Sarah Johnston's Custom Cakes

Call Directions

Sarah Johnston's Custom Cakes Custom Cakes for Any Occasion Hi, I'm Sarah! After taking a course in cake baking and decorating many years ago, I started baking for my friends and family.

I now do custom-ordered events for weddings, special events, or whatever you might need! If you are interested in placing an order, send me a message, call or text and we can get started! (289) 251 2686

🖤
07/19/2026

🖤

☀️🍪 SUMMER KICK-OFF TREAT DAY! 🍫🍰I’m set up at Kate L. Toms Fit on Erskine Ave. in Peterborough until 3:00 PM today with...
06/27/2026

☀️🍪 SUMMER KICK-OFF TREAT DAY! 🍫🍰

I’m set up at Kate L. Toms Fit on Erskine Ave. in Peterborough until 3:00 PM today with all the goodies!

✨ Dot Cakes
✨ Brownies
✨ Fudge
✨ Cookies

💵 Everything is just $5!

Come celebrate the start of summer and grab yourself a sweet treat (or a few 😉).

Can’t make it to the market? No problem! I’m also accepting online orders today. Send me a message to reserve your goodies, and I can deliver locally this afternoon.

Treat yourself—you deserve it! 🍪🧁☀️

Obsessed with how this KPop Demon Hunters cake turned out 💜✨Disco balls, bold purple buttercream, glitter details, and t...
05/24/2026

Obsessed with how this KPop Demon Hunters cake turned out 💜✨
Disco balls, bold purple buttercream, glitter details, and the cutest topper for Charlotte & Brianne’s celebration 🎤🪩

Definitely one of my favourite themed cakes lately — fun, girly, and full of personality!

Which detail is your favourite? 👀

Chocolate on chocolate, but make it vintage ✨This dreamy extra-tall cake was created to celebrate a very special 30th bi...
04/04/2026

Chocolate on chocolate, but make it vintage ✨

This dreamy extra-tall cake was created to celebrate a very special 30th birthday 🤎 Layers of rich chocolate, soft ruffles, and delicate brown ribbon bows come together for the perfect blend of elegance and nostalgia.

Designed with height for that luxe statement look and finished in timeless vintage-inspired details — because turning 30 deserves nothing less than beautiful, bold, and a little extra.

Happy 30th birthday! 🥂🎂

1,000 lessons later… and look how sweet that success is 💚🎉This custom cake was created to celebrate a HUGE milestone wit...
04/04/2026

1,000 lessons later… and look how sweet that success is 💚🎉

This custom cake was created to celebrate a HUGE milestone with Duolingo — 1,000 lessons completed! 🦉✨

From the bold green ombré to the signature owl and logo, every detail was designed to match the fun (and dedication!) behind the journey.

Whether you’re celebrating achievements big or small, there’s always a reason for cake 💛

DM to order your custom celebration cake!

✨ Sweet 16 with a little throwback magic ✨This birthday girl’s mom reached out with the sweetest idea… a Puss in Boots c...
03/18/2026

✨ Sweet 16 with a little throwback magic ✨

This birthday girl’s mom reached out with the sweetest idea… a Puss in Boots cake 🐱⚔️

She shared that her daughter used to love it as a kid, and wanted to surprise her by bringing that special memory into her 16th birthday. The perfect mix of nostalgia and celebration 💛

I had so much fun creating this one — from the soft watercolour finish to the delicate florals and, of course, that iconic topper. A beautiful blend of grown-up elegance and childhood joy.

Happy 16th birthday! 🥳 Thank you for letting me be part of such a meaningful surprise.

BakingJoy

Soft, sweet, and oh-so-pretty 💗This custom birthday beauty features a dreamy blush ombré finish, delicate ruffle details...
03/05/2026

Soft, sweet, and oh-so-pretty 💗

This custom birthday beauty features a dreamy blush ombré finish, delicate ruffle details, and hand-placed florals for that romantic touch. Topped with a gold acrylic “Happy Birthday” charm to make it shine just a little extra ✨

Simple. Elegant. Timeless.

Perfect for celebrating someone special 🤍

Now booking custom cakes for upcoming birthdays and events! Send me a message to reserve your date 🎂💌

PrettyInPink SupportLocal

⚽️💙 Game on! 💙⚽️Loved creating these soccer-themed birthday cakes — bold blues, touches of gold, and those little soccer...
02/23/2026

⚽️💙 Game on! 💙⚽️

Loved creating these soccer-themed birthday cakes — bold blues, touches of gold, and those little soccer ball details on top 🙌✨ The textured buttercream gives it that fun, sporty feel while still keeping it classy for the big celebration!

Perfect for your little (or big!) soccer star’s special day 🥅🎉

Now booking custom birthday cakes — themes, colours, and details made just for you!

Message to order 💌

🎂 Into the Upside Down for Bella’s sweet 16! 🖤⚡ Stranger Things–themed cake made with lots of love (and only a little De...
02/08/2026

🎂 Into the Upside Down for Bella’s sweet 16! 🖤⚡ Stranger Things–themed cake made with lots of love (and only a little Demogorgon energy). Happy 16th, Bella — hope your day was totally Strange in the best way! 🍰✨

🐒🐍🦍🦧🐅🐘🦓🦏🦛🦒🦘🦦🦥
01/31/2026

🐒🐍🦍🦧🐅🐘🦓🦏🦛🦒🦘🦦🦥

Address

3825 Ganaraska Road
Port Hope, ON
L1A1B0

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 5pm
Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 5pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 5pm
Sunday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+12892512686

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sarah Johnston's Custom Cakes posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share