Stephie's Outlaw Bakery

Directions Website Contact the business

Stephie's Outlaw Bakery "MADE FROM SCRATCH" custom, made to order, baked goods made with premium ingredients. Registered with the PA Dept of Agriculture

Located in South Annville Township Pennsylvania. About myself & my Outlaw Bakery…. I’ve been in the kitchen either helping or baking since I was old enough to sprinkle sugar on Christmas cookies & roll an Easter peanut butter egg many, many moons ago with my Great Grandmother & Grandmother. I have continued many family traditions with my baking & have family recipes that are generations old. I keep to the tradition with the original recipe and use REAL butter, cream, buttermilk and all brand name ingredients. When somebody asks me what my secret is, it is just that. I take extreme pride in only using the best ingredients. I do not substitute or try to cut costs with generic or off brand ingredients. Some ingredients I still go straight to the farm for! When I bake a cake, it is “from scratch” not out of a box. When I bake for my hobby of baking, it is 100% true, traditional baking. I was asked to start this page so people could more readily see what’s going on in my kitchen. I will let you know what I am baking and the cost. I like to bake with the seasons for the freshest fruit pies but have a few that I will make year round. If I am not baking what you would like at the time, just ask! I will bake for anyone if I have the time. I will use my recipe or yours, my container or yours. Family recipes are the best & I will do my best to reproduce it the way you are accustomed to enjoying it. Some people have the talent & just don’t have the time & others have no interest in baking but enjoy these special treats. Custom cakes & cookies are a luxury item. I try to keep my prices reasonable however using only the best ingredients & rising ingredient costs, make it difficult to control. Custom cakes and decorating are very time consuming. In addition to your "from scratch" made cake, there is design planning and fabricating. Please do not confuse your custom order with a "flash-frozen", made months ago and shipped to the big box store, treat. All orders are made fresh within 24 to 48 hours of delivery. Because custom cakes are just that, custom, prices vary. When we decide what it is you are looking for and if I am able to do it, I will give you a price quote. Keep in mind, I cannot & will not compete with big box store pricing. I am always open to suggestions and constructive criticism. I believe this is how we learn & grow and I am always looking to do both! Please don’t hesitate to come to me if something isn’t the way you believe it should be. Come to me 1st so we can discuss it and fix it. AND most certainly if you are happy with what I provided to you let everyone know! I love the hobby of baking and I am glad that you have taken an interest in my hobby. Baking = hobby = sanity for Stephie! ;)

🏖️ OUT OF THE BAKERY… OR AT LEAST ATTEMPTING TO BE! 🏖️Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery will be closed Saturday, September 26 thro...
09/25/2026

🏖️ OUT OF THE BAKERY… OR AT LEAST ATTEMPTING TO BE! 🏖️

Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery will be closed Saturday, September 26 through Sunday, October 4 while I enjoy some much-needed family vacation time.

Of course, NC 12 is currently closed to Avon—because apparently simply going on vacation wasn’t enough of an adventure. 😂 Whether we reach the beach house or spend the week staring at a road-closed sign remains to be seen!

Either way, I’m stepping away from the mixer, piping bags and bakery messages for the week. I’ll return on Monday, October 5 and respond to messages and order inquiries as soon as possible.

Tickets for my October 17 HOWL-O-WEEN decorating workshops will remain available exclusively through my website while I’m away:

mycustombakes.com/stephiesoutlawbakery

Thank you for your patience—and please send good vibes to NC 12! 🌊🚧

🐾🎃 HOWL-O-WEEN Paws for a Cause Cookie Decorating Workshop! 🎃🐾📅 Saturday, October 17, 2026⏰ 1:30 PM⏳ Approximately 3–3½ ...
09/25/2026

🐾🎃 HOWL-O-WEEN Paws for a Cause Cookie Decorating Workshop! 🎃🐾

📅 Saturday, October 17, 2026
⏰ 1:30 PM
⏳ Approximately 3–3½ hours
📍 Annville Train Station
N. Moyer Street, Annville, PA
🎟️ $50 per person

Join me for an afternoon of spooky, sweet fun as we decorate six adorable HOWL-O-WEEN-themed royal icing cookies!

You’ll decorate a ghost cat, ghost dog, pumpkin, paw print, dog bone and black cat cookie. All supplies and step-by-step instruction will be provided, and light refreshments will be served.

No decorating experience is needed—this workshop is designed for beginners!

A portion of the proceeds will be donated to two local animal rescues:

🐾 Friends of All Animals
🐾 Angels Among Us Animal Sanctuary – Community Outreach, helping pets remain with their senior citizen and veteran owners.

We NEED to fill this workshop! The more seats we fill, the larger the donation we can make to these wonderful organizations. Grab a friend and come decorate for a great cause!

I’ll also be collecting items from both organizations’ wish lists. Donations are welcome from workshop attendees and the general public—even if you’re unable to attend.

🎟️ Only 12 seats are available, and tickets may be purchased exclusively through my website:
mycustombakes.com/stephiesoutlawbakery

PHOTO DISCLOSURE: I RAN OUT OF TIME & DID NOT GET MY COOKIE SAMPLES FINISHED FOR PHOTOS IN TIME TO GET THE WORKSHOP LIVE & POSTED! The cookies pictured are from an AI-generated design image created as the model for this workshop. They were not baked or decorated by Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery. Participants will be guided in creating their own versions of these six designs.

Let’s fill every seat and make a difference for local animals! 🧡💜

🐾🎃 HOWL-O-WEEN Paws for a Cause Cake Decorating Workshop! 🎃🐾📅 Saturday, October 17, 2026⏰ 9:00 AM⏳ Approximately 3–3½ ho...
09/25/2026

🐾🎃 HOWL-O-WEEN Paws for a Cause Cake Decorating Workshop! 🎃🐾

📅 Saturday, October 17, 2026
⏰ 9:00 AM
⏳ Approximately 3–3½ hours
📍 Annville Train Station
N. Moyer Street, Annville, PA
🎟️ $68 per person

Join me to decorate this adorable HOWL-O-WEEN-themed, two-layer 6-inch cake! Each participant may choose vanilla or chocolate cake.

All supplies and step-by-step instruction will be provided, and light refreshments will be served. No decorating experience is needed!

A portion of the proceeds will be donated to two local animal rescues:

🐾 Friends of All Animals
🐾 Angels Among Us Animal Sanctuary – Community Outreach, helping pets remain with their senior citizen and veteran owners.

We NEED to fill this workshop! The more seats we fill, the larger the donation we can make to these wonderful organizations. Grab a friend and come decorate for a great cause!

I’ll also be collecting items from both organizations’ wish lists. Donations are welcome from workshop attendees and the general public—even if you’re unable to attend.

🎟️ Only 12 seats are available, and tickets may be purchased exclusively through my website:
mycustombakes.com/stephiesoutlawbakery

PHOTO DISCLOSURE: I RAN OUT OF TIME & DIDN'T GET MY SAMPLE CAKE FINISHED FOR PHOTOS & NEEDED TO GET THIS LIVE & POSTED! :(
The cake pictured is an AI-generated design image created as the model for this workshop. It is not a photograph of a cake made by Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery. Participants will be guided in creating their own version of this design.

Let’s fill every seat and make a difference for local animals! 🧡💜

Remember those mystery bags of icing I posted the other day? Here’s the finished reveal! 🧁🎉This birthday order was all a...
09/20/2026

Remember those mystery bags of icing I posted the other day? Here’s the finished reveal! 🧁🎉

This birthday order was all about Randy—his favorite “Tons of 100’s” ticket, his signature sayings and plenty of personality!

The celebration included an all-buttercream pull-apart cupcake cake designed after the ticket, along with speech-bubble cookies featuring some classic Randy-isms! 😆

Such a fun, completely personalized birthday theme. Happy Birthday, Randy! May your day be totally Swisseriffic—and filled with winning! 💜🧡💛

I’m all set up inside at the Alden Craft Show & Cruise-In today until 3 PM! 🩷💜🩵There are so many wonderful vendors here—...
09/19/2026

I’m all set up inside at the Alden Craft Show & Cruise-In today until 3 PM! 🩷💜🩵

There are so many wonderful vendors here—you can shop, eat and find all kinds of unique goodies while supporting local small businesses!

I brought cakesicles, Mini “More-ish” Cakes, apple pound cakes, Ginger Pop Crunch—and FREE “day-old but still delicious” royal icing cookies while they last! 😂

Thanks to my wonderful, metal fabricator son, my new sign is perfectly displayed at my table! Come find Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery and say hello! 🧁🚘

Come see me TOMORROW at the Alden Craft Show & Cruise-In! 🚘🛍️🧁I’ll be set up INSIDE from 10 AM–3 PM, look for my new sig...
09/18/2026

Come see me TOMORROW at the Alden Craft Show & Cruise-In! 🚘🛍️🧁

I’ll be set up INSIDE from 10 AM–3 PM, look for my new sign! This event is rain or shine, so don’t let a few raindrops scare you away!

I’ll also be posting more details about my upcoming events soon:

🎃 October 9 — Halloween Drag Show & Bingo
When purchasing your tickets, tell Ryan Lahr you’re sitting at my tables so you’ll have a reserved seat!

🐾 October 17 — Two Decorating Workshops, 1 cookie — 1 cake HOWL-o-ween themed! Both workshops will benefit local animal rescues!🐾

Mark your calendars—October is going to be busy, fun and just a little spooky! 👻

And since I haven't done the guessing game lately, here ya go! What do you think my theme is for these colors? Hint....this is buttercream not royal icing! ;) 🕵

I’m here and all set up at the Wish Upon a Food Truck Festival! 💜⭐️📍 Find Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery in the vendor area—not...
09/12/2026

I’m here and all set up at the Wish Upon a Food Truck Festival! 💜⭐️

📍 Find Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery in the vendor area—not beside the food trucks. Look for the big teal edged canopy and the giant wall of Paint Your Own cookies!

I brought PYO cookie sets, cakecicles, Just-for-Fun cookies, Apple Note Cards, mini apple pound cakes, Gingerbread Caramel Crunch—and even $2 “Whoopsies.” They lost their sticks, but not their flavor! 😂

We’re at the AACA Museum in Hershey until 4:00 PM. Live music, TONS of food trucks, everything you can imagine I think is here! Come find me, grab something sweet and help support Make-A-Wish!

Oh! And did I mention you can pet some baby goats?? They are adorable & almost next to me. 🐐

Baking so good, it should be illegal! 🧁🚔

Jackson’s first trip around the sun called for ALL the sunshine! ☀️🌈A bright ombré cake, matching cupcakes and hand-deco...
09/04/2026

Jackson’s first trip around the sun called for ALL the sunshine! ☀️🌈

A bright ombré cake, matching cupcakes and hand-decorated cookies made this first birthday extra sweet. That smiling little sun in a bow tie may have stolen the whole show! 💛🩵🧡

Happy 1st Birthday, Jackson! Here’s to many more trips around the sun! ☀️🎂

This week's cookies were a little extra special. 💜🍪I had the opportunity to once again be a Sugar Angel for Icing Smiles...
08/28/2026

This week's cookies were a little extra special. 💜🍪

I had the opportunity to once again be a Sugar Angel for Icing Smiles, this time through their Cookie Club. I was assigned to create & donate a dozen cookies for a very special little girl and her family, and the design was completely up to me!

My goal was simple: send a box full of HAPPY. 🌈☀️

Bright colors, rainbows, smiling sunshine, encouraging messages…and of course, a few Labubus because apparently I do occasionally know what the cool kids like. 😂

These cookies were made, decorated, packaged and shipped with lots of love from Stephie’s Outlaw Bakery, with one hope—that when this family opens their box, it brings a few extra smiles to their day. ❤️

This is exactly why I love being part of Icing Smiles. Sometimes cookies really can be more than just cookies. 🍪💜

A little less sparkle in the world today. 🩷✨Rest easy, Dolly. Thank you for the music, the sass, the big hair, the even ...
08/25/2026

A little less sparkle in the world today. 🩷✨

Rest easy, Dolly. Thank you for the music, the sass, the big hair, the even bigger heart, and for always being unapologetically YOU.

You’ll always be an icon. 🦋

Address

155 North Moyer Street
Annville, PA
17003

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Stephie's Outlaw Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Stephie's Outlaw Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category