Cookies by Jay

Cookies by Jay -Veteran owned
-Delicious custom cookies for ALL occasions
-Now booking PRIVATE Cookie Decorating Parties
-Make your Branding extra sweet with LOGO cookies!

Please use website for all inquiries! Thanks!

05/21/2026

My Etsy Shop is OFFICIALLY closed and packing day is in 5 days!! I NEED to get rid of all my shipping packaging! So please, if you know of a local business that could use these, PLEASE TAG THEM! Or message me if you are interested!

Thank you!

05/20/2026

On a scale of 1-10, how prepared do you think I am to get mynhouse packed up in 6 DAYS for our
Move to Japan?!?!

May the FOURTH be with you!
05/04/2026

May the FOURTH be with you!

May the FOURTH be with you!(and also with you)
05/04/2026

May the FOURTH be with you!

(and also with you)

šŸ’› Small favor, big help! šŸŖIf Iā€™ve ever made cookies for youā€”gourmet cookies, custom sugar cookies, holiday orders, birth...
04/29/2026

šŸ’› Small favor, big help! šŸŖ
If Iā€™ve ever made cookies for youā€”gourmet cookies, custom sugar cookies, holiday orders, birthday cookies, any of itā€”Iā€™d be so thankful if you could take a minute to leave me a review on my page or Google.

Having to start over in a new area is hard, but your reviews will seriously help me so much!!

Even just a couple sentences makes a huge difference. And if you have a picture of your cookies, that helps even more!

If you leave one, comment a ā¤ļø so I can say thank you!

Review link: https://g.page/r/Ceex62K3NNB1EAE/review

I really appreciate every order, share, recommendation, and kind word more than you know šŸ¤

04/29/2026

Gotta get all the details in!

Show Your Teachers Some Appreciation!!!Our teachers do soooo much for our kids so let's be sure to spoil them for Teache...
04/28/2026

Show Your Teachers Some Appreciation!!!
Our teachers do soooo much for our kids so let's be sure to spoil them for Teacher Appreciation Week!

This is my LAST Presale in Moore County, so if you snag a cookie or two for yourself as well, I wont judge!!

Order online through my website and pickup before next week at my home kitchen in Pinebluff or at in Downtown Southern Pines!
Not Local?!?! Go to my Etsy Shop!

Teacher Appreciation Cookies!!!Give the teachers in your life a personalized cookie to say thank you for all they do! Ea...
04/28/2026

Teacher Appreciation Cookies!!!

Give the teachers in your life a personalized cookie to say thank you for all they do! Each cookie comes ready to gift in a sealed bag with a bow! They make a great addition to a gift basket or paired with a gift card as well!!

Order directly on my website! Pickups will be this weekend in Pinebluff or at Against the Grain Shoppe in Southern Pines.

https://square.link/u/kyWmM8Ks

This is also my FINAL presale before I close my shop to prepare for our big move!

Its Time for a Flash Sale!!!!! Quarter pound cookies, $4 eachFlavors:Peanut ButterCookie MonsterThe Big ZESTBrown Sugar ...
04/20/2026

Its Time for a Flash Sale!!!!!
Quarter pound cookies, $4 each

Flavors:

Peanut Butter
Cookie Monster
The Big ZEST
Brown Sugar Poptart
Biscoff Cookie Butter
Carrot Cake (stuffed with Maple Pecan Buttercream)

Pickup in Pinebluff or Southern Pines!

Place your order in the comments!!

Iā€™ve been sitting on this news for a while because I wanted to make sure everything was officially officialā€¦ If you kno...
04/13/2026

Iā€™ve been sitting on this news for a while because I wanted to make sure everything was officially officialā€¦

If you know me, you know Iā€™m better at decorating cookies than finding the right words ā€” but here we go šŸ„¹

These past 5 years in Moore County have been so sweet (had to šŸ˜‰). Getting to be a small part of your birthdays, weddings, holidays, and ā€œjust becauseā€ moments has meant the absolute world to me.

To everyone who has ordered, shared, hyped me up, and recommended my little cookie business ā€” youā€™re the real MVPs. Iā€™m beyond grateful for each and every one of you. šŸ¤

Now for the big newsā€¦ Iā€™ll be closing my books at the end of this month because my business (and I!) are relocating to JAPAN!!!! āœˆļøšŸŒŽ (still doesnā€™t feel real saying that!).

Donā€™t worry ā€” this isnā€™t a forever goodbye! If itā€™s Godā€™s plan, Iā€™m hoping to be back in about 3 yearsā€¦ so consider this a ā€œsee you later, save me a cookieā€ situation šŸŖšŸ’›

Thank you for making this journey so incredibly special. Itā€™s been the sweetest chapter. šŸ’•

Address

Aberdeen, NC

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 10pm
Tuesday 9am - 10pm
Wednesday 9am - 10pm
Thursday 9am - 10pm
Friday 9am - 10pm
Saturday 9am - 10pm
Sunday 9am - 10pm

Website

https://cookiesbyjay.etsy.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookies by Jay posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookies by Jay:

Shortcuts

Share

Category