Penny’s Pies

Penny’s Pies Penny’s Pies are 100% homemade from the crust to the top! All pies are $15 each. Various pies made

Hot out of the oven!
05/23/2026

Hot out of the oven!

05/17/2026

Hello Penny’s Pies Peeps! For those wanting Memorial Day Pies please have your order placed by Wednesday May 20th. Thank you.

05/16/2026

Ok Penny’s Pies Peeps. I have 1 cherry, 1 Blueberry and 2 ( pie pans) of Cinnamon Rolls left from my event this morning get a hold of me today if you are interested. Pick up only.Thank you.

Getting pies ready for tomorrow. I’ll be at the Community Market in Stewart 9-12 May 16th(old school).Set up is on the ...
05/15/2026

Getting pies ready for tomorrow. I’ll be at the Community Market in Stewart 9-12 May 16th(old school).Set up is on the basketball court. Come on out and check out all the vendors.

Penny’s Pies will be set up this Saturday May 16th ,come on out and check out the vendors. Located at the old school in ...
05/13/2026

Penny’s Pies will be set up this Saturday May 16th ,come on out and check out the vendors. Located at the old school in Stewart.

04/15/2026

Breaking News!
Please share. I will not be available May 1st through May 11 th for baking. Thanks everyone and to all those that provide a Mother’s role have a very nice Mother’s Day!

04/05/2026

Attention:
Anyone needing a pie today?I have two extra available 1 Apple and 1 Key lime. I will be available for purchase until 11:30.

Making pies!
04/03/2026

Making pies!

Pie crust in the making!
04/02/2026

Pie crust in the making!

Had a hankering for some soft and chewy Peanut Butter cookies.
03/29/2026

Had a hankering for some soft and chewy Peanut Butter cookies.

Address

Albany, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Penny’s Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share