Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria

Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria Home Style Bakery, Pizzeria, Lunch & Coffee Shop. We respectfully acknowledge the bakery is on the traditional territories of the Anishnawbe

TURN YOUR PASSION FOR BAKING INTO A SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS - Looking for an organic sale....
The Humble Pie is a popular, home-style bakery and pizzeria located at the south end of Lake of Bays, in beautiful downtown Baysville - perfectly positioned for travellers on route to Algonquin Park and other popular tourist destinations. Founded in 2010, by owner/operator Michelle MacIsaac, the bakery has a

loyal and dedicated following and has become part of the Muskoka cottage family tradition. We maintain strong relationships with our community, regional tourism, local businesses, the media, and our suppliers. Famous for our delicious butter tarts, we also offer a variety of fruit pies, deep dish meat pies and quiche, pastries, breads and custom made Italian inspired pizzas. The bakery partners with Ontario based and local artisans offering honey, maple syrup, coffee, and craft condiments. Maintaining consistency and quality we continue to evolve and experiment with industry trends. We are recognized for our generosity and the work we do in our community creating awareness and raising funds for local charities. During the busy summer season customers are encouraged to call in advance to place orders, which helps guarantee customer satisfaction

With the sale we will provide transitional support, all social media platforms and our renowned recipes.

NEW!! Now available at the Humble Pie, the Loaded Western Quiche! Everything you love about a toasted western plus the p...
06/06/2026

NEW!! Now available at the Humble Pie, the Loaded Western Quiche! Everything you love about a toasted western plus the perfect blend of cheddar, mozzarella & swiss 🧀
Also featured are our Mushroom Swiss and Spinach with sun-dried tomatoes and feta cheese quiche!


NOW APPEARING - Our legendary strawberry rhubarb pies!  Made fresh daily! Get yours, they're going quick!  🍓🥧           ...
05/30/2026

NOW APPEARING - Our legendary strawberry rhubarb pies!
Made fresh daily! Get yours, they're going quick! 🍓🥧

NEW! Bacon Butter Tarts! We're getting great reviews!!Don't let the road improvements stop you! Baysville is Open For Bu...
05/22/2026

NEW! Bacon Butter Tarts!
We're getting great reviews!!
Don't let the road improvements stop you!
Baysville is Open For Business!!!


Discover Muskoka Great Canadian Wilderness

The Long Weekend is on our mind, We CAN'T WAIT TO SEE YOU! Our hours this week are Wed & Thurs 10 - 4,  Fri 10 - 5, Sat ...
05/13/2026

The Long Weekend is on our mind, We CAN'T WAIT TO SEE YOU!
Our hours this week are Wed & Thurs 10 - 4, Fri 10 - 5,
Sat 9 - 5 and Sunday 10 - 2
Get your orders in, call 705-224-8278.
Please be patient as you navigate the road improvements & rest assured Baysville is Open For Business!

Great Canadian Wilderness Discover Muskoka

AND WE'RE BACK! Just in time for Mother's Day! Friday & Saturday, regular Spring hours to follow Wednesday through Satur...
05/05/2026

AND WE'RE BACK! Just in time for Mother's Day!
Friday & Saturday, regular Spring hours to follow Wednesday through Saturday's.

We'll be making Mom some special treats made with love -
Fresh Strawberry Short Cakes featuring Blueberry Lemon Buttermilk Scones, Fresh Berries & Whipped Cream, Assorted Linzer Cookies with Blueberry, Raspberry & Lemon Curd fillings, and our delicious deep-dish quiche & golden flakey croissants.

Get your orders in everything will be make fresh to order. Please call 705-224-8278.

Great Canadian Wilderness Discover Muskoka

HAPPY EASTER!I will open the bakery between 12:30 & 3 today.
04/05/2026

HAPPY EASTER!
I will open the bakery between 12:30 & 3 today.

Easter treats...
04/04/2026

Easter treats...

Good Friday - the bakery is open today 10 until 4.  We have turkey pies, Easter treats, pastries and Hot Cross Buns!  Op...
04/03/2026

Good Friday - the bakery is open today 10 until 4.
We have turkey pies, Easter treats, pastries and Hot Cross Buns!
Open Saturday 10 - 4, Closed Easter Sunday.

Bring the kiddies by the bakery after the Easter Egg Hunt for a free Easter Treat!With the Cast Iron closed for a break,...
03/31/2026

Bring the kiddies by the bakery after the Easter Egg Hunt for a free Easter Treat!

With the Cast Iron closed for a break, you can stop by the bakery before Saturday for a Colouring Sheet - 3 age categories! Or email [email protected] to request one. Bring your finished sheet to the Hunt! Good Luck!!

03/28/2026

Fresh Hot Cross Buns!! Get them while you can! Call 705-224-8278.

Address

6 Bay Street BOX 40, Baysville
Muskoka, ON
P0B1A0

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10am - 4pm
Thursday 10am - 4pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm

Telephone

+17052248278

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria:

Share

Category