Fenwick Pie Company

08/25/2026

I guess we can't have anything exciting happen without a little bad...

Majorly discounted meals available today
...

08/25/2026

Something exciting has arrived at Fenwick Pies!

One of the most asked questions we get is "do you sell ice cream?" Truthfully, pie and ice cream almost belong together, so why don't we sell ice cream??

SO! We have FINALLY listened and we are VERY excited to announce that starting tomorrow you can now purchase a pint of locally hand made ice cream right here in our shop!

We have teamed up with our good friend Simon Says who makes small batch, real ice cream with real, local ingredients!

To celebrate this collaboration, starting tomorrow when you purchase any sweet pie and a pint, receive 10% off the bundle!

Our first flavours available will be:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Salty caramel

Please note that the ice cream will ONLY be available per pint in our grab and go freezers to be enjoyed at home. We will not be offering any scoops or cones in our shop. You'll have to go find Simon at one of his events for that!

Who's excited for this addition to our shop and which flavour will you try first??

08/18/2026

08/08/2026

Sorry this one's a bit long.... 🙃

Unfortunately we have made the decision to close the shop this weekend... again.

For the past several weeks we have had a lot of changes happen around our little shop, which has been SO great, but truthfully also very exhausting!

We have been adding some new equipment and making a few upgrades and we have some exciting changes and additions to come.

But...

Today, A LOT of work got done in our store front, and everything is currently EVERYWHERE.

Because of this and honestly just because of how exhausting it has all been, we have decided to close one more weekend to get everything in place so we can come back rested and refreshed.

Thank you to all of our amazing customers who have been so patient with us through the chaos, we wouldn't be here doing all of this if it wasn't for all of you, so thank you. 💕

07/30/2026

Happy Thursday!

We wanted to give everyone a heads up that we will be closed this weekend Saturday August 1st and Sunday August 2nd.

We are getting some work done in the shop this weekend and have decided to close the shop and give everyone a long weekend.

We will be open Friday 9-6 and we WILL still be Welland Farmers’ Market Saturday 8-12.

So get your goodies today and tomorrow!!

We will re-open Wednesday August 5th.

07/25/2026

Our first peach crumble tarts of the season are here and will be available this morning at the Welland Farmers’ Market!
.. I may have eaten one for breakfast to make sure they were good enough for y'all... And It did not disappoint 🤤

We also have some peach pies and peach crumbles available in store and at the market today!

Happy peach season!! 🍑🧡

07/19/2026

Good morning friends!!!

What a BEAUTIFUL DAY!! 🌞

All cream pies and flakies are available today!

We have a bunch of discounted products today.

Open until 4pm! Come see me 🤸🏻‍♀️

07/09/2026

Did you know we make our cream pies on the spot?? 👀

That's right, if you don't see any of our cream pies in our display, just ask and we can whip one up for you in under 5 minutes!

We make our cream pie fillings in small batches and ready to be filled in our freshly baked pie crusts, that way you are getting the freshest possible cream pie!!

Flavours available daily are:
Coconut
Banana
Key lime
Lemon
Chocolate
Peanut Fudge (special order)

Please note that because we make these in small batches we do sell out of flavours sometimes, so if you are ever coming specifically for one, just give us a call to confirm we can have one ready for you!

905-892-1289

07/09/2026

We are back at the today until 2pm!

I have all the things. Except regular Long Johns, unfortunately the heat and sunshine this morning claimed those pretty fast 🫠