAL butter, cream, buttermilk and all brand name ingredients. When somebody asks me what my secret is, it is just that. I take extreme pride in only using the best ingredients. I do not substitute or try to cut costs with generic or off brand ingredients. Some ingredients I still go straight to the farm for! When I bake a cake, it is “from scratch” not out of a box. When I bake for my hobby of baking, it is 100% true, traditional baking. I was asked to start this page so people could more readily see what’s going on in my kitchen. I will let you know what I am baking and the cost. I like to bake with the seasons for the freshest fruit pies but have a few that I will make year round. If I am not baking what you would like at the time, just ask! I will bake for anyone if I have the time. I will use my recipe or yours, my container or yours. Family recipes are the best & I will do my best to reproduce it the way you are accustomed to enjoying it. Some people have the talent & just don’t have the time & others have no interest in baking but enjoy these special treats. Custom cakes & cookies are a luxury item. I try to keep my prices reasonable however using only the best ingredients & rising ingredient costs, make it difficult to control. Custom cakes and decorating are very time consuming. In addition to your "from scratch" made cake, there is design planning and fabricating. Please do not confuse your custom order with a "flash-frozen", made months ago and shipped to the big box store, treat. All orders are made fresh within 24 to 48 hours of delivery. Because custom cakes are just that, custom, prices vary. When we decide what it is you are looking for and if I am able to do it, I will give you a price quote. Keep in mind, I cannot & will not compete with big box store pricing. I am always open to suggestions and constructive criticism. I believe this is how we learn & grow and I am always looking to do both! Please don’t hesitate to come to me if something isn’t the way you believe it should be. Come to me 1st so we can discuss it and fix it. AND most certainly if you are happy with what I provided to you let everyone know! I love the hobby of baking and I am glad that you have taken an interest in my hobby. Baking = hobby = sanity for Stephie! ;)

A sweet way to celebrate a graduate! 🎓💐These wild flower inspired graduation cookies were created for Emmie’s graduation...
06/07/2026

A sweet way to celebrate a graduate! 🎓💐

These wild flower inspired graduation cookies were created for Emmie’s graduation celebration, and I absolutely love how they turned out! From the tiny flowers to the dimensional details, every cookie was decorated by hand with royal icing.

Congratulations Emmie! Here’s to chasing dreams and making them happen. 💙

Because every accomplishment deserves cookies.




⚡ Gotta catch 'em all — and keep 'em allergy-aware! ⚡Meet Xavier's 10th birthday Pokémon cookie set! 🎂🍪One of Xavier's c...
05/28/2026

⚡ Gotta catch 'em all — and keep 'em allergy-aware! ⚡

Meet Xavier's 10th birthday Pokémon cookie set! 🎂🍪

One of Xavier's classmates has a red dye allergy, so this order pushed me into brand new territory and taught me something new — using natural food colorings for the very first time!

I used TheSugarArt.com Natural colors for the reds and pinks and honestly? I’m obsessed. The color payoff was beautiful. I actually think the natural red was MORE vibrant than artificial red! And for you other bakers out there with questions of taste & consistency, taste was not objectionable, I really couldn't taste a difference. Consistency of my icing was no different & it set in the same amount of time. :)

BUT — here’s the cookie decorating twist, and a lesson worth sharing. 👇

While preparing an ingredient list for Xavier’s mom and teacher, I discovered that some blue food colorings can also contain red dye. 💙

At that point, the cookies were already decorated, so I immediately shared the full ingredient information and research directly with Xavier’s mom and teacher so they could review everything and make the best decision for the child involved.

As a baker, those of you that know me, know that transparency matters to me — especially when families are navigating food sensitivities and allergies.

Because of this experience, I’ve decided that as my current gel colors run out, I’ll be transitioning early to TheSugarArt.com Natural colors across my bakery — even before the FDA regulated timeline. The natural colors are significantly more expensive for various reasons, but making more informed ingredient choices for my customers matters more to me.

The SugarArt is already the primary brand I use in my decorating, so it’s a brand I already know and trust.

Is there a learning curve? Yep.
Is it expensive? Yep.
Is it worth it? Absolutely. 🙌

And for the record… I think these turned out pretty darn cute 💛

Happy 10th Birthday, Xavier! ⚡

Fresh baked blueberry muffins, hot coffee, and a quiet moment to remember those who gave everything for our freedom. ❤️🤍...
05/25/2026

Fresh baked blueberry muffins, hot coffee, and a quiet moment to remember those who gave everything for our freedom. ❤️🤍💙

This Memorial Day, may your day be filled with gratitude, family, and maybe something sweet from the kitchen too. 🇺🇸🫐☕️

Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery
Baking so good it should be illegal.



Love in bloom…Miss to Mrs. has never looked so delicious.This bridal shower set is giving wildflower garden party vibes ...
05/13/2026

Love in bloom…
Miss to Mrs. has never looked so delicious.

This bridal shower set is giving wildflower garden party vibes 🌸

Every flower, every line, every detail—piped by hand with intention. No shortcuts, no skimping, no rushing. This is the kind of work that turns a dessert table into a full moment.

These aren’t just cookies… they’re the details people remember.

Custom orders are limited, so if you’ve got an event coming up, now’s the time to get on my calendar.
And just a friendly reminder—dates are not held. Your order is only secured once your quote is confirmed through my website.

On a side note… if you’ve ever wanted to learn how to decorate royal icing cookies 👀
My next decorating class is Saturday, May 30 at 9:30AM
📍 Annville Train Station
Mark your calendars—details coming soon!

Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery | Custom cookies for every occasion

Wishing my amazing family, friends, and followers the most beautiful, delicious, and well-deserved Mother’s Day. You des...
05/10/2026

Wishing my amazing family, friends, and followers the most beautiful, delicious, and well-deserved Mother’s Day. You deserve every crumb. 🦋✨
With love (and buttercream), Happy Mother’s Day!!
Steph
Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery 💜

Alright… this one is not for the faint of heart 😏Snickers Trifle.And yes—it’s every bit as ridiculous as it looks.Layers...
05/08/2026

Alright… this one is not for the faint of heart 😏

Snickers Trifle.
And yes—it’s every bit as ridiculous as it looks.

Layers on layers of:
• Rich, from-scratch chocolate cake
• Gooey caramel (the good kind, not the sad squeeze bottle kind)
• Fluffy peanut butter icing
• Crushed peanuts
• Silky chocolate mousse
• Finished with chunks of Snickers because… obviously

This isn’t a “have a polite little slice” dessert.
This is a grab a spoon, cancel your plans, and don’t make eye contact with anyone while you eat it kind of dessert.

Perfect for birthdays, parties, or when you just feel like being a little extra. 💁🏼‍♀️

📩 Custom orders are limited—if this is calling your name, don’t wait too long.

I've been saying this all along! It's a no judgement zone here! :)
05/05/2026

I've been saying this all along! It's a no judgement zone here! :)

May the 4th be with you… and also with this cake. 🖤🤍⚔️We're celebrating the galaxy's favorite holiday the only way we kn...
05/04/2026

May the 4th be with you… and also with this cake. 🖤🤍⚔️

We're celebrating the galaxy's favorite holiday the only way we know how — one delicious layer at a time. This Stormtrooper helmet cake is ready to report for duty… right after someone takes the first slice. 🪐🎂






🌸✨ WE ARE LIVE at the Spring Mother's Day Vendor Event! ✨🌸Come find us RIGHT INSIDE THE DOOR at the Ono Fire Company Ban...
05/03/2026

🌸✨ WE ARE LIVE at the Spring Mother's Day Vendor Event! ✨🌸

Come find us RIGHT INSIDE THE DOOR at the Ono Fire Company Banquet Hall — 10805 Jonestown Road, Jonestown! 🏠💕

We've got a TON of delicious treats today including:
🫙 Cannoli, Snickers & Lemon Berry Cake Jars
🧁 Cupcakes in 6 packs to go
🍭 Cakesicles. What’s that you ask?? Come out to see!!
🎂 Custom "Mom" Flower Pot Cakes available for order.
🍪 Gluten Friendly Cookies & Cream & Chocolate cakesicles. ..and SO much more! (Limited quantity of whoopie pies) 😉

The event runs TODAY from 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM with vendors both inside AND in the parking lot. The perfect place to treat Mom (or yourself — no judgment 😉)!

Don't miss us — we'd love to see your face! 💜

📍 Ono Fire Company Banquet Hall
10805 Jonestown Road, Jonestown
⏰ 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Address

155 North Moyer Street
Annville, PA
17003

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Stephie's Outlaw Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Stephie's Outlaw Bakery:

Share

Category