Maggie's Cookie Cottage

Maggie's Cookie Cottage Thank you all for supporting our small Cookie Cottage during Thanksgiving and Christmas! We sold out both holidays and are feeling extra blessed.

We're currently booking for Wedding Season 2026! We'll be back with Holiday Specials for Valentine's Day!

🇺🇸✨ 4th of July Menu Drop! ✨🇺🇸The fireworks aren't the only thing worth getting excited about this year!Pre-orders are o...
06/04/2026

🇺🇸✨ 4th of July Menu Drop! ✨🇺🇸

The fireworks aren't the only thing worth getting excited about this year!

Pre-orders are officially OPEN, and all orders must be placed by June 26th. Pickup will be ONE DAY ONLY — Friday, July 3rd so you can spend the holiday weekend making memories instead of making dessert.

⭐ **Star Shaped Sugar Cookie Tray with Dip**
Our soft sugar cookies paired with our fan-favorite Lady Lock filling dip. Sweet, buttery, and absolutely perfect for showing up to a BBQ looking like you have your life together.

⭐ **Mini Sugar Cookie & Dip Tray**
The little sister to our full-size tray. Perfect for an individual treat, a picnic snack, or a handful of little hands who swear they're "just having one."

⭐ **Cake Jars**
Making their Maggie's Cookie Cottage debut! These jars are packed with layers of classic vanilla cake and our homemade buttercream icing. Want to be trendy? Add the *viral sprinkle topping* for just $1 more.

Each jar is the equivalent of about three cupcakes, making it ideal for sharing around a bonfire with your sweetheart... or quietly eating yourself while recovering from the festivities of the night before. We don't judge either way.

As always, thank you for supporting our little cottage bakery. We can't wait to add a little extra sweetness to your Independence Day celebrations! ❤️🤍💙

Message us to place your order!

Something fun and festive is in the works for the 4th of July menu!
06/04/2026

Something fun and festive is in the works for the 4th of July menu!

We don't make cake pops but our amazing cousin does 😍 look at these beauties 🤤
06/01/2026

We don't make cake pops but our amazing cousin does 😍 look at these beauties 🤤

Festive sprinkle restock completed! I'll be dropping a menu for 4th of July pre-orders which will include our mini party...
06/01/2026

Festive sprinkle restock completed! I'll be dropping a menu for 4th of July pre-orders which will include our mini party dipping tray and individual 'cup cakes'!

These items are still up for grabs! If you're interested please message or comment to arrange pickup today so we can gua...
05/31/2026

These items are still up for grabs! If you're interested please message or comment to arrange pickup today so we can guarantee freshness 🫶

📢 🚨 EXTRA COOKIE DROP 🚨📢 Good morning cookie connoisseurs! I have 3 assorted boxes at a discounted price for grabs today...
05/30/2026

📢 🚨 EXTRA COOKIE DROP 🚨📢
Good morning cookie connoisseurs! I have 3 assorted boxes at a discounted price for grabs today. All available after noon today. Comment on the ot message to reserve you ur box and arrange porch pickup at my home in Wintersville.
Box 1 - PB Lovers Box 6 no bakes, 6 peanut butter blossoms, and 6 Buckeyes $15
Box 2 - Classic Box 6 sugar cookies and 6 snickerdoodles $10
Box 3 - Fancy Box 6 lady locks and 6 chocolate thumbprints $12

There’s something extra special about being invited to help celebrate life’s sweetest milestones. 🤍 🎓❤️ Maggie’s Cookie ...
05/30/2026

There’s something extra special about being invited to help celebrate life’s sweetest milestones. 🤍 🎓❤️

Maggie’s Cookie Cottage is so thankful to have been chosen by a friend to add a touch of sweetness to the graduation celebration for Caleb and Caylea. Congratulations to the Toronto High School Class of 2026! 🎉

We were asked to provide 12 dozen cookies of our choice, and we took that challenge seriously! We did our very best to create a spread filled with classic favorites, customer-loved treats, and enough variety to rival a small wedding dessert table.

This sweet assortment included:
🍪 Chocolate Chip Cookies
🍪 Sugar Cookies
🍪 Snickerdoodles
🥜 Peanut Butter Blossoms
🥜 Buckeyes
🍫 Chocolate Thumbprints
✨ Lady Locks
🥣 No-Bakes

Watching these trays come together reminded us just how many memories are made around a cookie table. From celebrating accomplishments to gathering with family and friends, we're honored whenever our treats become a small part of your big moments.

Congratulations, graduates! We hope your next chapter is every bit as sweet as the cookies shared in your honor. ❤️

Congratulations to Caleb, Caylea, and the entire Toronto Class of 2026! 🎓🍪✨

Stay tuned for Saturday! I am going to have some extras available for a flash sale. Great to bring to a BBQ or nibble aw...
05/28/2026

Stay tuned for Saturday! I am going to have some extras available for a flash sale. Great to bring to a BBQ or nibble away the weekend.

Address

Wintersville, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Maggie's Cookie Cottage posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category