Erica Caldwell's Cookie Co.

Erica Caldwell's Cookie Co. My name is Erica! I fell in love with making cookies a few years ago when a friend/pastry chef walked me through the process from start to finish. Enjoy!

Since learning, I've perfected the process & put my own bit of sweetness into them. They are amazing!

Micheal Jackson cookies for a special 9 year olds birthday!LOVE these! ❤️🖤🎶
06/06/2026

Micheal Jackson cookies for a special 9 year olds birthday!
LOVE these! ❤️🖤🎶

UPDATE: Someone has said they can use them!! Very thankful they won’t go to waste and for all the messages, comments, an...
06/05/2026

UPDATE: Someone has said they can use them!! Very thankful they won’t go to waste and for all the messages, comments, and texts I’ve gotten 💕

Soooo….. 💔 I’m taking this one to heart as it’s the first time I’ve ever been told someone didn’t like the colors and/or cookies ever since I’ve been baking, which has been awhile. I don’t always get it right but I do try my absolute best to give each and every person exactly what they want. I’m sorry when I don’t make that happen. In this case the colors weren’t as light as they should have been. They were looking for more of a baby blue and baby green.

With that being said I thought I’d at least turn this into a plus and give them away to someone who could use them for either an event this weekend or as a “just because”. I can give them away all separate or all together depending on who comments. The ones with black won’t be sold as they have a child’s name on them.

Pick up would need to be today! 💙💚

Not your average graduation theme but when you graduate, you get whatever you want 🖤💕 Congrats Shawn!!!
06/04/2026

Not your average graduation theme but when you graduate, you get whatever you want 🖤💕 Congrats Shawn!!!

Congrats to another SC grad!!!! 🧡💙
06/02/2026

Congrats to another SC grad!!!! 🧡💙

Stitch Cake for Lillian’s 5th Birthday!!
06/01/2026

Stitch Cake for Lillian’s 5th Birthday!!

Cupcakes with SpongeBob theme & beautiful set up!!
06/01/2026

Cupcakes with SpongeBob theme & beautiful set up!!

12 years later….. SpongeBob cookies!!
06/01/2026

12 years later….. SpongeBob cookies!!

Happy 16th Birthday Shannon! Hope you loved your lemonade themed cookies 🍋
05/24/2026

Happy 16th Birthday Shannon!

Hope you loved your lemonade themed cookies 🍋

Cookies for a Jeffersonville graduate 👩🏼‍🎓❤️
05/24/2026

Cookies for a Jeffersonville graduate 👩🏼‍🎓❤️

I got to be a part of birthday surprise in such a fun and creative way! Got asked to make a copycat Bruno Mars ticket to...
05/19/2026

I got to be a part of birthday surprise in such a fun and creative way! Got asked to make a copycat Bruno Mars ticket to surprise their daughter with actual Bruno Mars tickets for her birthday today! Her reaction was priceless and I almost cried with her.

Address

Sellersburg, IN

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Erica Caldwell's Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category