Caleigh’s Crumb Co.

Home
Caleigh’s Crumb Co.

Formerly known as The Cottage Shoppes
Custom sugar cookies and small batch sweets
Cottage bakery in St. Marys, Ohio

06/06/2026

“Born-2-Ball” Cookies

This sporty set was SO much fun to bring to life! From textured basketballs and golf balls to classic baseballs and soccer balls, every detail was hand-piped with love!

I’m especially obsessed with how the earthy greens paired with the bold red lettering… such a fun, modern twist on a sports theme!

Happy Birthday, little one!

Custom cookie sets are perfect for birthdays, parties, and special events! Message me to get on my calendar.

30/05/2026

Radiance World Pageant Set

I am STILL obsessing over this adorable pageant inspired sugar cookie set for a close family friend that made her debut as pageant director for Radiance World!

This set included crowns, heels, makeup, lashes, and custom Radiance World logos! Some of the cookies even had edible glitter (though my camera didn’t pick it up)!

I’m SO very sorry for being MIA this week (and honestly last week too!) I have been so so SO busy in and out of the kitchen!

Once again, I have failed in the photo department, but I HAD to snap at least 1 picture of these sugar cookies before they went out the door!

As a little update- I am, once again, fully booked the next 2 weeks (seriously, THANK YOU)! My kitchen has been nonstop busy, which I am SO beyond grateful for… but it also means I haven’t had time to slow down, take pictures, and work on my launch of NYC-style cookies like I’ve been wanting to (trust me, they’re coming, just slower than anticipated)

For example, the last 2 weeks have been HUGE cookie order weeks for me, and I managed to take 1 photo of some of the cookies I baked and decorated of the literal hundreds that went out my door! 😮‍💨

A few scheduling notes:
-I will not be accepting orders July 17-21
-I will not be accepting orders July 25-August 4

Otherwise, my books are open, my oven and mixer are thrilled to see me coming, and I’m ready to take on all of these cookie orders! I have genuinely loved each and every set that I’ve sent out the door, I’m just notoriously horrible at documenting them!

If you’ve ordered from me and have loved your cookie sets, feel free to drop them in the comments below (if you have pics)! I love seeing my work being displayed through the eyes of my clients, and it truly helps my small business more than you know!

As always, thank you from the bottom of my heart for helping my dreams become a reality!

14/05/2026

Let’s be real honest here- tell me you’re a cookie decorator without telling me…

I had TWO very adorable cookie sets that I just finished up! I got them bagged, sealed, packaged, and ready to go! Then it hit me…

I. FORGOT. TO. TAKE. PICTURES… AGAIN… 😮‍💨

And of course, now that they’re bagged, a glare is working its way into my pictures and thus, are NOT up to my picture standards…

One day I’ll learn, but today is not that day 🫠

Just know, they were SO STINKING CUTE, okay?!

Instead, here they are, all boxed up, hardly recognizable, but still adorable and totally delicious!

08/05/2026

Hey friends!!

If you’ve ever ordered cookies or cupcakes from me and loved your treats, I would be SO grateful if you could take a minute to leave a review on my page!

Your feedback means everything to my small business — it helps others feel confident ordering and truly supports me more than you know!

If you’ve been happy with your order, drop a quick review sharing what you loved (flavor, design, experience, etc.)- even drop a picture of your delicious desserts!

Thank you for supporting my dream and keeping my oven busy! 💕

06/05/2026

UPDATE!

I will be dropping my New York–inspired, big, gooey, over-the-top cookie menu VERY soon and I am SO excited for you all to see what I’ve been working on!!

Over the next couple weeks, I’ll be baking up these thick, delicious cookies and getting photos ready for the official menu launch!

Right now, I am completely booked for the next 2 weeks with custom orders (seriously… wow!). I just want to say how incredibly thankful and blessed I feel to have such an amazing community supporting my small business. It truly means everything to me!

Stay tuned… because these cookies are about to be worth the wait!!

What do you think, should I start the day process of baking/offering cake pucks? Leave your thoughts in the comments below!

05/05/2026

Teacher appreciation, but make it cookies!!!

This custom set was such a fun one to bring to life! Sweet little apples, smiling daisies, chunky cookies, and all the teacher love messages to go with it. I’m obsessed with how soft and playful this color palette turned out!

Whether you’re celebrating teachers, birthdays, or anything in between, I love creating sets that feel personal and special to you.

Message me to get on my books! I’d love to make something just as cute for your next occasion, or just because!

04/05/2026

Obsessed with this sweet Mama Goose themed set!

This set included:

* Mama Goose cookies
* Goose designs
* Rattles
* Onesies
* Plaid “H”
* Personalized “Brooks” cookies

Such a soft, classic theme and perfect for celebrating a little one!

My books are open for ALL cookie themes!
Message me today to get on my calendar before I’m fully booked. I absolutely love bringing new themes to life for your special celebrations and events!

03/05/2026

There’s something extra special about being a small part of life’s meaningful moments!

This custom First Communion set was designed with soft, elegant details. Featuring delicate florals, crosses, and personalized name plaques to celebrate such a beautiful and faith-filled occasion. The touches of gold and blush bring a timeless, classic feel that makes these cookies just as memorable as the day itself.

Custom orders like this are my favorite! They’re thoughtfully created to match your vision and make your celebrations even sweeter!

If you have an upcoming event, I’d love to bring your ideas to life! Let’s create something beautiful and delicious together! IM me now to get on my books!

01/05/2026

Calling all sports lovers!

How fun are these custom sport-themed cookies?! This set includes a logo cookie, jersey, and ball! They’re perfectly personalized for your favorite athlete!

These make the cutest gifts for your sport lovin’ kids, team celebrations, end-of-season treats, or even game day surprises!

My books are open for June and July and I’m ready to bake!
Spots fill up quickly, so be sure to message me to get on my calendar!

Customization options available for teams, colors, names, and numbers, and of course- the sport!

29/04/2026

Graduation Cookie Collection is how available for orders!

Celebrate your graduate with something as special and memorable as the milestone itself!

These handcrafted cookies are the perfect blend of beauty and flavor and are ideal for gifting or elevating your graduation celebration.

Signature Offerings:
• Graduation Gift Set – $25
This 5 piece set is boxed, individually wrapped, and finished with shred! It was designed to be ready to gift.

• Custom by the Dozen – $40/dozen
Perfect for dessert tables or party favors!

Fully Customizable Colors
All designs can be tailored to match your graduate’s school colors for a cohesive, personalized look.

Flavor Selections:
• Classic Vanilla
• Cookie Nip (a snickerdoodle-inspired flavor with subtle caramel notes)

Every set is carefully crafted to be both visually stunning and irresistibly delicious, because your celebration deserves nothing less!

Planning your graduation event?
Let’s create something beautiful, customized, and totally unforgettable.

Message me to reserve your order and secure your date!

Address

314 Market Street
OH
45885

Telephone

+14193039273

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Caleigh’s Crumb Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Caleigh’s Crumb Co.:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Bakery?

Country:

City: